Jewish Influence in the U.S. Mass Media
In 1986 Ze'ev Chafets, an American Jew who had moved to Israel,
returned for a while to the states to do a book about the American
Jewish community; he entitled the resultant volume, Members of
the Tribe. Following an AIPAC (the powerful Israel lobbying
agency based in Washington DC) organizer who was "hunting Jews"
across America, he noted an interesting incident at a Jewish
gathering at the Stardust Motel in Moline, Illinois. Chafets writes
that a fellow Jew sitting next to him in the audience poked the
American-Israeli in the ribs, and then "tapped my copy of the
Quad-City Times ("The Midwest's Most Exciting Newspaper") and
whispered, 'This is a Jewish newspaper' ... The man was referring to
ownership, not content ... Determined to make an impression, the man
poked me again. 'See this motel?' he asked. 'It's a Jewish motel.'"
[CHAFETS, p. 39]
In 1999, the
chairman of the Newspaper Association of America was
Richard Gottlieb. He is also the chairman of Lee Enterprises,
based in Davenport, Iowa, which owns 21 newspapers and 16 TV
stations across the United States -- from Billings, Montana, to
Madison, Wisconsin, to Lincoln, Nebraska. Lloyd Schermer retired
as CEO of the company in 1999. A corporate subsidiary, NAPP
Systems, constructs printing plates for about 350 newspapers
in 30 countries. In Nebraska too, John Gottschalk is the
chairman and president of the Omaha World-Herald company.
He is also publisher of the Omaha World-Herald. [BATT,
J., 3-24-2000]
In northern California, in the heart of the internationally
important high-tech area of Silicon Valley, David Cohen controls
an area-wide empire as the Publisher/CEO of the Silicon
Valley Community Newspapers (SVCN Inc.). Cohen founded
Metro, "Silicon Valley's weekly alternative newspaper." A
SVCN subdivision is Metro Newspapers. Metro, in
turn , "purchased the Los Gatos Weekly and the more than
100-year old Los Gatos Times-Observer, which were
combined as the Los Gatos Weekly Times. In 1991, the
company acquired the weekly Saratoga News and the
Willow Glen Resident ... In 1993, Metro Newspapers
began publishing a newspaper in Cupertino, and acquired its
competitor the Cupertino Courier, in 1995. The company
founded The Sun in 1993. The most recent addition to the
community family was The Campbell Reporter, which began
publishing in March, 1999." [CUEPERTINO COURIER, 4-11-01]
In Colorado, Edward Lehman publishes a few small town
newspapers, including the Longmont Daily Times-Call, the
Loveland Daily Reporter-Herald, and Superior in
Lafayette. The executive roster for all these papers includes
Edward Lehman at the top, Dean Lehman as president, and Lauren
Lehman as vice-president. (Ruth Lehman is the Associate Editor
at the Longmont journal).
In 1975, in New
Hampshire, journalist Kevin Cash wrote an entire volume
criticizing the concentrated media and political power of
newspaperman William Loeb. Loeb owned New Hampshire's two major
newspapers -- the Manchester Union Leader and the New
Hampshire Sunday News, as well as the Vermont Sunday News,
and a few smaller New England area papers. Loeb was also in the
habit of writing regular editorials in his newspapers. "The
truth is," wrote Cash, a former reporter at the Union Leader,
"is that [Loeb's papers] are to a large extent monopolistic in
nature within the limits of New Hampshire." [CASH, K., p. 3]
Loeb was of Jewish heritage (both parents were Jewish);
he once published in one of his papers, however, his father's
1906 Episcopal baptismal document, signed by American President
Theodore Roosevelt (his father was Roosevelt's executive
secretary).
In Pittsburgh,
Paul Block (1877-1941) owned the Pittsburgh Evening Sun,
the Pittsburgh Morning Post, and the Pittsburgh
Post-Gazette, as well as the Toledo Times and
Toledo Blade. [GREENBERG, M., p. 53] His sons, William and
Paul, also later added television and cable stations to their
mini-empire. Elsewhere, "in 1978, the Samuel Horvitz Trust [run
by three sons and an employee] owned five monopoly newspapers in
Ohio and New York, cable systems in Ohio and Virginia, and
construction firms in Ohio, and was a major landowner in
Florida." [BAGDIKIAN, p. 42]
In a review of Jewish book
publishing in the United States to 1976, Jewish author Charles
Madison noted the following Jewish-founded, or purchased, firms
(some still exist, some are now defunct, some are absorbed by
others):
Simon and
Schuster (Richard L. Simon; Max L. Schuster)
Knopf
(Alfred A. Knopf)
Random
House (Bennett Cerf and Donald Klopfer)
Pantheon (founded by Kurt
and Helen Wolf)
Viking
(Harold Guinzburg)
Dover (founded in 1943)
Farrar, Strauss, and Giroux
- (The father of Roger Strauss
--
president of the publishing
company -- was in turn chairman of the
Board of the American
Smelting and Refining Company. From
1955-65
Roger was also chairman of the board of American
Judaism magazine).
Grove Press (1947) - which
controlled Evergreen Books and the
Evergreen Review.
Praeger (1950)
Basic Books (1952) - Its
founder, Arthur Rosenthal, later became
Director of Harvard
University Press.
The Free Press (1947) - Its
founder, Jeremiah Kaplan, joined Crowell-
Collier, which had acquired MacMillan, as a Vice-President.
Atheneum (1959)
Crown Publishers (1936) (headed
in later years by Nat Wartels, "a legend in the
business") [KRANTZ, J., 2000, p. 250]
Academic Press
International Universities Press
Twayne Publishers (1948)
World Publishing Company
(1905)
Frederick Ungar (1941)
Harry Abrams (1950) - mostly
art books.
George Braziller (1955)
Tudor - mostly music books.
[MADISON, CHARLE, 1976]
"One year," says famous Jewish novelist Judith Krantz in
her autobiography, "when I came back from Paris, I foolishly
risked a certain jail sentence by bringing for, buttoned into my blouse, a copy of the
utterly pornographic Rosy Crucifixion by Henry Miller, an erotic
masterpiece that Jeremy rented out to his friends as twenty-five cents a day. I'm not
taking all the credit,
but eventually he [Jeremy Tarcher] became the first
and best publisher of
New Age books in the United States." [KRANTZ, J., 2000, p.
147]
[Krantz notes that her novel Mistral "was quickly bought
for France by Edition Stock, whose publisher, Jean Rosenthal, as
it happened had translated my other novels into
French."] [KRANTZ, J., 2000, p. 313]
In a
continuing trajectory of percentage of ownership, by 1968 Roger
Kahn noted that "Jews own perhaps half the major book publishing
houses: Random House, Simon & Schuster, New
American Library, Alfred Knopf, and Atheneum
are a few that thrive under the leadership of Jews." [KAHN, R.,
p. 5] "Owners of new [early to mid-20th century publishing]
concerns, "notes Jay Gertzman, "most of them young Jewish men
(Horace Liveright, Thomas Seltzer, Ben Huebsch, Max Schuster,
Alfred Knopf) had begun to specialize in presenting European
writers to an American audience curious about their sexual
frankness and Marxist ideas. Established houses, such as Doran,
Houghton, Appleton, and Doubleday, did not do so, and some of
their executives resented their parvenu colleagues. Modernist
writers especially owed their exposure to Jewish firms."
[GERTZMAN, J., 2000, p. 114]
In the 1980s,
Crown Books, headed by Robert Haft (who also founded the
Trak Auto supply chain), rose to become the third largest
bookstore chain with nearly 250 outlets throughout America. At
its peak the firm was a national giant with nearly 10,000
employees and valued between $500 million to $1 billion (the
company drastically weakened with in-house, intra-family legal
feuds between Robert and his father Herbert, a Jewish immigrant
from Russia). The Brentano's bookstore chain was also
founded by Jewish entrepreneur August Brentano in the late 19th
century. Abraham Rosenbach and his
brother Philip were used book sellers from 1903 until the 1950s.
In 1928, the New Yorker called Abraham "the most famous
dealer in rare books." "If Gutenberg [Bible] sales are taken as
the measure of a dealer," says Guy Lesser, "Rosenbach would have
to be reckoned history's most successful [book dealer], judiging
by his transactions over ... four decades." [LESSER, G., JAN
2002, p. 48, 46] "Whiskey, cigars, deep-sea fishing, and women
(to put the last politely)," adds Lesser, "in roughtly that
order, after books, seem to have been his passions." [LESSER,
G., JAN 2002, p. 48]
Jewish
publishers also brought out the inexpensive series for mass
appeal, including the Little Leather Library, the
Little Blue Books, and the Modern Library (Horace
Liveright); Jewish entrepreneurs also initiated the "Book-of-the-Month
Club." "As an author and editor, [Mortimer] Adler built a
publishing empire on an unlikely foundation: the philosophic
system of Artistotle and St. Thomas Aquinas. That system
influnenced his work as compiler of the Great Books of the
Western World and as editor of Encyclopedia Britannica."
[D'Alessio, F., 6-29-01] In 2001, Michael Ross, the publisher of
the World Book Dictionary, removed the verb "jew" (traditionally
meaning "beat down in price") from the volume. [LEVINE, S.,
JUNE/JULY 2001]
Other Jewish book publishers include Westview,
Stein and Day, Holmes and Meier, Price Stern
Sloan, Lyle Stuart (the founder, Lyle Stuart, was
born Lionel Simon), Ottenheimer (a Baltimore publisher
with 200 titles a year), and Schocken.
In England, Lord George Weidenfeld not only
controls a well-known namesake publishing house, he is also
chairman of the Zionist Federation of Great Britain. From
England, Andre Deutsch's namesake company published
Norman Mailer, V.S. Naipaul, Arthur Schlessinger, and other
prominent authors. In Canada, Avie Bennett is president of
McClelland & Stewart (1992).
By the late
1990s, Golden Books Family Entertainment, "the nation's
largest producer of children's books," was headed by Jewish
publisher Richard Snyder (who replaced Richard Bernstein). The
next four top executives at the firm were also Jewish: Steven
Grossman, James Cohen, Ira Gomberg, and Ian Reich. [HOOVER, p.
255]
Alfred Lilienthal, a Jew and
lifelong crusader against Zionism and Jewish chauvinism, wrote
in 1982 that
"All the
leading magazines, ranging from Commentary, Esquire,
Ladies
Home Journal, New
York Review of Books, New Yorker, and U.S.
News and World Report have
Jews in key positions as publishers,
editors, or
managing editors. No one is able to
criticize Jews -- or
even take Israel to task -- for fear
of being out of line with the boss ...
There is [also] the constant
overriding concern of the media about losing
advertising
... at times making a mockery of
'freedom' of the press ...
[LILIENTHAL, p. 219] ... It would be
futile to list the number of top
Jewish editors and writers across
the country. Many of the largest
book publishers, including Knopf,
Random House, Holt, Liverwright,
Viking Press, Simon and
Schuster, Van Nostrand Reinhold, and
Lyle Stuart are Jewish-owned,
directly or by Jewish-controlled
interests
(including CBS, RCA, Music Corporation of
America
[MCA], Litton's, and
Gulf and Western. In other firms such as
Macmillan and Grosset and
Dunlap, one will find editors-in-chief or
presidents who are Jewish."
[LILIENTHAL, p. 220]
In the same
year, Jewish literary agent Bill Adler (formerly the Executive
Editor at Playboy when Mike Cohn was Director of
Playboy's book division) wrote a volume entitled Inside
Publishing. Some of the (Jewish) power people in his New
York publishing world included
* Richard Snyder: CEO, president and
Chairman of the Board of
Simon & Schuster
* Joni Evans:
(Snyder's wife), president of Simon & Schuster
subsidiary,
The Linden Press
* Robert
Gottleib: President and Editor-in-Chief of Alfred A. Knopf
* Louis Wolfe:
President and CEO of Bantam Books
* Marc Jaffe: Editor-in-Chief of
Bantam Books
* Hillel Black:
Editor-in-Chief at William Morrow
* Nat Wartels:
Chairman of Crown Publishers
* Jonathan
Segal: Editor-in-Chief of Times Books
* Helen Meyer: President of Dell
Publishing)
* Phyllis Grann:
Publisher of G.P. Putnam's Sons
* Jim Silberman:
President of Summit Books
* Howard
Kaminsky: President and Publisher of Warner Books
[ADLER, B., 1982]
Adler's
favored choice for assignment as writing "collaborator" with
celebrities was Mickey Herskowitz. Herskowitz wrote books for
Bette Davis, Dan Rather, Gene Autry, Jimmy the Greek, and
others. In the "book packaging" field (where literary agents
produce anthology-type volumes commissioned by publishers) Lyle
Kenyon Engel was "one of the most prolific book packagers over
the years." [ADLER, B., 1982, p. 89]
Jewish actor Kirk Douglas has written some books
about his life; he notes his surprise when he discovered that
"my editor Ushi was becoming fascinated with Judaism [she
eventually converted to it]. Out of the blue, in the fall of
1993, she announced that she was going to Israel. A
whole month in Israel would cost her a mere $950 plane fare,
food and lodging included. Could that be true? Oh yes, but she
was doing it through an organization called Volunteers for
Israel, which basically meant she was going into the Israeli
Army for three weeks." [DOUGLAS, K., 1997, p. 125]
"Any roll
call of the most respected and/or powerful figures in the
publishing world," wrote Robert C. Christopher in 1989 in a book
about the decline of WASP institutions," whether in editorial or
executive positions, has to include a sizeable number of Jews;
among those who automatically come to mind are Robert Bernstein,
Jason Epstein, and Joni Evans at Random House, Richard
Snyder and Michael Korda [also author of Power: How to Get It
and Success!] at Simon and Schuster, Simon Michael
Bessie at Harper and Row, Howard Kaminsky at Hearst
and Marc Jaffe at Houghton Mifflin." [CHRISTOPHER, p.
222] "I don't want to sound
chauvinistic," said Jason Epstein in 2001, "but [Jewish
publishers] were smarter than their gentile colleagues." [GREEN,
D., 5-31-01]
Others Jews in
positions of power in earlier years (as noted by Martin
Greenberg in 1979) included the publisher of Collier's
and the Women's Home Companion, founder and editor of the
National Guardian, the editor and founder of AB
Bookman's Weekly, the editor of the Saturday Review,
senior editors at Time, Forbes and Newsweek,
the editor of Variety, a member of the Board of Editors
for Fortune, the editor-in-chief of Redbook and on
and on. [GREENBERG, 1979]
More recently,
take, for example, a 1996 report in Advertising Age that
noted that Ellen Levine, the editor-in-chief of Good
Housekeeping, was having a spat with her publisher, Alan
Waxenberg, and that Jerry Kaplan was one of those being
considered to replace him. [KELLY, p. 47] In 1994, Barbara
Grossman left Simon and Shuster to become the publisher
at Viking where Peter Mayer was the Viking Penguin
CEO. In the same era, Joni Evans (born Joni Goldfinger) became
the head of the Turtle Bay imprint at Random House.
