|
A Record
of Repression In
Helvetia
Holocaust Skeptics Under Growing Attack in
Switzerland
Jürgen Graf and
Gerhard Förster are by no means the first
persons in Switzerland to be attacked or
punished for their revisionist views. They
certainly won't be the last. Indeed, it appears
that during the past year Swiss authorities have
been cracking down on dissidents with noticeably
greater severity.
In 1986 a teacher in
Lausanne, Mariette Paschoud, was dismissed from
her teaching position following a media smear
campaign because she had expressed skeptical
views on the Holocaust issue. More recently
because she had asked for a single piece of
proof for the existence of gas chambers,
Switzerland's highest court solemnly declared in
May 1995 that Paschoud disputes "the most
serious crime of the National Socialist regime,
namely the systematic gassing of Jews in gas
chambers."
In November 1986 the
Geneva police chief forbid two French
revisionista - writer and publisher Pierre
Guillaume and author Henri Roques - to hold a
news conference in the Swiss city. The two were
also banned from speaking publicly in
Switzerland for three years.
During the 1970s and
1980s, Dr. Max Wahl, a retired Swiss jurist,
came under repeated attack from pressure groups
and some of the media for his punchy nationalist
and pro-revisionist newsletter, Eidgenoss. In
October 1991, a Munich court fined him 25,200
marks (about $17,890) for the newsletter. (After
18 years of publication, he closed it down in
early 1995)
In January 1993,
Bernhard Schaub (a father of two) was fired
without notice from his position as a teacher of
history and German at a private school in Zurich
because he had expressed doubts about war-time
"gassings" of Jews in a book he had written. His
1992 history of German-speaking central Europe,
Adler und Rose, had also prompted the usual
media emears. (See Schaub's essay, "Switzerland
in the Grip of the `Traditional Enemy'," in the
July-August 1997 Journal, pp. 32-35.)
The first Swiss citizen
to be brought before a court for expresaing
revisioniat views was Arthur Vogt, an
80-year-old retired secondary school teacher.
The country's first Holocaust revisionism trial
was held on May 31, 1997, in the district court
of Meilen. A few days later, on June 3, 1997,
the court declared Vogt guilty of "racially
discriminatory propaganda and repeated racial
discrimination," and fined him 20,000 francs
(abeut $15,000). Specifically, he had broken the
law by mailing copies of Graf s "Cause of
Death° book to seven acquaintances in
Germany and had mailed out copies of a
newsletter that included Holocaust revisionist
essays he had written.
In December 1997
publisher Aldo Ferraglia, an Italian citizen,
was tried by a court in Vevey for having
distributed several revisionist titles,
including the anti-Zionist book of French
scholar Roger Garaudy, Les mythes foundateurs de
la politique israelienne. Ferraglia was
sentenced to four months imprisonment, and
ordered to pay 28,000 francs "atonement" to
three Jewish organizations, as well as to pay
court costs of 15,075 france. The court took
care to note that the country's new Anti-Racism
Law "does not prohibit opinions, but rather only
their public expression." The country's leading
daily newspaper, the Neue Zürcher Zeituug,
devoted not a single word to the Ferraglia
trial.
In Zurich the district
prosecuting attorney's office has recently asked
for an eight month prison sentence against
revisionist Andreas J. W Studer.
Gaston-Armand Amaudruz,
a retired foreign language teacher who lives in
western Switzerland, has recently been indicted
for having circulated revisionist books, and for
essays in two issues of his mimeographed
newsletter Born in 1920, Amaudruz has published
Courrier du Continent (BP 2428, 1002 Laueanne)
since 1946. It has about 500 subscribers, many
of them outside the country.
In recent weeks the
Swiss Federal Police has been struggling to
combat "racism" on the Internet. The Neue
Zürcher Zeitung reports (July 31) that the
effort has been hampered by the technical
difficulties inherent in the freewheeling
Internet system as well as by legal
uncertainties. For one thing, nearly all of the
alleged 700 "racist and right wing" Internet web
sites are outside of Switzerland, many of them
in the United States.
On August 19, 1998,
Swiss police arrested and jailed Ernst
Indelkofer, publisher of Recht + Freiheit
("Justice and Freedom"), a magazine with nearly
4,000 aubscribers that has supported freedom of
speech for revisionists. On September 18, 1997,
the Basel city criminal court handed down a fine
of 3,000 francs (as well as a three month prison
sen-tence, which was suspended) against
Indelkofer because he had included revisionist
passages in three issues of Recht + Freiheit.
After two weeks in jail, he was released on
September 2, 1998.
Among the "offending"
passages cited by the court were such banal
sentences as the following: t1 photograph of
corpses [as taken in the just-liberated
German camps] actually proves nothing about
the time it was taken, nor how it came to be
taken, or about the ethnicity [of the
victims shown]. "Similarly objectionable,
the court found, was a reference by Indelkofer
to an "alleged systematic mass extermination of
the Jews." Also offensive, the court declared,
was a mention of a North American television
broadcast that provided "revisionist
(correc-tive) information about the Auschwitz
Holocaust, and which was therefore countered by
Jewish circles."
-September
6, 1998
|