Tina Brown, also Jewish, was described by one London newspaper
as "the most famous woman editor in the world ... [She is] the
worst social climber since Kong lumbered to the top of the
Empire State Building." [LANGTON, J.]
In England, in
1998 the (London) Daily Telegraph noted Gail Reubuck,
"daughter of affluent Baltic Jewish immigrants," as "the most
powerful figure in British publishing," and "recently voted
Publisher of the Year." [CAMPBELL, p. D4] Another example is
Richard Malina who started out as a lawyer for Grosset and
Dunlap. By 1985 he was the President of the publishing
division of Doubleday; in 1987 he became the Executive
Director and Publisher of the Jewish Publication Society.
[GODFREY, p. 2]
A mere random
look at a few 1998 issues of Publishers Weekly evidenced
the following items: Al Silverman retired as "Editor-at-large"
at Penguin. He was also the former publisher and
editor-at-large at Viking, and chairman and CEO of the
Book of the Month Club. Mark Lieberman was the
Executive Vice President of Cahner's Publishing Company,
which publishes Publishers Weekly where Sybil Steinberg
was the Senior Editor for Fiction. Jane Friedman was the
CEO and president of HarperCollins. Martha Levin was
named the new Vice President and editor-in-chief at Hyperion
(moving over from a position as Senior Vice President at
Doubleday. Lucianne Goldberg was noted as the literary agent
for Linda Tripp (who exposed the President Clinton-Monica
Lewinsky sex scandal. Goldberg -- formerly Steinberger -- is the
wife of Sid Goldberg, former editor of the North American
Newspaper Alliance, and later vice president of United
Media, a syndicator of news stories. One of Lucianne's own
novels is Madame Cleo's Girls, a "frothy tale about three
high-class prostitutes.' [HUBBARD, p. 111])
The Bantam Doubleday Dell International CEO in
1998 was Stephen Rubin. The president and editor-in-chief of
Summit Books was still Jim Silberman. Marc Jaffe was
publisher of his own imprint at Houghton Mifflin. Others
afforded news making mention in the Publishers Weekly
issues were Jonathan Karp, an editor at Random House,
Esther Newberg, an agent at ICM; and agents Daniel
Greenberg and Al Zuckerman of James Levine Communications.
The Horowitz-Rae book manufacturing company was also
noted as sold.
Such Jewish
prominence today is all over the map. Michael Hoffman is the
Executive Director of Aperture, probably the most
influential "art" photography journal and book publisher.
Michael Hirschorn is editor of Spin, "the bible of
alternative music." Alan Light is Editor-in-Chief of Vibe
magazine. George Hirsch is the vice-president and publisher of
Runner's World. Nat Lehrman was the publisher of
Playboy. (Richard Rosenzweig was Playboy founder Hugh
Hefner's personal Executive Assistant, Bobbi Arnstein his
personal secretary, and Howard Shapiro his chief legal counsel.
By the 1990s, Shapiro was third in command of the Playboy
empire, behind only Hefner and his daughter). Peter Bart is
Editor-in-Chief at Variety. Michael Solomon was named
editor of Premiere in 2000. Lesley Seymour is the editor
of Redbook. Merle Ginsberg is the Entertainment Editor
for Women's Wear Daily. David Bauer is one of the
Executive Editors at Sports Illustrated. David Fine is
SI's photography editor. Todd Gold recently left the editorship
of People magazine to found a company with fellow Jew
Adam Werbach, recently stepped down as the president of the
Sierra Club.
Milton Esterow
is the publisher and editor of both ArtNews and
Antiques World. He is also co-editor and founder of the
American Art Journal. Jonathan
Steinberg -- son of notorious corporate raider Saul Steinberg --
publishes Individual Investor magazine. Steven Brill
founded American Lawyer and a media watchdog journal
called Brill's Content (editor-in-chief: David Kuhn,
formerly executive editor of Talk magazine), and the
Court TV program on television. (A rival, Peoples' Court,
features presiding Jewish judge Jerry Sheindlen and commentating
attorney Harry Levin. Another court TV program, Judge Judy,
features Jerry Sheindlin's wife, Judy, at the helm.) For years
Jerry Finkelstein published the New York Law Journal.
Janice Kaplan is the Executive Producer of TV Guide
Television. Jane Goldman is the Executive Editor of
California Lawyer. Rae Anne Marsh is the managing editor of
Arizona Corridors Magazine. Steven
Cohn edits the Media Industry Newsletter. Rachel Newman
edits Country Living. David Klinghoffer is the literary
editor of the National Review. Debbie Rosenberg is the
Managing Editor of Biography. Robert Epstein is the
Editor-in-Chief of Psychology Today. Adam Garfinkle is
the Executive Editor of the National Interest. Michael
Berman co-founded George magazine. Baltimore's Style
magazine is owned by the Baltimore Jewish Times.
Michael Gewanda became the editor of Time
(Australia) in 1993. Peter Newman edited Canada's prominent
weekly magazine, Maclean's. Peter Eisenman was "the
father of two architectural publications of note, Oppositions
and Skyline." [ARONSON, S., 1983, p. 303] And on and on
and on.
"White and
Jewish," Ben Burns (originally Bernstein) even "made a career in
black journalism, editing the Chicago Defender and
helping found Ebony magazine." [GROSSMAN, p. C1]
He also edited Sepia, "a white-owned magazine for
blacks." [ZALLER, p. 30] A more recent
black-based magazine is the musical "hip-hop" The Source;
by the mid-1990s it boasted a newsstand circulation larger than
Rolling Stone. The Source "speaks to young black
males," noted USA Today, "in a language they can
understand. More than 60% of its readers are African-Americans.
Over 80% are under age 25." Featuring "shock covers" and
articles like the one about bulletproof vest clothing fashions
to ward off "a 44 magnum at close range," the publisher of
The Source, Peter Mays, is also Jewish. [HOROVITZ, p. 1B] In
1998, Elinor Ruth Tatum became the publisher of her father's
newspaper, the Amsterdam News, New York City's oldest and
largest African-American newspaper. Ms. Tatum's father is Black;
her mother is Jewish. [JET, p. 32]
The Detroit
News is both published and edited by Marc Silverman. Howard
Kleinberg was, until recently, the editor of the Miami News.
Martin Baron edits the Boston Globe. Phil Bronstein is
the executive editor of the San Francisco Examiner and
the second Jewish husband of non-Jewish actress Sharon Stone
(his father was a former director of the Los Angeles Jewish
Federation). (Michael de Young, also Jewish, founded the rival
San Francisco Chronicle). Jeff Cohen became the Houston
Chronicle chief editor in 2002. Tom Rosenstiel is the director
of the Project for Excellence in Journalism. ABC's Peggy
Wehmeyer, a self-described Protestant, born of a Jewish mother,
is "the only network correspondent specializing in religious and
spiritual issues." [SHISTER, G., 9-11-99, p. G2] At least half
of the ten members (Jonathan Alter, Howard Fineman, Michael
Isikoff, Debra Rosenberg, and Ron Haviv) of Newsweek's
"political team" covering the 2000 American presidential
campaign were of Jewish heritage. [NEWSWEEK, 11-20-2000, p. 4]
And if you want to write regularly for editor Steve Wasserman's
Los Angeles Times Book Review, and you're not Jewish, the
odds are heavily against you. His stable of "Contributing
Writers" is Anthony Day, Michael Frank, Jonathan Kirsch,
Jonathan Levi, Suzie Linfield, Suzanne Mantell, and Benjamin
Schwarz. Politically conservative commentator David Horowitz
would argue that you'd have to be left-wing too, noting that:
"I knew Wasserman as a former
Berkeley radical and protege, in
the 1960s, of a
Times contributing editor, Bob Scheer ... After the
1960s, Scheer had ingratiated himself
with Hollywood's bolsheviks,
married a top
editor at the Los Angeles Times, and become a figure
of influence in the paper's
hierarchy, which enabled him to secure
Wasserman his job." [HOROWITZ, D.,
1999, p. 189]
Longtime media
critic for the Los Angeles Times has been Howard
Rosenberg. In a 1991 column he wrote that
"The mail is coming in about my
column endorsing KCET's recent
presentation of the controversial
film 'Stop the Church,' and nearly
all of it is critical and angry. Most
writers accused me of being
rather a fence sitter and biased
against Catholicism. Some note that
I am Jewish." [ROSENBERG, H.,
9-16-91, p. F1]
The
Washington Post media reporter is another Jewish Howard,
this one Kurtz. Until his death in 1997, across the continent,
Herb Caen was for fifty years a "legendary San Francisco
columnist" and the city's "most beloved institution." [SCHEER,
R., 2-4-97, p. B7; DOUGAN, M., 2-7-97, p. A1] Looking back into
earlier years, Dennis McDougal singles out (Jewish columnists)
Joyce Haber (of the Los Angeles Times) and Irv Kupcinet
(of the Chicago Sun-Times) as prominent media loyal
public supporters/defenders of Hollywood lawyer/mobster Sidney
Korshak. [MCDOUGAL, p. 396]
In 2000, journalist Katherine Ross
wrote about the case of fellow journalist Lynn Hirschberg:
"She is the premier chronicler of the entertainment elite
for
the New York
Times Magazine ... On the beat for almost 20
years, Hirschberg stands at the nexus
of the Los Angeles
entertainment and New York publishing
worlds ... Hirschberg's
pieces almost always deify or
demonize. 'She can make your
career,' says publicist Bumble Ward."
[ROSMAN, K., 5-2000]
Hirschberg
started out with help from David Rosenthal, "then the assistant
manager at Rolling Stone and now the publisher of Simon
and Schuster's adult-trade division." "Hirschberg," adds
reporter Ross,
"doesn't just profile and befriend
the powerful. Like most other
successful operators, she is savvy at
facilitating business deals
for friends that will leave those
friends in her debt. In 1993, for
example,
Hirschberg brokered a Time magazine cover story about
her then close friend, the producer
Scott Rudin, written by her
friend Philip Weiss ... [Also]
consider her close alliance with
Peter Kaplan,
the editor of the New York Observer, a weekly
newspaper popular in New York's media
circles. Kaplan and
Hirschberg have never worked
together, but their friendship
has benefited both." [ROSMAN, K.,
5-2000]
All these people are Jewish.
Does all this
massive Jewish predominance in the mass media,
internationally, and their collective sense of destiny
in history; upper echelon cliques; widespread allegiance to
Israel; intense sense of collective community; concerted
economic and ideological pressures to encourage
pro-Israel/Jewish views; the systematic political pressures and
omnipresent lobbying maneuvers of the Anti-Defamation League,
the American Israel Political Action Committee, the American
Jewish Congress, the American Jewish Committee; and many other
multi-million dollar lobbying groups whose fundamental purpose
is to control information about Jews and Israel, mean
nothing, as so many Jews insist? Let us take but one
aspect of the systematic censorship throughout American culture
by the Jewish community: the state of Israel. This is what Paul
Findley, for twenty-three years a United States Congressman from
Illinois had to say about his book that described the
Jewish-American lobby for Israel in America, They Dare to
Speak Out: People and Institutions Confront Israel's Lobby
(the book was eventually published by a small publisher,
Lawrence Hill, and made the Washington Post's ten top
books list for nine weeks):
"My quest for a publisher began in
March 1983 and was predictably
long and frustrating. Declining to
represent me, New York literary agent
Alexander Wylie forecast with
prophetic vision that no major United
States publisher would accept my
book. He wrote, 'It's a sad state of
affairs.' Bruce Lee of William
Morrow and Company called my
manuscript ‘outstanding,’ but his
company concluded that publishing it
'would cause trouble in the house
and outside' and decided against
'taking the heat.' Robert Loomis of
Random House called it an
'important book' but reported that
the firm's leadership decided the
theme was 'too sensitive.' Twenty
other publishers said no." [FINDLEY,
THEY, p. viii]
When in 1986
Israeli defector Mordechai Vanunu had his photographic evidence
of the inside of Israel's nuclear weapons plant published in
England, it should have been a major news story. Jerry Oplinger,
a former White House aide, was amazed at how little attention
the mass media gave it, saying: "I couldn't believe those guys.
There was nothing [significant] in the [New York] Times,
[Washington] Post, and Wall Street Journal.
Everybody in the arms control business was amazed that there was
nothing. To me and my close friends, it was really
discouraging." [HERSH, p. 308]
In the London
Independent, in 1998 Robert Fisk wrote an entire article
about the mass media's systematic bias and censorship of stories
relating to Israel. Among the Fisk's list of outrages, is the
fact that
"the New
York Times ... ran a syndicated account from an Israeli
paper
of an Israeli soldier's life in
Qana before the massacre [when Israeli
troops fired a missile into an Arab
ambulance in Lebanon]: but the New
York Times deleted a
paragraph about how the Israeli troops had stolen
cars from their Lebanese owners and
looted houses -- thus even
censoring the Israeli press ...
History continues to be short-changed in
the American media ... Academics
may one day decide how deeply the
American public has been misled by
the persistent bias of the US media,
and the degree to which this has
led them to support US policies which
may destroy America's prestige in
the Middle East." [FISK, p. 14]
Norman
Finkelstein, a well-known Jewish critic of Israel, tabulated the
articles about torture in the Middle East in the New York
Times between 1981 and 1991. He found over 80 articles -- 26
articles about torture in Iran, 15 in Turkey, 14 in Iraq and 8
in Egypt. "Consider how the case of Israel was treated," he
wrote,
"Except for a brief period under
[Israeli] Prime Minister Begin,
torture was practiced continuously
from the early 1970s against
Palestinian
detainees ... [The Times] has probably devoted as much
space to coverage of Israel [on
other matters] as the entire Arab
world combined. Yet for the full
decade under consideration
(1981-91), the Times found space for
only five items on Israeli
torture of
Palestinian detainees ... Not once did the Times even
hint
at the not trivial fact that
Israel's torture of Palestinian detainees in
the Occupied Territories is
'virtually institutionalized' (Amnesty
International)
and 'systematic and routine' (B'Tselem)."
[an Israeli
human rights organization]
[FINKELSTEIN, 1996, p. 67]
In 1982 the
Times' Foreign Correspondent to Israel, Thomas Friedman
(also Jewish) ran into trouble with his Jewish superiors for
telling the truth about the Israeli invasion of Lebanon.
Friedman filed a report with his employers about the
"indiscriminate" bombing of the Arab community there. New
York Times editors censored the adjective. Friedman "then
sat down and wrote one of the most indicting messages the
Times ever received from a correspondent, that his editors
were 'afraid to tell our readers' about Israel's 'apparent aim
of terrorizing its [Beirut] civilian population ... I am filled
with profound sadness by what I have learned in the past
afternoon about my newspaper.'" [GOULDEN, p. 323] Friedman was
immediately called back to the states and warned that "if you
ever pull a stunt like that again, you are fired. Understand?"
[GOULDEN, p. 323]
In 1994, the
Jerusalem Post noted another case of Jewish
lobbying-censorship of the American mass media, this time of the
work of Time magazine reporter Murray Gart:
"Time
was planning to publish a list of Israeli agents in Washington
submitted by the Mossad to the CIA.
[Howard] Teicher's name [a Jewish
National
Security Agency adviser] was purportedly on the list. Time
never ran the story, the editors
pulled it out of the magazine virtually
at the last minute." [RODAN, S.,
1994, p. 18]
Thomas Kiernan notes the case of non-Jewish mogul Rupert
Murdoch, so beholding to the Jews who helped him get a foothold
in the world of international mass media:
"[ABC head Leonard] Goldenson's personality and lectures
thus had the effect of
sharpening Murdoch's sympathy toward Israel. As a result,
his Australian papers
took a decidedly pro-Israel tone during the early 1960s --
a fact that didn't please
his surrogates in the top editorial chairs. The eventual
resignation of Douglas Brass
as editor for the Sydney Mirror, for instance, is
said by some in Murdoch's organization
to have come about over that issue ..." [KIERNAN, T., 1986,
p. 78]
In a discussion of the reportage at Murdoch's New York
Post, Kiernan observes
"I was witness to some of th Post's coverage of the Israeli
invasion of Lebanon
in the summer of 1982 and of the subsequent siege of
Bierut. Throughout that
period, the paper was without a single reporter on the
scene, yet its stories were
laced with unattributed
'eye-witness' descrptions of Arab atrocities and Israeli
heroics, many of them invented in its New York newsroom."
[KIERNAN, T.,
1986, p. 262]
In May 2001, during the latest Palestinian intifada
(uprising) against Israeli rule, the Anti-Defamation League
announced that their recent survey showed that "56 percent of
major newspaper editorials took a strong pro-Israel stance."
[TEITELBAUM, S., 5-25-01] This was despite the fact that
representatives of organizations as diverse as Amnesty
International, the European Union, the Red Cross, and YMCA were
criticizing, and often condemning, the brutal policies of the
Israeli state. Incredibly, even as most of those who headed
press organizations were emphatically pro-Israel, Howard Goller,
chairman of the Foreign Press Association, publicly complained
that "twenty foreign correspondents in the West Bank and Gaza
have been shot at and hit [by Israeli troops] with live
ammunition or rubber coated-bullets since the start of the
intifada ... Worse still, he says, the Israeli government is
refusing to deal with the matter." [HAUSMAN, T., 5-25-01]
Michael Shermer and Alex Grobman
note the case of British author David Irving, who faced the
destruction of his decades-old writing career when he started
addressing the Jewish community critically:
"After Irving testified for the
defense in ["Holocaust denier" Ernest]
Zundel's 1988 'free speech' trial in
Canada, various governments filed
notices of entry denial and
deportation against him. As he recounts
on his Web page, his publishing firm,
Focal Point, has received
notices from the bookstores in
England canceling distribution of
[his book]
Hitler's Wars and other titles. 'Following complaints from
valued customers we no longer feel
able to stock this title,' read one
notice from a Sheffield bookstore in
July 1992. Also in the same year,
the director of Media House
Publications in Johannesburg, South
Africa,
informed Irving that with regard to Hitler's War, "I
don't
want any copies on our premises. We
have had some incidents
already. Many of our book buyers are
Jewish. It is much easier
for [my staff] now to say, 'We don't
stock the book.'" [SHERMER/
GROBMAN, 2000, p. 50]
Filmmaker Tom
Hayes calls the mass media's wall of censorship surrounding the
state of Israel "the Information Blockade." This systematic
censorship is important in keeping Americans ignorant about the
truths concerning Israel, including the details of the
staggering sums of money -- approximately $78 billion --
American taxpayers have funneled to that other country (instead
of to themselves) since the creation of the Jewish state in
1948, [APAS, p. 106] let alone the myriad of moral injustices
perpetuated upon others by the Jewish nation. [See later
chapter] Arthur Hays-Sulzberger, the
publisher of the New York Times, noted the
behind-the-scenes economic intrigues and mass media power of
pro-Israel Jews as early as 1946:
"I dislike the coercive methods of
Zionists in this country who have not
hesitated to use economic means to
silence persons who have different
views." [LILIENTHAL, p. 124]
Those who would like to criticize
Israel, notes Jewish French scholar Maxime Rodinson, "remain
silent, either because they are not in a position to write or
speak publicly, or because they fear the reactions of their
immediate environment or the broader public. I understand them
very well. Moreover, publishers, newspaper editors, and radio
and television producers, also tend to be afraid to let them
speak; they suffer constant blackmail from Judeo-centrists."
[RODINSON, p. 15]
Ze'ev Chafets
notes a 1979 article that got past the censors in Newsweek;
it read:
"With the help of American Jews in
and out of government, Mossad
[Israel's intelligence agency]
looks for any softening in U.S. support
and tries to get technical
intelligence the Administration is unwilling to
give to Israel."
The normal
chorus of Jewish complaint and pressure to censor any similar
future statement was soon to follow. As Chafets observes, "the
editor of Newsweek later admitted that Newsweek's
insinuation that American Jews are disloyal to the United States
'reflects an anti-Semitic stereotype' and informed the
Anti-Defamation League that 'we have engaged in some
consciousness raising on this subject and I do not expect a
recurrence.' The letter to the ADL was signed by the magazine's
editor-in-chief: Lester Bernstein [also Jewish]." [CHAFETS, p.
281]
Also in the
1970s, CBS news commentator Jeffrey St. John made a
similar mistake about speaking openly of Jewish dual loyalty on
the radio program "Spectrum." He had the courage to observe that
"American public opinion is shaped
largely by a pro-Israeli viewpoint.
And when
someone suggests we should begin changing our policy,
as an American oil executive did
recently, the pro-Israel propaganda
machine is America crucifies him in
public ... Emotions, not reason,
govern our policy towards Israel ...
The issue is whether you are
an American first and a Jew second
and if forced to choose, which
commands your loyalty first."
[LILIENTHAL, 1983, p. 450]
St. John was
gone from CBS soon afterwards. Likewise, CBS
newscaster Eric Severeid took heavy Jewish lobbying heat in 1975
for daring to say that "A growing number of American Jews are
... torn in a soul-searching internal debate as to just where
their loyalties should lie and how far they should go in
honoring them." [LILIENTHAL, 1983, p. 449]
In 1994 after
rejections from numerous publishers, John Sack, a respected
Jewish journalist for Esquire and other magazines for
nearly 40 years, managed to get his manuscript (An Eye for an
Eye, about the "vengeful" Jewish heads of post-World War II
concentration camps for Germans and Poles) published by Basic
Books. (The book was originally commissioned with a $25,000
advance by the Henry Holt publishing company. When Sack's final
manuscript was completed, it was abandoned by the firm). "Major
U.S. newspapers and publishers," noted the Associated Press,
"shied away from the manuscript before Basic Books finally put
out the English edition in 1993." [BAJACK, INTERNET]
The editor for the volume at Basic Books, Steve Fraser,
noted that
"We concluded it ought not to be
suppressed -- which is what was
happening. I take my vocation as a
publisher seriously enough to feel
that it is my responsibility to
publish something that's important even
if the rest of
the industry is afraid to do that." [WIENER, p. 24]
Terry
McDonnell, one of Sack's editors at Esquire, was one of
those refusing to publish any of the investigators articles
about the Jewish commandants of concentration camps. "[Other
publishers are] scared," he told Sack. "And I'm scared too."
[LOMBARDI, p. 18]
Sack had
researched the facts of the volume for seven years. "Although
Sack's facts were not disputed," notes the Associated Press,
"the book was slammed as sadistic sensationalism in a review by
powerful German [Jewish] critic Elke Geisel, whose seething
polemic called it 'vile docudrama' and 'a gift to neo-Nazis.'"
"[Sack's book] is the greatest filth," added Ralph
Giordano, a German Jewish writer who never read the book in
question, " ... [it is a] vulgar artistic fetish."
[AP, INTERNET] (Press censorship about Jewish history
even occurs in Poland, presumably because the new capitalist
state must seek so much western/Jewish economic aid in
rebuilding their nation. In 1994 the
Gazeta Wyboroza, one of Poland's most-widely read
newspapers, covered an investigation of fifteen former officers
of the Office of State Security [Poland's communist secret
police]. "The paper is avoiding any mention of Jews," notes
Jewish journalist Carol Oppenheim. "I think there is widespread
opinion of the dominance of Jews in the Communist Party," said
Michael Cichy, the cultural editor of the paper, "but mention of
this in the Polish press is taboo." [OPPENHEIM, p. 39]
In response to
Jewish outrage that such truthful information be published, the
new head (Viktor Niemann) of the publishing house that printed
Sack's book in German, R. Piper, decided to destroy all 6,000
copies in its warehouses. "It was the fourth time," notes the
Associated Press, "that Sack's story ... had been bought by
a publisher who subsequently decided against printing." [BAJACK,
INTERNET] "It is tragic," wrote Sack in response to his German
publisher's actions, "that 'An Eye for an Eye' is not
being published in Germany now and that Germans have nowhere to
learn the truth." [SACK, p. A18]
When the TV
news show 60 Minutes investigated one of the Jewish
subjects of Sack's book, Shlomo Morel, Sack's broader story
"looked as if it might take off," said Carol Oppenheim, "and it
sent shock waves through the Jewish community."
"A feature by '60 Minutes' that backed up Sack
seemed to promise major attention and at least minor
bestsellerdom," noted the Washington Post, "but the rest
of the media either attacked or ignored the book. The general
tenor was summoned up in Miami Jewish Week: "Do me a
favor -- don't read this book." [STREITFIELD, p. D4]
In 1994, John
Lombardi wrote a disturbing article for New York magazine
about the Sack story and the massive censorship surrounding it.
Lombardi called his piece "The Book They Dare Not Review: An
Inconvenient Holocaust Story." Lombardi formerly worked at
Advance Publication's GQ magazine, the periodical
that had initially paid Sack $20,000 to research and write about
the Jewish concentration camp overseers, only -- after the
article had been typeset -- to quietly kill it.
The most
venomous attack on Sack's book came from the New Republic
(owned by avidly pro-Israel publisher Martin Peretz). Sack wrote
a point by point rebuttal to their review, but the magazine
refused to publish any of it in their Letters to the Editor
section. "But," noted the Nation, "the magazine made the
remarkable decision to sell him ad space to run it ($525 for
five column inches). The ad was typeset, but the magazine then
chose to reject it." [WIENER, p. 287]
Leon Wieseltier, the Jewish literary editor of the New
Republic, was even quoted as saying, "I'm not embarrassed to
say that as part of my job of policing the culture, I felt that
the sooner we stopped this book, the better.... It's one of the
stupidest books I ever read, and I frankly resolved to do as
much damage as I could." [LOMBARDI, p 18] Elan Steinberg,
spokeswoman for the World Jewish Congress impugned the veracity
of Sack's dozens of interviews with Jewish (and other)
eyewitnesses to Jewish-created atrocities, saying: "You cannot
rely on witnesses ... [because] you're insulting the memory of 6
million [Jewish Holocaust] martyrs." [LOMBARD, p. 18]
In 1997, the
United States Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington DC
suddenly cancelled a lecture by Sack about his book and his
findings therein. "The invitation to give your lecture was
issued without my knowledge," wrote Director Walter Reich to the
Eye for an Eye author, "Having had the opportunity to
examine the matter, I have determined that holding the
presentation would not be compatible with the Museum's
programs." [STREITFIELD, p. D1] In turn,
Sack decided to rent (for $301) a room at the nearby National
Press Club to discuss his book and the censorship around it.
There is no record in the major national computer research
database of America's newspapers that Sack's press conference
was ever reported upon.
"It would be
tempting to simply dismiss this painful book as the work of an
anti-Semitic crackpot, as many have," wrote Jewish author Carol
Oppenheim, "The New York Times, the Washington Post,
and Time have ignored An Eye for An Eye [i.e., not
reviewed it]. But John Sack is a noted journalist with some
forty years experience. His work on the Vietnam War is studied
in college classes. And he is also a Jew." [OPPENHEIM, p. 39]
And what are we
to make of the case of Victor Ostrovsky, former Mossad agent and
author of 1990's By Way of Deception, an expose of the
international workings of the Israeli Mossad organization?
Although Israel managed to briefly, and literally, ban
his book in America through the American courts, the censorship
was soon lifted. [See earlier discussion] "We will get to him by
other means, we will break him economically," the head of the
Mossad, Israel's CIA, then told the Israeli media. "I'm now
convinced," wrote Ostrovsky in 1997, "that I am the target of a
broad collusion between elements of the Israel government and
their gofers, mostly in the American Jewish community ... My
second book was ignored ... A speaker's bureau in Toronto, which
seldom had trouble arranging speaking engagements with student
and other groups eager to have me as a speaker, found that the
engagements were cancelled before I could appear." [OSTROVSKY,
1997]
When Ostrovsky appeared on Canadian
national television, Yosef Lapid, the former chief of Israeli
television, declared on the same show, via satellite from the
Jewish state, that Ostrovsky's assassination by the Mossad could
cause diplomatic problems now that he lived in Canada, but "I
hope that there would be a decent Jew in Canada who would do the
job for us."
Ostrovsky was
later stunned that no North American media outcry rose against
this call for his assassination on live public television.
(Recall, in contradistinction, the mass media outcry against
Iran's death sentence on author Salmon Rushdie. Iran, of course,
is a declared arch-enemy of Zionism. And what, one wonders,
would happen to a former president of CBS who called for
murder?) But Lapid? Nothing. A reporter from USA Today
interviewed Ostrovsky about Lapid's public threat and planned to
write a story about it, but, "while I was still in his office,"
laments Ostrovsky, "his editor told him
by telephone to kill the article." "The same people," wrote the
former Mossad agent, "who presumably would praise someone from
the CIA or the U.S. armed forces who exposed serious wrongdoing
in those institutions were now hard at work to smother my
criticisms of an intelligence agency for a foreign country that,
to put it as charitably as possible, does not have America's
best interests at heart."
Eventually he
sought to sue the man who called for the call to kill him, but
Ostrovsky's lawyer soon bailed out, explaining "that the safety
of his staff would clearly be jeopardized if he proceeded." Soon
thereafter, Ostrovsky had financial problems with both his
publishers, HarperCollins and, in Canada, Stoddart.
His agent suddenly refused to return his calls and in due time
his "house burned to the ground. The fire marshal's report
declared it arson." In 1997, Washington publisher Regnery
backed out of a plan to publish his next book, already listed in
its upcoming books catalogue. "It suddenly occurred to me,"
Ostrovsky wrote,
"for the first time, that the forces
of racism, bigotry and apartheid
may win, even here in North America.
In calling out, finally, for help,
I suddenly fear that I man only be
shouting into the wind. To all who
believe that 'it can't happen here,'
I say beware. It is immensely
satisfying to take a stand and speak
out against coercion and tyranny.
But ... although your friends
cherish you, they may choose to do it
from a distance." [OSTROVSKY, V.,
1997, p. 37, 84-85]
In another
case of covert censorship, in 1996 the London Sunday
Telegraph took note of an unusual article by American Jewish
journalist Philip Weiss:
"A studied silence has greeted the
cover story in the normally
scrupulously
liberal New York magazine which claims that Jews
in America wield so much power and
influence that they need no
longer fear the shadow of
anti-Semitism. The magazine refuses to
discuss the article, as apparently
does the author, Philip Weiss ...
The weekly must have known it was
inviting trouble. Even the cover
seemed a calculated risk: a
photograph of the American flag with
some of its stars replaced by the
Star of David. American magazines
rarely confront the issue of Jewish
influence so directly.... Richard
Goldstein, a
columnist for the Village Voice, has already remarked
that the fact Jews have achieved so
much influence despite the anti-
Semitic views of many Americans is
'less a paradox than a timebomb.'
The irony, of course, is that the
issue is one that has been privately
discussed among Jews for decades."
[LANGTON, p. 24]
In another
censorial case, 1989 BBC reporter Alan Hart complained that
United States publishers were afraid to publish his
less-than-condemning book about PLO leader Yassar Arafat because
they "privately feared a backlash from supporters of Israel."
The volume, Arafat: A Political Biography, had already
appeared in three editions in Great Britain -- first published
five years earlier. Over 40 American publishers had passed on
publishing Hart's work until Indiana University Press decided to
do it. In a formal statement, the university publisher remarked
that it was "not unaware that some form of self-censorship might
have been the cause" for the lack of American publisher
interest. [ABRAMS, G., 6-19-89, p. 5, 1]
In 1996 the
Christian Science Monitor noted the attack upon a famous
Catholic cleric in France, headlining its article: "Cleric's
Comments Ignite the Fury of French media." The origin of this
controversy stems from a book by Roger Garaudy: The Founding
Myths of Israeli Politics. Garaudy, as noted earlier, wrote
this volume that criticized Israel, Zionism, and the Holocaust
as Judeo-centric propaganda; it has been effectively banned in
France. The author, an 82-year old former Resistance fighter
against the Nazis, was also once a Communist member of the
French parliament (expelled from the party in 1970 for
criticizing the Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia) and later a
convert to Islam. He was fined $20,000 by a French court for
writing his book, which, declared the court, "questions all
Jews, not only Israelis ... Far from merely criticizing Zionism
... Roger Garaudy embarked on a virulent and systematic
questioning of crimes against humanity against the Jewish
community." [ROSENBERG, C., 2-27-98]
The
Christian Science Monitor noted that Garaudy's book was
available in only one bookstore in Paris, and it was not
possible to even order the work in many of the others. The
Monitor also noted that most of the critics of the book have
not read it and that "Garaudy's book does not deny that millions
of Jews were murdered by the Nazis." "A
"prominent jurist," Francois Terre, called the 1990 Gayssot Law
(that "makes it a criminal offense to challenge the facts of the
Holocaust") totalitarian: It was "a law that kills historical
research and dishonors France ... Even politicians who oppose
the law have been reluctant to speak out against it." [CHADDOCK,
G., 7-25-96, p. 5]
The Catholic
cleric Abbe Pierre fell into the controversy surrounding the
book soon after. Pierre, noted the Washington Post, was
"France's most admired man ... For five decades [he] ranked
consistently at the top of the popularity polls in France for
his defense of the downtrodden. As a champion of street people
and a former activist in the anti-Nazi resistance, Abbe Pierre
commanded universal respect and unrivaled media coverage."
[RANDALL, J., p. 7-3-96, p. A27] Pierre's activities in the
French underground also included smuggling Jews to safety. He is
the founder the Emmaus foundation, 350 centers around the world
for the homeless and poor.
The cleric's
problems began when he publicly came out in support of Garaudy.
Knowing the author for fifty years, Pierre attested to his
integrity. "I think the average Frenchman," said Pierre, "will
say with relief the taboo [about how the Holocaust may be
examined] is over. You will no longer be called anti-Jewish or
anti-Semitic for saying a Jew sings out of tune." [RANDALL, J.,
7-3-96, p. A27] Unfortunately for Abbe
Pierre, however, not understanding the power of such forces
against such an open comment, this was a gross miscalculation.
The 83-year old
cleric was barraged with critical attack from all sides -- from
the French media, civil rights groups, and eventually -- seeking
to assuage vociferous Jewish complaint -- the Church itself.
France's chief rabbi called Pierre's words those of an
anti-Semite. The president of the Jewish Consistory of France
declared that: "[Abbe's] continuous support of Roger Garaudy is
unacceptable." [PHILLIPS, I., 5-39-96, p. 13] Under an avalanche
of criticism, Pierre took refuge in a monastery in Italy. For a
while the old cleric continued to defend his position, digging
himself deeper into controversy, noting that Jewish suffering
was only part of the calamity of World War II. He also "said
that according to the Bible, the Jews committed a genocide
comparable with the Shoah when they entered Palestine 12 or 11
centuries before Christ." Addressing Zionism, he called it "a
world conspiracy," that it was "based in the United States with
world ramifications," and he implored people to have "the
honesty to look at the truth." Zionism,
said the cleric, "want[s] the empire promised to Abraham. And
this movement is plotting worldwide for that." [AGENCE FRANCE
PRESSE, 6-17-96] [See later chapters for discussions of Zionism]
The attacks
upon Frances national "saint," suddenly fallen, continued.
Months later a British newspaper noted that "it is clear that
the debate left him traumatized. His conversation [now] is
scattered with references to his friendship, help towards, and
empathy, with the Jews." [FINANCIAL TIMES, 6-21-97]
The Washington Post's reporter Jonathan Randall
ended his report on Pierre with a suggestion of senility in the
old man. Quoting Charles DeGaulle, Randall concluded his piece,
saying: "Old age is a shipwreck." [RANDALL, J., p. 7-3-96, p.
A27]
Overwhelmed
by the attacks against him, Pierre finally publicly surrendered.
"The attacks of which I have been targeted have been beyond all
measure," he said. "I have greatly suffered." [PHILLIPS, I.,
5-30-96, p. 13] He announced that "I have
decided to retract my statement, and to bow entirely to the sole
opinion of the experts of the Church," also adding that his
comments had been "exploited by elements who dangerously toy
with the anti-Semitic, neo-fascist, and neo-Nazi currents that I
have fought and will always fight against." [ASSOCIATED PRESS,
7-23-96]
A controversy of a somewhat related
vein occurred in Montreal, Canada, a year before the Abbe Pierre
story. A prominent Canadian Jewish lawyer, Julius Grey, faced an
avalanche of Jewish condemnation and outrage when he freely
noted in a lecture at John Abbott College that "I think the
Holocaust and anti-Semitism is being used by some elements and
Israel and the Jewish community to keep people in the fold. What
is happening is a fake alarmist mentality, because there is
effectively no anti-Semitism in North America ... [Modern
teaching about the Holocaust] is turning it into a political
incident. Each ethnic group creates its own martyrology, that
we're good and kind and we've been mistreated." [CHERNEY,
4-25-95]
Response to
Grey's comments was overwhelming in the Jewish community. Mike
Cohn of the Canadian Jewish Congress told a reporter that "in
the many years I've been at the congress, I don't remember
getting this many phone calls from irate members of the
community." [CHERNEY, 4-26-95] In the flurry of subsequent
editorials about the controversy, one non-Jewish commentator
noted that "the effect of the reaction to Grey's remarks could
be to intimidate, to stifle open debate, to chill free
expression. For after seeing what happened to Grey, others may
think twice about expressing unconventional opinions and ideas."
[MACPHERSON, D. p. B3] The original (Montreal) Gazette
reporter who reported the Grey story later wondered in a later
article about "the rush to discredit and silence Julius Grey ...
[Does] a writer need ... a special license to deal with the
Holocaust, or a lawyer need to get permission from the
community's institutions to talk about it ... Could that ...
silence dissent?" [CHERNEY, E., 4-29-95, p. B6]
Elsewhere, in the more personal
realm, when Tom Bower sought to publish his unauthorized and
highly critical biography of Robert Maxwell, the British Jewish
media baron invoked litigation involving at least twelve
lawyers, a number of accountants, and two private detectives in
researching Bower's background. Failing in the courts to stop
the book, Maxwell's army of censors intimidated -- by economic
threats and intimidating legal innuendoes -- much of England's
publishing world. Wholesale book distributors and most British
bookshops knuckled under to Maxwell's power, and didn't carry
the book. The mogul even bought a paperback company that held
the rights to Bower's pending volume in order to effectively
censor it. [BOWER, p. ix-x]
In 1997, in a
story about Jewish South African mogul Sol Kerzner, the New
York Times noted that:
"In an early test of press freedom
under South Africa's new
constitution, a well-known
international casino magnate has
delayed the publication of a book
about him and is trying to
ban it.
The book, 'Kerzner Unauthorized' ... profiles Sol Kerzner
[who] made his fortune operating
[casinos] under apartheid in
south Africa's black
‘homeland’.... [He] has threatened to sue
local newspapers if they excerpted
it. As a result, a major Sunday
newspaper withheld publication of
an excerpt from the book."
[MCNEIL, p. A3]
The author
of the Kerzner volume, Allan Greenblo, is credible; he is
himself the CEO of two major South African publications -- the
Business Day and the Financial Mail. (Perhaps he
himself is Jewish?)
Jewish author
Steven Weinberg (author of Armand Hammer: The Untold Story)
was even sued by corrupt Jewish mogul Armand Hammer. "After
The Untold Story was published in England, Armand filed the
most expensive libel action in British history, suing Weinberg
on 157 counts of defamation." [BLUMAY, C., 1992, p. 449]
In 1988, yet
another Jewish business mogul family (Canada's Reichmanns, at
the time owners of the largest real estate empire on earth)
sought to censor the truth about their past.
The (Montreal) Gazette notes that:
"These are dangerous waters for any
journalist. In 1988, Toronto Life
magazine was hit with a $102
million libel suit for publishing an article
by freelance writer Elaine Dewar
which investigates [patriarch] Samuel
Reichmann's murky past as an egg
dealer in pre-war Austria and then
as a currency
speculator in wartime Tangiers. Toronto Life's eventual
apology and out-of-court settlement
suggested that 'libel chill' can be
an effective deterrent for any
wealthy family seeking to keep a curtain
of privacy around itself."
[HADEKEL, p. I]
In the same realm, as microcosm for
the whole problem of censorship and self-censorship in the mass
media world, in reviewing Jewish Hollywood mogul Michael Ovitz
at the peak of his power, Robert Slater noted that
"As the most powerful person in
[Hollywood], Ovitz had the power,
if he chose, to use it in order to
punish any critic who went public by
denying him or her all access to his
stable of stars. The mere possibility
that he exact such punishment was
enough to silence his critics ... No
Ovitz critic was willing to speak
out either on or off the record."
[SLATER, p. 202]
In August 1992,
John H. Richardson, a senior writer at Premiere magazine
in Los Angeles, finished a story about Jewish madam Heidi Fleiss
and her drug and prostitution ring in the Hollywood community.
The entertainment magazine, dependent upon cooperation with the
movie world for its very existence, decided against publishing
the piece. The Entertainment Weekly also developed an
article about the story, but threats of legal action from
attorneys for Columbia executive Michael Nathanson killed
the story. The Hollywood Reporter also had an article
about Fleiss too; this too was aborted when Nathanson threatened
to "destroy [each reporter's] reputation" if the story was
published. [KENNEDY, D., 8-20-93]
Reporter Dan
Moldea experienced a similar situation when he dared to write an
expose (published in 1986) about mogul Lew Wasserman at MCA.
Moldea who has written about crime for over twenty years
(including books about the murder of Bobby Kennedy, the
Teamsters Union, and corruption in professional sports), noted
that "Writing Dark Victory [about Wasserman] was the only
time I ever really feared for my career. I felt raw power coming
at me like a rifle shot." [MCDOUGAL, p. x] "Moldea," notes
Dennis McDougal, "maintains that he was followed and his phone
lines tapped during the year he worked on the book. He is
certain that Lew Wasserman targeted him for harassment."
[MCDOUGAL, p. x]
Los Angeles Times reporter
Bill Knoedelseder also faced blatant censorship when he tried to
write about the Wasserman-MCA-Mafia world, which extended
to powerful influences in the Reagan White House (Wasserman was
Reagan's Hollywood agent). The reporter, notes Dennis McDougal,
"changed his mind about his
newspaper's independence.... Somewhere
in plusher,
upper reaches of the Times, beyond the hard scrabble
cubicles of the newsroom, Lew was
enjoying lunch with the newspaper's
executives ...
Knoedelseder's stories about MCA and the derailed Mob
probe [at Los Angeles City Hall]
began to get rejected regularly by his
editors. He was instructed to switch
interests and write about something
other than
MCA for a change. Before the year was out, stories about
MCA and the Mob ceased to
appear in the paper at all, and Bill
Knoedelseder
quit his job at the Times." [MCDOUGAL, p. 468]
In 2000, Los
Angeles Times reporter, Kim Murphy, a 17-year veteran
newswoman, wrote some articles about the community of "Holocaust
Deniers" and alleged right wing political groups that led to
many Jews "accusing the Times of legitimizing the views
of anti-Semites." The first article addressed controversial
British historian David Irving who had attempted to, in effect,
sue the international Jewish lobby that had destroyed his
writing career. Murphy's attempts at objectivity rankled a lot
of Jews and the reporter soon found herself under fire. "The
story outraged members of the Los Angeles Jewish community,"
notes Eric Umansky, "The controversy even found its way into the
Times newsroom." At close quarters, fellow Los Angeles
Times reporter Alan Abramson, of course Jewish, decried
Murphy's work, as did another Jewish newsman, David Lauter, the
Times religion reporter, who said, "Kim is a very good
reporter. But I think she screwed up on this particular
subject." The Times' executive editor, Leo Wolinsky, also
Jewish, "signed off on Murphy's second story after asking her to
quote more sources critical of Irving." Murphy publicly defended
herself, insisting that
"The Holocaust was horrible, "[but]
it's my profound belief that
there are no questions that can't be
asked. This is an issue of
political correctness. There are just
certain things you are not
allowed to say, even in this
country." [UMANSKY, E., 9-2000]
During the era
of the 1980s Savings and Loan scandals across America, Wall
Street Journal reporter Charles McCoy was set to run an
article about the Federal Home Loan Bank Board's questionable
decision to allow J. Livingston Kosberg's First Texas
Savings and Loan (fourth largest in Texas) to acquire
Gibraltar Savings (the state's largest S&L whose principal
investor was Saul Steinberg). Connected to the deal was yet
another influential Jewish entrepreneur, Robert Strauss, former
chairman of the Democratic National Party and head of the Jimmy
Carter campaign against Ronald Reagan. Reporter Martin Meyer
notes that
"In my presence [Strauss] chewed
reporter McCoy out on the telephone
for a quarter of an hour, informing
him that he (Strauss) was close to
Warren Phillips
[also Jewish], CEO of Dow Jones, and thus McCoy's
employer, and Strauss would have his
ass if there was stuff in the story
of which Strauss disapproved ... [So]
McCoy wrote carefully, and you
had to know what the numbers [in his
story] implied to know what the
story said."
[MEYER, M., p. 14]
"The deal
shouldn't have been approved at all...," remarks Meyer, "First
Texas was a sinking ship, losing money on its lending
operations ... [But] with Strauss on one side and [Jewish junk
bond manipulator Michael] Milken on the other, the Bank Board
was completely surrounded by political influence ... First
Gibraltar's star board member was [also] Strauss' son,
Richard (who was further blessed in Dallas by his aunt, the
mayor)." [MEYER, M., p. 13-14]
In 1992, director/actor Woody Allen
faced public embarrassment when actress Mia Farrow (who had a
common law relationship with him for many years; she was also
once married to Jewish conductor Andre Previn) accused Allen of
having an affair with one of their teenage adopted daughters,
and that he had repeatedly sexually molested another daughter, a
young child. Criminal charges, however, were another story.
Allen conceded, and defended, his sexual relationship with the
older daughter but denied any other incidents with others. Paul
Williams, the New York Child Welfare worker on the case, noted
that
"based [on the child's] demeanor and
her responses to my questions,
and my conversations with the
caseworker in Connecticut, and
my experiences from interviewing
hundreds of children who have
been abused, I concluded that abuse
did occur and that there was
a prima
facie cause to commence family-court proceedings against
Woody Allen. Then the barriers came
down. There came a litany of
reasons why we should not go forward.
My superior said that Woody
Allen is 'an influential person,' she
talked about his films, and his
'position.' As more evidence came
through interviews, I insisted that
the case should have been filed.
Managers at the Child Welfare Agency
responded that 'pressure [to drop the
case] is coming all the way from
the mayor's office [Jewish mayor: Ed
Koch]." [FARROW, p. 311]
The case was dropped. A child
custody trial featured Allen represented by six different law
firms. [FARROW, p. 316] Later, the Connecticut state attorney,
Frank Maco, announced that "probable cause" for Allen's arrest
existed, but that by then Farrow had decided a public trial
would be extremely detrimental to the abused child. [FARROW, p.
329]
In 1997 Peter
Watson's sensational expose of the systemic corruption within
the Sotheby art auction house (headed by Jewish real estate
mogul Alfred Taubman) "sparked scandalous headlines on both
sides of the Atlantic when it was released in Britain." [NY
POST, 2-2-98] "Now that [the book] has finally arrived [in
America]," noted the New York Post, "the press doesn't
seem to be showing much interest. So far, only the weekly New
York Observer has reviewed it -- and even that is going
Sotheby's way." [NY POST, 2-2-98] The
American publisher of the book, Random House (owned by
Jewish mogul Si Newhouse) backed its publication up three times
and revised part of the European version. The Post
suggested that "Sotheby is getting kid glove treatment thanks to
Alfred Taubman getting a favor from Random House owner Si
Newhouse -- an avid collector known to spend millions at
auctions." [NEW YORK POST, 2-2-98, p. 12]
In 1999, independent journalist and
art critic Hector Feliciano found himself facing a $1.8 million
lawsuit at the hands of the (Jewish) Wildenstein family (Daniel,
Alec, and Guy). Feliciano had dared to write about the family's
clandestine art dealings with the Nazis during Hitler's looting
of Jewish-owned art treasures. "They're suing me," said
Feliciano, "so that other journalists will think twice about
writing about them." [GOLDBERG, J. J., 6-18-99, p. 14]
Dissident ("self-hating") Jews too
are not immune from enforced censorship about public criticism
of their community. British reporters Christopher Reed and
Eleanor Mills note a well known case in Hollywood:
"An example of Tinseltown shyness
about criticism of Jews is Budd
Schulberg's
book What Makes Sammy Run? Now 82, he wrote the
classic about a ruthlessly ambitious
Hollywood type called Sammy Glick,
in 1941. Five attempts to film it
have failed. After reading the book,
MGM studio chief Louis Mayer said
Schulberg should be deported.
It was pointed out that the author
was not only born in America, he
was the son of the head of
Paramount." [He was also Jewish] [REED, p.
2]
"The charge of anti-Semitism was laid on
the book," notes the Los Angeles Times, "although
Schulberg pointed out that all of Sammy's victims were Jewish
too ... These days, Schulberg fears that What Makes Sammy Run?
has become what he calls 'a handbook for yuppies.'
'It's a new handle on Sammy," Schulberg says, "Sammy's
credo of success at all costs and it doesn't matter how you get
there makes the book seem not truly merely entertaining but a
Bible of sorts." [CHAMPLIN, p. F1] (Along
the same censorial lines, in 1963, Jewish cinema verite
documentary filmmaker Albert Maysles' unforgiving film about
Hollywood producer Joe Levine evoked such anger in the Hollywood
community that "members of the Oscar screening society
reportedly found 'Showman' so anti-Semitic that they watched
only five minutes before walking out." [JEW JR LA, 1-16-98, p.
26] (Levine, notes Thomas Hoving, "earned his
millions by buying nonentities such as the Italian Hercules
films starring Steve Reeves and Godzilla, the
Japanese monster movie, and hyping them shamelessly." [HOVING,
T., 1993, p. 396]
Jewish singer Eddie Fisher recalls wanting to play
the lead acting role in What Makes Sammy Run? "I had
several meetings with Lew Wasserman, then the president of MCA,"
Fisher says,
"the talent agency that represented me. I wanted to play the
lead, an aggressive
producer named Sammy Glick, maybe the ultimate Jewish
hustler. I knew a lot of
real Sammy Glicks and I felt confident that was a character
I could play.
Wasserman decided Sammy Glick was 'too Jewish, too
negative.' He hated the
concept and did not want the picture made. I think he
decided it was bad for
the Jews." [FISHER, E., 1999, p. 90]
Angry reaction
by the Jewish community to members of their own depicting such
Jewish "success stories" is not uncommon. The (Montreal)
Gazette noted Mordechai Richler as one of Canada's best
known writers, but
"caustic,
controversial, and often crude ... [Richler's novel] Dudley
Kravitz
remains the best-selling of Richler's
works. A comic extravaganza of a
coming-of-age novel, it tells the
story of a 'scheming little bastard,' a
coarse, driven, young Jew determined
to make something of himself at
any cost. A critical success both in
Canada and beyond, the book
inspired a raging controversy and
denunciation by the Jewish community
that Richler [who is Jewish] was an
anti-Semite." NAVES, p. 12
In the movie
making world, in 1996 actor Arnold Schwarzenegger learned a bit
about Jewish censorial power when he dared to consider to make a
film about a real life character, a Nazi captain named Osterman
who refused to kill a group of British prisoners during World
War II. His interest came in the wake of Jewish director Steven
Spielberg's colossal hit Schindlers List, where a Nazi
saves Jews. Scheduled to begin shooting in ten
weeks, the director of Schwarzenegger's project backed out of
the film. "Other directors," noted the London Sunday Times,
"have privately admitted they are avoiding a film that might
offend the powerful Jewish lobby in Hollywood ... According to
Hollywood reports, Joel Schumacher, who is directing the latest
Batman film, offered Schwarzenegger a short word of advice about
making the film, 'Don't.'" [HARLOW]
In 1999, in an
overtly censorial and revisionist move, the British ITV
television company announced that it was sweetening the
unpleasant Jewish "Fagin" character in their new filming of
Charles Dickens' classic novel Oliver Twist. In the new version
too, he would not be Jewish. "We don't want a Fagin that is a
Shylock character," said the ITV Director of Programming,
David Liddiment. "This decision," noted critic Rhoda Koenig,
"exemplifies not only a lack of understanding of our literary
heritage, but a contempt for the past itself. It is also an
example of the sentimentality, arrogance, and cowardice that are
now passed off as 'sensitivity' and 'responsibility' ... Why
have we become so illiterate, so phony, and so craven? "
[KOENIG, 7-7-99, pl. 13] Dr. David Parker, curator of the
Dickens House Museum in London, responded, saying: "This
softening of Fagin is done to political correctness. Literary
stereotypes, however objectionable, should not be lightly cast
aside." [HELLEN, 1-17-99]
In 1997 the
mainstream Jewish Thought Police struggled to censor (and
failing that, at least marginalize) a book by a Jewish author,
Norman Finkelstein. Finkelstein, described in the (Jewish)
Forward as "a notorious ideological opponent of the state of
Israel," a man who characterized a more favored -- and
best-selling -- Jewish author as a "Zionist propagandist who
distorted evidence in order to legitimate the existence of the
state of Israel." [MAHLER, p. C1] Hearing that Finkelstein's
book, A Nation on Trial, was set to be published by the
Henry Holt publishing firm, "the literary editor of the
New Republic, Leon Wieseltier, was so startled by the
news that he put in a call to Michael Naumann [also Jewish], an
old friend and the publisher of Holt, assured that
[Naumann] could not be familiar with Mr. Finkelstein's work."
[MAHLER, p. C1] The Anti-Defamation
League was among those who publicly rallied against the
publication of the "anti-Zionist and anti-Israel" work. "There
seems no question," noted the Forward, "that the book is
something of a hot potato. An esteemed historian who initially
agreed to write the prologue to the book, Istvan Deak, a
professor of Central European history at Columbia University,
suddenly changed his mind." [MAHLER, p. C1]
In the violent
criminal underworld, vengeful censorship actions can be more
draconian. Jewish journalist Robert Friedman was forced to go
into hiding in 1998 when authorities informed him that Russian
Jewish mobster Seimon Mogilevich (described by the Village
Voice as "the World's Most Dangerous Gangster") was
overheard contracting for Friedman's murder because of the
journalist's expose about him.
Various forms
of censorship by the powerful -- usually by economic blackmail
and intimidation -- is not uncommon in the mass media world,
creating an environment of people worried about their careers
and fear of their bosses, thereby becoming overly protective of
Jews/Israel from criticism. Even leaving aside, for example, the
issues at stake in the simple fact that the vast Newhouse media
empire -- like so many others -- is Jewish-owned (a subject
whose political implications publishers are certainly forbidden
to address), any criticism of the Newhouse
organization is smothered because of its omnipresent economic
clout, media interconnectedness, and long arm of vengeance. Even
in the academic world. Take the case of the Columbia
Journalism Review and its Jewish editor, Suzanne Levine, who
in 1992 wanted to find a writer willing to address the many
negative changes affecting the New Yorker magazine after
the Newhouses took it over. Thomas Maier notes that:
"Levine went through numerous
contacts until she found an out-of-state
editor willing to accept the
assignment. 'Why me?' asked the editor, Eric
Utne, who runs his own alternative
magazine. 'You're the perfect person
to do it,'
the Columbia Journalism Review told him. When Utne
pressed
for the real reason, he was told
flatly, 'Because no one else will touch
it.'" [MAIER, p. 347]
In 1998, a
small publisher, Seven Stories Press, published an "unauthorized
biography" of the Newhouse family. A reviewer in the New York
Times Book Review noted that "Citizen Newhouse was initially
signed with Viking, but new management there took the
unusual step of canceling the book when it was done -- a
decision itself that was the subject of news articles and gossip
columns. [Author] Felsenthal said that once she turned in the
manuscript, Phyllis Grann, president of Penguin Putnam, Inc.,
parent of Viking, told her she couldn't publish it
because too many people mentioned in it were friends."
[GOLDSTEIN, T., p. 17]
And what -- away from the
mass-produced popular press -- of Jewish dominance of the more
"high-brow" reading? The most widely-read American "intellectual
periodicals," remarks W. D. Rubenstein,
"are either Jewish or contain a disproportionately Jewish
input." [RUBENSTEIN, p. 64] His list is
five journals long: Commentary,
The Public Interest, the New York Review of Books,
the Partisan Review, and the New Republic.
Commentary is a house-organ
publication of the American Jewish Committee (Jewish editors
Elliot Cohen and then Norman Podhoretz),
"Commentary," wrote Richard Curtiss in 1998, "... has
been around so long that probably few Americans even recognize
it as the Israel lobby's principal national publication."
[CURTISS, p. 9] In a 1990s survey of "3,000 prominent Americans"
Commentary was ranked third behind the New England
Journal of Medicine and Foreign Affairs among "most
influential" print and electronic media. It was ahead of the
New York Times, Washington Post, and Wall
Street Journal. [TWERSKY, p. 40] "Many Commentary
authors," says David Twersky, "have gone on to serve in
government as a result, in large measure, of being read by the
right people at the right time." [TWERSKY, p. 41] Such Gentile
authors have included Jeanne Kirkpatrick and Daniel Moynihan (Commentary
is well known for its "neoconservative" flavor).
"[Editor Norman]
Podhoretz's struggle with his Jewishness," notes Twersky, "is
central to the evolution of Commentary ... [It] came to
be defined by the desire of Jewish intellectuals to create a
space for modernism without discarding their Jewishness."
[TWERSKY, p. 43] Yet, according to editor Murray Polner of a
second American Jewish Committee-published journal, Present
Tense, (1973-1990), this second publication was founded
"because Commentary wasn't Jewish enough."
[TWERSKY, p. 58] Former non-Jewish journalist Scott McConnell
notes the unpleasant experience he had when (years after his
employment at Commentary) he bumpted into Podhoretz at a
dinner party:
"Norman was standing across a round table from me, looking
older and frailer (and
thus in a way sweeter). When I approached him, hand
extended, his distaste in
putting forth his own was palpable. 'I always liked you
Scott. But you wrote an
anti-Israel piece, and I'm very ideological on that
subject' ... To be charged with writing
an 'anti-Israel' column is no small thing -- it has been
known to get people fired ...
The U.S. gains nothing for its own reputation or interests
by backing Israeli
policies that are unjust to the Palestinians, reviled
throughout the Arab world and
opposed by most of the world's governments. In political
Washington (as at some
Hamptons dinner parties), life may go more smoothly if one
doesn't do or say
anything that irritates right-wing Zionists. As my
encounter with Norman reminded
me, the consequences of speaking out sincerely can be quite
unsettling. But it|
it is still the right thing to do." [MCCONNELL, S., v.14,
ISSUE 30]
The "New York
Intellectuals [a group of influential social and political
critics and theorists, whom Podhoretz calls "The Family"]," says
David Twersky, were "a group made up largely (though not
exclusively) of Jews ... writing in Partisan Review, and
later Commentary and Dissent...., [they] helped
fashion post-war American attitudes toward literature, culture,
art and politics." [TWERSKY, p. 40] The Jewish author Irving
Howe (himself benighted as one of "The Family") wrote in 1968
that
"they have a fondness for
ideological speculation; they write literary
criticism with a strong social
emphasis; they revel in polemic; they
strive self-consciously to be
'brilliant;' and by birth -- or osmosis --
they are Jews." [TWERSKY, p.
40-41]
In a symposium
in Commentary magazine in 1966, notes Arnold Eisen, "all
the participants except the Reconstructionists and Rabbi Jacob
Agus affirmed that Jews were God's Chosen People, and did so in
the traditional terms of revelation, covenant, messiah, and
exile, rather than by citing the Jewish contribution to
civilization or explaining that, in fact, it was Jews who had
chosen God ... Significantly, Commentary did not ask asks
respondents whether the Jews were the Chosen People but
in what sense they had been chosen." [EISEN, p. 149]
The second of
Rubinstein's "most widely read" intellectual journals is
Public Interest, founded by Jewish conservatives Irving
Kristol and Daniel Bell in 1973. The
third, The New York Review of Books, wrote Dennis Prager
in 1980, "is still edited by Robert B. Silvers and Barbara
Epstein ... most of its political writers were Jews, and its
tone, in the words of Irving Howe ... was a 'snappish crude
anti-Americanism." Within a decade it was
the "most influential magazine" among America's 275,000
academics. [KOSTELANETZ, p. 69]
Jewish authors
William Phillips and Philip Rahv (born Ivan Greenberg) were the
founding editors of the reinstitution of the fourth of
Rubinstein's noteworthy magazines, Partisan Review, in
1937. "The main difference between Partisan Review and
Commentary," said Elliot Cohen, Commentary's first
editor, "is that we admit to being a Jewish magazine and they
don't." [PODHORETZ, p. 99-100] Even today, Partisan Review
remains Jewish-dominated. The Editor-in-Chief remains William
Phillips, the Editor is Edith Kurzweil, and Number three in the
hierarchy is Associate Editor Steve Marcus. Joanna Rose is also
Chairman of the Publications and Advisory Board.
Lastly, of
Rubinstein’s five seminal "high-brow journals,” The New
Republic is still owned and edited by Martin Peretz, "one
of the most militant defenders of Israel." [GOLDBERG, p. 299]
Peretz, once a bankroller of the left-wing Ramparts
magazine, was described by a New Republic foreign editor
as "a very emotional guy. He has certain passions in life, one
of which is Israel. I hate to keep bringing in the Israeli
thing, because I consider myself just as pro-Israeli, but it
colored his whole view of the world." [CURTISS, p. 325] (Among
other things, Peretz has served on the Board of Directors of
Channel 7 TV in Boston. A Jewish friend, Robert Kraft, owner of
the largest privately owned packaging company in America, also
sat on the Board and was the station's number two shareholder).
[WEINGARTEN, p. 4]
In 1992, a
25-yeard old Jewish author, Ruth Shalit, "began interning at the
New Republic. Practically overnight she became a star --a
TNR Associate Editor writing cover stories for the
political weekly as well as for the New York Times Sunday
Magazine with a $45,000-a-year contract to do pieces for
GQ." [SHEPARDl, p. 34] She was also
accused, notes the American Journalism Review, of
"plagiarism, factual errors" and -- in one specific article --
racism, when she charged that the Washington Post "had
lowered high standards in an attempt to diversify its newsroom
and had softened news coverage of black politicians so as not to
offend African-American readers." [SHEPARD, p. 34]
In 1998, a (Jewish) Associate Editor
at the New Republic, Stephen Glass, was even fired for
fabricating the news stories he authored. Glass, noted the
New York Times about the scandal, "had made up part or all
of 27 articles he wrote." [NEW YORK TIMES, 4-18-00, p. C2] (A
former editor of the New Republic, Michael Kinsley, also
Jewish, today is the editor of Microsoft's Internet magazine
called Slate. Michael Hirschorn edits rival Internet
magazine Inside, and Scott Rosenberg is the vice
president and "technology editor" of another of the major
Internet magazines, Salon. Steve Waldman founded and
edits the commercial religious web site, beliefnet.com)
Other
important intellectual journals over the years with links to the
mostly Jewish "intellectual" clique include [d] Dissent,
run by Irving Howe, Meyer Schapiro and Michael Walzer; Sol
Levitas' New Leader; the New Criterion (publisher:
Samuel Lipman); and the Menorah Journal; a periodical of
entirely Jewish content. Hilton Kramer (for nearly twenty years
a news editor and art critic for the New York Times)
founded and edited the New Criterion; Peter Grose was
managing editor of Foreign Affairs. Laurence Goldstein
edits the Michigan Quarterly Review. Irving Horowitz
founded the social-science periodical Transaction, now
called Society, and Transaction Publishers.
"Horowitz," writes fellow Jewish intellectual Nathan Glazer,
"once an advocate of the
generally undifferentiated poor and powerless
and down trodden, has become over
time much more concerned with
one group in all its specificity:
Jews ... Horowitz is much concerned
with anti-Zionism, which he sees
as extending to what he considers
anti-Semitism -- even in
sociology, with the large numbers of Jews
working in
it." [GLAZER, Decomp., p. 127]
Theodore
Solotaroff was the founding editor of the New American Review,
as well as an Associate Editor at Commentary. Daniel
Pipes is the founder and editor of Middle East Quarterly.
At one point in time, "roughly half of all the articles of the
American medical journals were authored by Jews." [KRAFETZ, p.
176] Daniel Koshland, Jr., a descendant
of the Levi-Strauss blue jean dynasty, is the former editor of
Science magazine. In 1999, he donated $8 million to an
Israeli university. [LUM, R., 11-19-99, p. 1A] And, as one
Jewish observer noted in 1968, "For the last ten years 70
percent of the editors of the Yale Law Journal have been
Jewish." [YAFFE, J., 1968, p. 224] Sam Bercholz, also Jewish,
even founded Shambhala Books, "the first major publisher
of Tibetan Buddhist works in this country." [KAMENETZ, R., 1994,
p. 9]
Billed as a
left wing alternative to Commentary, and just as
blatantly Jewish in concern, is Tikkun, the brainchild of
editor Michael Lerner. In 1997 Lerner -- always heralding the
beauties of Jewish values and ethics for the problems of modern
society -- was exposed to be regularly (over a period of years)
publishing "letters to the editor" written by himself under fake
names. [KATZ, L, p. 3] Lerner is publicly
"known as Bill and Hillary Rodham Clinton's favorite
philosopher." [COLLINS, L., 1994, p. 302]
In 1997, Danny Goldberg, the CEO of Mercury Records,
became the publisher of Tikkun.
The thinking of
the educated public," wrote Charles Silberman in 1985," is
strongly effected ... by a relatively small number of literary
and intellectual magazines and journals ... Most of these
publications are edited by Jews." [SILBERMAN, p. 145] Aside from
the already mentioned publications, Silberman added Jewish
editors William Shawn [original name: William Chon] of the
New Yorker, Stephen Graubard of Daedalus, and
Mitchell Levitas of the New York Times Book Review.
More eccentrically, I. F. Stone's Weekly was an
expression of Stone's muck-raking "personal journalism."
Likewise, one of the best known "liberal" periodicals in
America, the Nation, is Jewish owned and edited (today by
Victor Navatsky). Another Nation
editor, Katrina van den Heuvel is the granddaughter of MCA's
Jules Stein. [MCDOUGAL, p. xi] Alfred Lilienthal, an
anti-Zionist and anti-Israel Jew, wondered in 1950:
"Who, I ask,
are the liberals? The Nation Associates Freda Kirchway,
Henry Wallace, Clark Eichelberger,
Albert Barkley, William O'Dwyer,
Ludwig Lewisohn, Abba Hillel
Silver, all of whom have intolerantly
and ardently supported Zionism?
[LILIENTHAL, p. 145]
In 1967, I. F. Stone (Isadore
Feinstein) felt it necessary to write: "As a Jew, closely bound
emotionally to the birth of Israel, [I feel] honor bound to
report the Arab side, especially since the U.S. press is so
overwhelmingly pro-Zionist." [LAGUEVIR/RUBIN, p. 327]
Most of the
best known "radical" and hippie 1960s-era newspapers were also
Jewish-founded. These include The Realist (Paul Krassner,
later an editor at Ramparts), the Berkeley Barb
(Marvin Garson), Rat (Jeff Shero, who had funding help
from Jason Epstein at the New York Review of Books,
[NOBILE, p. 198], the East Village Other (Allan Katzman),
and the Liberation News Service (Jesse Kornbluth and
Marshall Bloom). [WHITFIELD, American, p. 145]
Arthur Kunkin, who eventually softened from being a
"radical Zionist," founded the Los Angeles Free Press.
[PECK, 1991, p. 22] Allen Cohen was "editor of the San
Francisco Oracle." [KRASSNER, P., 1993, p. 152] Even in
communist Russia, a Jewish author noted in 1969 that "younger
Jewish intellectuals feature prominently in 'protest' campaigns,
which here have taken the form of underground literature.
Moscow's first underground magazine, Syntax, was founded
by Alexander Ginsburg." [LITVINOFF, B., p. 100] Jeff
Shero, editor of the above-mentioned Rat eventually
"changed his name to Nightbyrd and launched a mail-order
business selling drug-free powered urine." [KRASSNER, P., 1993,
p. 228]
"The leading exemplars of this genre [of radical
journalism]," note Stanley Rothman and S. Robert Lichter, "such
as the East Village Other, the Los Angeles Free Press,
the Berkeley Barb, and Detroit's the Fifth Estate,
as well as 'alternative' papers like the Village Voice,
the key personnel were invariably of Jewish background."
[ROTHMAN/LICHTER, 1982, p. 107] Today's versions of this include
David Barsamian (founder and director of Alternative Radio),
Michael Albert (editor of Z magazine), and Robert
Weissman (editor of Multinational Monitor).
Abby Goodman has for years been the news
director at "progressive" Pacifica station WBAI in New York; she
also hosts its national Democracy Now! program.
Mother Jones, the well-known
left-wing "social conscience" magazine, was largely founded in
1974 by the philanthropy of Adam Hochschild, heir to a fortune;
he thereby became the magazine's original managing editor, as
well as Board Chairman. Judging by his autobiography,
Hochschild's commitment to create Mother Jones in behalf
of the socially and politically dispossessed appears to have
been, in major part, in atonement for the sins of his father.
This man, Harold Hochschild, was the wealthy Jewish co-founder
(and chairman) of an international mining syndicate that sent
entire communities of Africans into holes in the ground for a
miniscule wage, and engendered local wrath for its strip-mining
in Appalachia, pollution of Indian fishing areas in British
Columbia, and destroying Aboriginal lands in Australia. The
younger Hochschild was even embarrassed to discover, while
working on a series of exposes about the CIA as a staff member
at an earlier left-wing journal, Ramparts, that for a
decade his father was Chairman of the Board of the
African-American Institute, a front for the CIA. [HOCHSCHILD,
1986, p. 130] Adam Hochschild, noted the
San Francisco Examiner in 1998, is "historically [Mother
Jones'] largest funder and the wielder of very substantial clout
within the foundation [that runs Mother Jones] ...
Hochschild has placed an unspecified sum in a 13-year account
which ... provides money year by year in diminishing amounts."
[ARMSTRONG, D., 9-13-98, p. D1] As editor-in-chief Jeffrey Klein
resigned in 1998, "creative director" Rhonda Rubenstein designed
a new format for the magazine. Today's editor-in-chief at
Mother Jones is Roger Cohn.
Matthew
Rothschild edits the left-wing Progressive (for years
published by Erwin Knoll). James Weinstein is the founding
editor and publisher of another influential leftist journal,
In These Times. (Today's editor: Joel Bleifuss). Naomi Klein
is a former editor of a Canadian leftist journal, This.
As mentioned earlier, Jews have dominated Nation for
decades. Louis Weisberg edits Chicago's gay newspaper, The
Chicago Free Press. And as Stanley Rothman and S. Robert
Lichter note about the world of American journalistic communism:
"From the 1930s through the 1950s, Jews were quite active
in the [Communist]
party leadership. Almost half the Communist leaders tried
for violations of the
Smith Act in 1947 were Jewish. In the 1940s, the editor of
the Daily Worker,
the managing editor, and the labor editor were all of
Jewish background.
The publicly visible top leadership, however, was
non-Jewish." [ROTHMAN
LICHTER, 1982, p. 100]
To the American political right, by 1997 Adam Meyerson
edits the Heritage Foundation's Policy Review and Bill
Kristol, also Jewish, former Chief of Staff for former Vice
President Dan Quayle, publishes, and edits, the Weekly
Standard, a journal he founded with fellow Jew John
Podhoretz. Even William F. Buckley's well-known politically
conservative (and supposedly Catholic) magazine, the National
Review, founded in 1953, had a strong Jewish foundation. As
George Nash notes:
"The fact
remains that a striking number of National Review's
original
luminaries were Jews. [Nash cites
seven] Indeed, without them the
magazine might have never gotten off
the ground, for if Buckley was
the founding father of the journal,
its unlikely godfather was an Austrian
Jewish émigré journalist named
William S. Schlamm ... [And] it was
Morrie Ryskind (1895-1985], a
prize-winning playwright and Hollywood
screenwriter, who organized a series
of crucial fund-raising receptions
for the project at his home in
Beverly Hills. As a result, Buckley achieved
more financial success with Ryskind's
California friends than with anyone
else except his own father." [NASH,
G., 2000, p. 124]
Other
influential Jews associated with the National Review were
Eugene Lyons, Frank Meyer, Frank Chodorov, and Ralph Toledano
(an editor at Newsweek who was offered the Managing
Editor job. He turned it down but later became the National
Review's music editor). Marvin Liebman also "emerged as the
outstanding fund-raiser, organizer and coordinator of
'agitation-propaganda' for a vast apparatus of conservative
causes associated with National Review."
Will Herberg, also Jewish, became the journal's first
religion columnist. [NASH, G., 2000, p. 124-126, 156]
Other prominent politically
conservative Jewish journalists these days include Charles
Krauthammer, David Brooks, David Frum, John Podhoretz, and Dan
Feder. [FRIEDMAN, M., 1999, p. 110] Even the Christian
evangelical World newsweekly (which has over 100,000
subscribers, reasonably comparable in size to the "premier
magazine for evangelical Christians," Billy Graham's
Christianity Today, which has a circulation of 150,000) is
edited by Marvin Olasky. Olasky is a "Jew turned Marxist turned
born-again Christian ... [He] oversees the magazine from his
custom-built home in the posh hills of Austin, Texas ... He
declared himself an atheist at 14, and became a committed
Marxist at Yale -- even joining the Communist Party and touring
the Soviet Union." [PERINA, K., JUNE 2000]
And how about
"radical" (i.e., anti-establishment, anti-Hollywood] documentary
filmmakers? For two years (Jewish) film critic and historian
Alan Rosenthal was "supported" by an Israeli university to do a
book about international documentary filmmaking. (In 1980, the
book was published by the University of California Press).
Although it was not a publicly stated interest of
Rosenthal's, this side too of movie-making has also been largely
Jewish. Rosenthal's list of the most important "radical"
filmmakers of the 1960s includes the Maysles brothers, Ricky
Leacock, Don Pennebaker, Bill Jersey, Fred Wiseman, and Alan
King. For the 1970s, he singles out Barbara Kopple, Jill
Godmilow, Julia Reichert and James Klein. [ROSENTHAL, p. 9]
Of 14 people cited, at least 8 are Jewish.
Moving back
towards mainstream documentary media, Rosenthal elsewhere
observes that "one appreciates Barbara Kopple, Julia Reichert,
James Klein, and Richard Cohen but it was directors like Al
Wasserman and Douglas Leiterman who have helped enlarge the
boundaries of broadcast documentary." [ROSENTHAL, p. 23]
Jewish documentary filmmakers or producers afforded
chapter-length interviews in his book included Robert Vas, Abe
Osheroff, Amalie Rothschild, Richard Cohen, Jerry Blumenthal
(with a group), Julia Reichert and James Klein, Morton
Silverstein, David Elstein, and Albert Wasserman.
Wasserman,
notes Rosenthal, had a career that covers the best years of 'CBS
Reports,' the CBS ‘Twentieth Century’ series, and NBC's 'White
Paper' series, which he helped originate. At present [1980] he
works as producer on CBS's Sixty Minutes.'
[ROSENTHAL, p. 91] "I was at CBS until 1960," says
Wasserman, "Then I went to NBC with Irving Gitlin, who
was a very important figure in the evolution of the television
documentary." [ROSENTHAL, p. 93] Another Jewish writer,
director, and producer, Fred Freed, merited an entire volume
about his contributions to documentary television. [YELLIN 1973]
For all the international muckraking
of all these Jewish documentarians, none of them is noted in
Rosenthal's volume to have turned their critical eyes to Israel,
from which the volume's university support stems. And the only
one who mentions Jews in any way is Robert Vas, who frames
himself in the context of the Holocaust. By 1995, with the mass
media increasingly celebrating Jewish themes, the world could
look to more overt mass media Judeo-centrism when Stephen
Spielberg funded the New York-based "Fund for Jewish
Documentaries," an off-shoot of his National Foundation for
Jewish Culture.
Like the
film, television, and publishing industries, the musical
recording business and general musical world is, and has been,
in virtually all its important facets, dominated by Jews.
Classical
music? In 1968 Roger Kahn noted that "the four pre-eminent
American orchestras are conducted by Jews: Erich Leinsdorf
at Boston, George Szell at Cleveland, Eugene Ormandy at
Philadelphia and Leonard Bernstein, who is about to retire
from the New York Philharmonic. A look at the rosters of
these orchestras reveals string sections all but solidly
Jewish clear back to the rear desk in the furthest corner of
the second violins ... [KAHN, p. 6].... A Jewish armada has
conquered musical performance. Jewish names comprise the
aristocracy of performers: Heifetz and Horowitz; Elman and
Rubinstein; Piatigorsky and Koussevitsky; Bernstein and
Stern; Fleisher, Glazer, Gomberg, Graffman, Roisman, Rosen,
Schneider ... Jews dominate serious musical performance in
America." [KAHN, p. 63-64] Arnold
Schoenberg is arguably "this century's most influential
composer." [HEILBUT, p. 493] "In the 1920s he
wrote (a still unpublished) Zionist drama and began with the
preparations for his opera Moses and Aron."
[GRUNFELD, F., p. xix] Philip Glass and Steve Reich
are well-know composers in the "pushing the boundaries"
avant-garde genre. "In the 1920s [Aaron] Copland was a
primary influence in American music through the League of
Composers." [PEYSER, J., 1987, p. 33]
Joan Peyser, a biographer of
Leonard Bernstein, notes the following about her subject:
"The more one knows about
Bernstein, the more complicated the
portrait is
of him as a Jew. Capable of working productively with
anti-Semites, he still holds a
soft spot in his heart for fellow Jews,
whom he says he finds superior to
all others. 'He is so adamant
about music being Jewish,'
[conductor and composer Gunther]
Schuller says, 'It is important
to him that a composer is a Jew,
that a
performer is a Jew. He told me that Triplum, my
composition,
has a Jewish soul. That is meant
as a compliment. I am not a Jew.
When Lenny says, 'You can almost
be Jewish,' that is considered
by him to be one of the most
supreme of compliments.'" [PEYSER,
J., 1987, p. 409]
Throughout
the American geographical terrain, by 1998, Jews were
prominent in directing/conducting America's orchestras: Yoel
Levi of the Atlanta Symphony, David Zinman of the
Baltimore Symphony, Daniel Barenboim of the Chicago
Symphony, Yaccov Bergman of the Colorado Springs
Symphony, Neal Gittelman of the Dayton Symphony,
Stephen Gunzenhauser of the Delaware Symphony,
Leonard Slatkin of the National Symphony (Washington DC),
Gerhardt Zimmerman of the North Carolina Symphony,
Joel Levine of the Oklahoma City Philharmonic, Victor
Yampolsky of the Omaha Symphony, Eugene Kohn of the
Puerto Rico Symphony, Robert Bernhardt of the
Rochester Philharmonic, Philip Greenberg of the
Savannah (Georgia) Symphony, Gerard Schwartz of the
Seattle Symphony, Bernard Rubenstein of the Tulsa
Philharmonic, and Joseph Silverstein of the Utah
Symphony, among others. [BRUNNER, 1998, p. 736] James
Levine became head of the Boston Symphony Orchestra
in 2001. The same year, a 25 year-old Israeli, Ilan Volkov,
became the youngest conductor to ever be appointed to head
the BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra.
In southern
California, there exists the Los Angeles Jewish Symphony,
which "is an established and growing ensemble that aims to
fill a cultural niche by exploring new or seldom heard music
by or about Jews." Founder Noreen Green "is most proud of an
original oration and concert, 'Women of Valor,' sponsored by
Hadassah Southern California [the international Jewish
women's Zionist group] which premiered at UCLA." [SMITH, L.,
6-11-2000, p. E1]
Harlan Robinson notes who dominated the musician
(especially violinist) realm of the American classical music
realm in the 1940s:
"Further down the 1942-43 [Jewish impresario Sol] Hurok
list was a recent addition
to the stable: violinst Isaac Stern. Though at the time
a newcomer, he, too, would
eventually turn into a steady source of income. Stern
would also become one of
his manager's [Hurok] most trusted advisers and the
patriarch of a group of
Jewish musicians (especially violinists) whose imposing
artistic and booking
influence would come to earn them the ironic nickname
the 'Kosher Nostra ...
[ROBINSON, H., 1994, p. 287] ... [Itzhak] Perlman
turned into a very popular
and profitable addition to his list. So did another
Stern recommendation, Pinchas
Zuckerman. Together, they became the backbone of the
Manhattan-based
Jewish musical clique jokingly labeled the 'Kosher
Nosta.'" [ROBINSON, H.
1994, p. 427]
Famed pianist Arthur Rubinstein was an ardent devotee
of Israel:
"Another matter that frequently enraged Rubinstein was
the world's attitude
-- or his interpretation of it -- toward Israel. In his
last years, he was not
merely benevolent toward Israel: he was a right-winger,
certain that Israel
could do no wrong. The territories that Israel had
occupied in 1967
were Israel's by right, he believed, and he said that
the Palestinians were
nomads in whom Lawrence of Arabia had unfortunately
implanted the
notion of being a people -- after which they had done
nothing but
procreate ... Since the Soviet Union had become the
major supporter of
Israel's opponents, Rubinstein even suggested that the
United States bomb
the Kremlin." [SACHS, H., 1995, p. 393]
Rubinstein onced donated $100,000 to Israel's Weizman
Institute, he gave $50,000 to the Israel-American Cultural
Foundation "in honor of Isaac Stern, on the violinist's
sixtieth birthday," and he left $500,000 in his will to the
city of Jerusalem. [SACHS, D., 1995, p. 394]
In 2000, famous Jewish opera
singer Beverly Sills (also chairwoman of New York City's
Lincoln Center performing arts center) was in Seattle to
speak to the northwestern chapter of Hadassah, the Zionist
women's group. This was special news, noted the local
newspaper, because Sills "limits appearances to a dozen a
year, often speaking to members of Hadassah, a Jewish
women's organization. She says, 'They're people trying to
make the world a better place.'" [GODDEN, J., 5-2000, p. B1]
In 1933, a
researcher discovered consistent Jewish overrepresentation
in the classical music world, including "51% of the first
violins of twelve orchestras," 23.8% of the works "performed
by symphony orchestras," and so forth. Why was this so?
Comparing Jewish and non-Jewish children, Kenneth Sward
found no intelligence differences, but speculated that "the
Jewish child may be a superior all-around organism by
'nature.'" [WEYL, N., 1968, p. 188]
Singer Jan Peerce (born Jacob Pincus Perelmuth) from
the late 1930s to early 1950s "was a regular on the most
popular classical music [radio] broadcast in American
history ... In a story worthy of Hollywood, he was finally
noticed [i.e., 'discovered'] by showman Samuel L. 'Roxy'
Rothafel while performing as a singing violinist."
[ROBINSON, H., 1994, p. 253-254] (Peerce "was so deeply
religious that he had even disowned his son Larry, a film
director, for marrying a gentile woman with two children).
[ROBINSON, H., 1994, p. 459]
Jewish influence in
more popular music has been profound. During the rise of rock
and roll, notes Jory Farr, "in many ways, the pop business was
run as the film business in its heyday. It was a club, mostly
Jewish, filled with wily impresarios, maverick street fighters,
and out-and-out operators." [FARR, p. 126] In earlier years, the
musical agent -- and later executive -- John Hammond, notes
Frederic Dannen, "was the ultimate WASP in a preponderantly
Jewish profession." [DANNEN, p. 62] A
network of Jewish executives, agents, managers, and other
entrepreneurs have reigned supreme in the musical network for
decades. ("One writer in 1927," note
Claire Pagackowska and Barry Curtis, "referred to jazz as
reaching 'from the black South to the black North, but in
between it had been touched by the commercial wand of the
Jew.'") [PAGACKOWSKA, p. 242]
Kenneth Kanter notes that:
"Both as a business and as an
expression of talent and creative artistry,
American popular music was in large
part shaped and formed by Jews,
many of them immigrant newcomers to
the American scene ... Virtually
all the great names that come to
mind when one considers popular
music -- Rogers and Hammerstein,
Irving Berlin, Lorenz Hart, Jerome
Kern, George and Ida Gershwin,
Irving Caesar, and Charles Harris,
for instance, are Jewish names. Jews
wrote the songs, Jews sang the
songs, and Jews made sure that the
songs were circulated to every
corner of the country, for they
founded and built America's publishing
industry. Among the vanguard
publishers were M. Witmark, Charles K.
Harris, Joseph Stern, Shapiro and
Bernstein, Harry von Tilzer, Leo Feist,
T. B. Harms, and Irving Berlin [born
Israel Baline]. Collectively their
publishing firms came to be known as
'Tin Pan Alley' ... It was the Tin
Pan Alley ethos, combining the
commercial with the aesthetic, that gave
our popular
music its distinctive character." [KANTER, p. ix]
The Jewish Tin Pan Alley monopoly of the music business was
solid for decades. As H. F. Mooney notes:
"By 1941, the virtual monopoly of the ASCAP (American
Society of Composers
Authors, and Publishers, organized in 1914), which had
practically protected New
York's ascendancy in the music market, was broken by legal
judgment. The
consequent opening of broadcasting and recording channels
to non-ASCAP
composers and publishers, many of them unknowns outside the
conventional
musical establishment of Tin Pan Alley ... marked the end
of an era of increasingly
urbane New York composers. These had been heavily Jewish
... Such New York
Jews as Harold Arlen, George and Ira Gershwin, Jerome Kern,
Vernon Duke
(ne Dukelsky), Herman Hupfeld and Vincent Youmans had
produced a pensive
music of finesse and polish, often using minor strains in
the cantorial tradition.
Their melodic concepts influenced 'white' jazz
instrumentalists -- themselves
frequently Jewish -- flowing with increasing facility
through plaintive but
delicately restrained saxophones from Benny Kreuger in the
early 1920s
through Frank Trumbaujer to Stan Getz; and through the
arabesque
clarinets of Benny Goodman and Artie Shaw." [MOONEY, H. F.,
1972, p
p. 258-259]
(Per current Jazz, in 1998 the Cleveland Jewish
News annonced that "the world's No. 1 jazz group [is] Spyro
Gyra. Meet the man who started it all -- Jay Beckenstein. The
world-renowned musician and music producer and his jazz crew
(Bekenstein and two other members are Jewish) have been legends
since 1970.") [ALPEN, J., 5-1-1998, p. 46]
Jewish domination of the music world did not, of course,
end with the demise of Tin Pan Alley. As we shall soon see,
Jewish influence merely broadened.
Tin Pan Alley (a term invented by
song writer/journalist Monroe Rosenfeld) [SHAW, A., 1982, p.
386] Jews were also instrumental in maintaining popular negative
views about themselves. "The image of the Jews in the songs of
the day," says Kanter, "was not terribly flattering. Jews were
presented as money-grubbing, hand-rubbing old men who wore crepe
hair and ran pawn shops. The Jews of Tin Pan Alley helped
perpetuate this stereotype." [KANTER, p. 57]
The Jews who dominated Tin Pan Alley
and the turn-of-the century vaudeville world were also central
in the popularization and propagation of profoundly demeaning
African-American stereotypes. Pamela Brown Lavitt notes Tin Pan
Alley and the many onstage Jewish "coon callers":
"Jewish women vaudevillians at the
turn of the century popularized
what is now a little-discussed and
misunderstood performance
venue, known as "coon shouting" ...
Trying to break into the
entertainment business, [Tin Pan
Alley entrepreneurs'] aesthetics
were circumscribed in a vehemently
antiblack and xenophobic
milieu. By the mid-1880-s they had
formed a tight-knit Tin Pan
Alley industry that came to dominate
vaudeville and early black
musicals ... Intended as comedy, coon
song ranged from jocular
and dismissive to cruel and sadistic
... Coon song sheet music
and illustrated covers proliferated
defamatory images of blacks
in barely coded slanderous lyrics.
For example, the 'N' word and
associated inferences were dispatched
in words like 'mammy,'
'honey boy,' 'pickinniny,'
'chocolate,' 'watermelon,' 'possum,'
and the most prevalent 'coon.'"
[LAVITT, P., 2000, p. 253-258]
Especially well known Jewish "coon
callers" included Sophie Tucker, Stella Mayhew, Fanny Brice,
Anna Held, Eddie Cantor, and Al Jolson.
Jews have long gravitated to an
entrepreneurial exploitation of the Black cultural scene and
jazz music. As Burton Peretti notes:
"Aside from the hazards of the mob
[organized crime] environment,
the exploitation faced by jazz
players was rather typical for this era
[1930s and 1940s]. Jazz, like
minstrels and ragtime before it, came
under the control of professional
promoters who sought to make music
profitable. [They adapted] the
technique of advertising, song plugging,
and vaudeville ... Some promoters,
like Joe Glaser (who managed Louis
Armstrong in the thirties) were
associates of organized crime who left
the underworld when prohibition was
repealed. Glaser apparently had
overseen Al Capone's profits from
the Sunset Cafe and a prostitution
ring before he became Armstrong's
manager in 1935. Many more
promoters, however, were veterans
of Tin Pan Alley, Manhattan's
song-publishing industry, including
Irving Mills, a former singer and
songwriter who managed Duke
Ellington's and other black bands in
the thirties." [PERETTI, p. 147]
Glaser ran the
Associated Booking Corporation, often "the exclusive
agent for many of the top Black performers. He became a close
associate of many of the top underworld figures in Chicago and
New York, whom he met through his band-booking agency." [MOLDEA,
p. 14] Glaser had been an early partner
in the company with eventual MCA chief Jules Stein.
In 1962, mob-linked attorney Sidney Korshak, also Jewish,
gained control of the ABC company. [MCDOUGAL, p. 141]
Mills and Paddy
Harmon, owner of Chicago's Dreamland Cafe, "sought and
gained spurious renown, as Mills took partial credit for many
Ellington compositions and Harmon patented and gave his name to
a trumpet mute that had long been popular among Joe Oliver and
other black players." [PERETTI, p. 148]
The rip-off of Black artists was a norm for the era. As Al
Silverman notes in the case of Fats Waller:
"In his time Fats wrote the
melodies to over 360 songs. Not that many
bear his name today,
unfortunately, because when money was needed
he'd write the music and sell all
rights to unscrupulous Tin Pan Alley
characters." [SILVERMAN, p.
129-130]
"That practice
of show business share-cropping ... in the 1920s and 1930s,"
notes the director of Harlem's Apollo Amateur Night, Ralph
Cooper, "existed right on through the fifties and sixties. Its
bitterness still exists among many performers to this day -- a
bitterness from the theft of their songs, their sound, their
talent." [COOPER, p. 199] Jewish singers "Sophie Tucker,
Eddie Cantor and Al Jolson," notes Donald Fischer,
"performed in blackface at the beginning of their
careers, singing black songs.
They later built on their successes in this medium to
develop national statures
and professional sucesses with other music. However,
their early songs were
for the most part borrowed or plagiarized from
African-American sources,
with little or no public recognition -- or monetary
reward -- for the creative
talents that produced them." [FISCHER, D., 6-30-2000, p.
21A]
Jews were also
prominent in the overseeing of the Black community's jazz life,
including the control of musical clubs in Black neighborhoods in
a variety of American cities. "The invasion of the Black
community by organized crime lords with connections to downtown
money," notes Ted Vincent, "was certainly the most sensational
contribution to the loss of Black oversight of neighborhood
dance halls and theatres." [VINCENT, p. 176] "Slumming resorts"
served a largely non-Black audience and "were noted for their
riverboat decor, fake magnolia plants, and nearly nude dancers
... Perhaps the nationwide pioneer in the resorts was Isadore
Shor's Entertainment Cafe."
[VINCENT, p. 78] In Harlem, such clubs
included Connie's Inn (owned by Connie Innerman) and the
famed Apollo Theatre. "From the opening of the [Apollo]
building in 1912 until 1934," notes Vincent, "the theatre was a
showcase for white [i.e., largely Jewish] vaudeville burlesque
shows, with white strippers coming to be the main attraction."
[VINCENT, p. 189] The Apollo was eventually sold by
"Burlesque Kings Hurtig and Seaman" to Sid Cohen and Morris
Sussman, and then to Frank Schiffman and Leo Brecher. Brecher
also owned the Douglas, the Roosevelt, the
Lafayette Theatre ("the prime showcase for black talent in
America") [COOPER, p. 44], and the Harlem Opera
House located a block from the Apollo. [VINCENT, p.
189-192] Jay Fagan, and Moses and Charles
Gale (Galewski), founded the popular Savoy Ballroom in
1926.
Mel Watkins notes the reputation in the Black community of
dominant mogul Frank Schiffman:
"Schiffman was a controversial figure in black
entertainment. Admired and respected
by some, scorned and excoriated by others, he was rarely
viewed neutrally.
His Machiavellian approach to business is a matter of
record, and most would admit
that he was an unrepentant shark in business matters. He
quickly eliminated
his competitors and for decades eradicated all serious
competition, which
earned him the grudging esteem of other showmen. Among
performers, however,
the estimate was not glowing. Of his knowledge of black
acts, John Bubbles
[an African-American performer of the era] said, 'Only
thing he knew was how
to get people cheap as he could, and work them as long as
he could.' And
John Hammond, a record producer and friend, flatly declared
'Frank had no
artistic taste at all.'" [WATKINS, M., 1994, p. 386]
Samuel Charters and Leonard Kunstad
note the situation of another famous nightclub:
"The Cotton
Club had opened at 142nd St. and Lexington Ave. in 1922
with a strict policy of white only.
The owner, Bernard Levy, had pressed
his policy, despite loud protests
from the Harlem community. He used
Negro orchestras and a Negro revue
and ran it as a tourist attraction for
society people who wanted to see a
little of 'Harlem life' ... The club was
forced to admit colored patrons
during the next winter, but the prices he
kept high and it remained
predominantly a tourist attraction until the
Depression." [CHARTERS, p. 217]
New York's
Latin Quarter club (with eventual branches in other cities)
was also owned by a Jew, Lou Walters, father of famous
newscaster Barbara Walters; Monte Kay was the founder of the
famous Birdland jazz club. He too was Jewish. Mobster
Morris Levy later controlled the place. The Panama
was one of the top two cabarets in Chicago. It was owned by
Isadore Levine. [BRICKTOP, 1983, p. 53] Bricktop, a famous
international African-American nightclub manager from the
1920s-1950s, wrote about her time spent in Mexico:
"The most prominent of the wheeler-dealers in Mexico City's
American colony
was a strange, tiny little man called Blumey. He was A. C.
Blumenthal, a
financier who had his fingers in many pies. He was once
married to Peggy
Fears, a Ziegfeld showgirl. Blumey went to Mexico City to
dodge Uncle
Sam's tax collectors, and he was just one of many rich
Americans who had
gone to Mexico City for that reason. The others lived
quietly and inconspicuously,
but Blumey loved the limelight ... He had a stable of tall,
beautiful girls
who towered over him, and he could be found holding court
every day in the
Reforma Hotel, where he was the manager." [BRICKTOP, 1983,
p. 223]
As Israeli scholar Robert Rockaway
notes about a common undercurrent in such night life:
"Jewish Gangsters frequented
nightclubs ... In fact, Jewish underworld
figures owned many nightspots and
speakeasies. In New York, Dutch
Schultz owned
the Embassy Club. Charley 'King' Solomon owned
Boston's
Coconut Grove. In Newark, Longy Zwillman owned the Blue
Mirror
and the Casablanca Club. Boo Boo Hoff owned the
Picadilly
Cafe in
Philadelphia. Detroit's [Jewish] Purple Gang owned Luigi's
Cafe, one of the city's more
opulent clubs. Jewish singers and
comedians, such as Al Jolson, Eddie
Cantor, Fanny Brice and Sophie
Tucker played in the mob clubs."
[ROCKAWAY, R., 1993, p. 205]
Upset with outsider exploitation and
degradation of the Black community (where many night clubs were
located), there was an effort by the Marcus Garvey
African-American movement as early as the 1920s to institute
Black-owned Liberty Halls "where the musical offerings would be
part of an overall effort at community uplift and not just a
profit-oriented business." [VINCENT, p. 114]
(From France,
even the international jet-set luxury playground/resort of "Club
Med" was founded by Gerard Blitz, and built to power by Gilbert
Trigano. Both are also Jewish. By 1999 the firm had 116 sites in
36 countries, now headed by Gilbert's son Serge. [REGULY, E.,
4-25-88, pl. 24; MCDONELL, E., 5-1-99, p. D10] Hollywood's
Roxy nightclub was founded by the Jewish managerial trio
of David Geffen, Lou Adler, and Bill Graham. [KING, T., 2000, p.
187] La Boehme in Hollywood, Florida, was owned by Jack
Lansky, brother of famous mobster Meyer Lansky. [THOMAS, D.,
1991, p. 162] )
Jews have of
course been prominent over the years as musical performers.
These included three of the most influential band leaders of the
1930s -- Benny Goodman ("the King of Swing"), Harry James, and
Artie Shaw (Arthur Arshansky). More recent popular names include
Leonard Bernstein, Andre Previn, Arthur Fiedler, Stephen
Sondheim, and many others. As noted
earlier too, by the 1930s MCA (Music Corporation of
America) was a powerful talent agency, founded by Jules
Stein and built later to power by Sidney Sheinbein and Lew
Wasserman, who ultimately became one of the most powerful men in
Hollywood. Ronald Brownstein observes that:
"By the
mid-1930s, MCA controlled many of the country's most
popular
bands, from Tommy Dorsey to Artie
Shaw." [BROWNSTEIN, p. 181]
For years,
MCA's Jules Stein, adds Michale Pye, "ran the music business
so toughly that no dance hall would stand against him." [PYE, p.
18-19] In a 1946 antitrust trial that MCA lost, a Los
Angeles federal judge "declared that MCA held a virtual
monopoly over the entertainment business." The presiding judge
also stated that MCA was "the Octopus ... with tentacles
reaching out into all phases and grasping everything in show
business." [MOLDEA, p. 2, 3] "The one man," notes
non-Jewish band leader Guy Lombardo, "who probably more than any
other solidified the business and hastened the era of the Big
Bands was Jules Stein. He had started his Music Corporation of
America in Chicago and to that city gravitated bands from all
over the country, seeking the buildup and engagements they would
get if MCA took them in the fold." Lombardo was also under
contract to Stein. [LOMBARDO, G., 1975, p. 153] Stein even wrote
an introduction to Lombardo's autobiography.
For years
MCA increasingly interfaced with Chicago's Mafia and other
underworld personalities. Seemingly omnipresent in Hollywood was
lawyer Sidney Korshak. "A close friend of Stein's and
Wasserman's," says Dan Moldea, "Korshak quickly became one of
the most powerful influences in the entertainment industry and
in California politics ... [MOLDEA, p. 5] ... Korshak
... has been described by federal investigators as the
principle link between the [Hollywood] legitimate business world
and organized crime." [MOLDEA, p. 2]
And rock and
roll? The Jewish foundation continued. "The most famous and
important [rhythm and blues disc jockey]," note Steve Chapple
and Reebee Garofalo, "was ... Alan Freed, the father of Rock 'n'
Roll ... Freed was credited with co-writing fifteen rock and
rock hits including Chuck Berry's 'Maybelline,' but he did
little more than promote any of them." [CHAPPLE, p. 56-57]
A biography of Freed notes that "by 1956, there was no
bigger name in rock and roll than Freed, except Elvis Presley."
[JACKSON, p. ix] (Another of America's
best known early disc jockeys was also Jewish, Murray the K, aka
Murray Kaufman). In 1960, Freed was indicted for accepting
$30,000 in bribes to play songs at his radio station.
"[Freed] grabbed the kids and led them to the great rock
candy mountain," says Albert Goldman, "He named their music,
coined its us-against-them rhetoric, created rock show biz,
including the package tour ... Alan Freed is really one of the
principal exhibits in the Rock 'n' Roll Hall of Ill Fame ...
[He] was not only a crook but a self-righteous hypocrite. Even
[Freed's manager] Morris Levy [with deep ties to the criminal
underworld, particular the Mafioso Gigante family] had to
concede that the 'Father of Rock 'n' Roll' was not a nice man.
Speaking as one Jew to another Jew about a third Jew, Levy said
simply: 'He could have been another Hitler.'" [GOLDMAN, p.
519-520]
In a book
about the Atlantic Records empire (later swallowed by
Warners), Dorothy Wade and Justine Picardie noted Morris
Levy and the kinds of people that populated the rock and roll
industry: "The truth is, with or without mob connections, Morris
Levy was much more typical of the new music moguls than either
[non-Jewish] Ahmet Ertegun or [Jewish] Jerry Wexler ... The
world in which Atlantic had to survive was populated
largely by hoodlums and hustlers." [WADE, p. 57] As Syd Nathan,
the owner of King Records, once said, "You want to be in
the record business? The first thing you learn is that everyone
is a liar." [WADE, p. 60] "The early rhythm and blues
companies were run by a fraternity of Jews ... They were tough
and they were shrewd -- some say unscrupulous -- and they were
alternately loved, despised, respected, and feared. The deep
bond of these cultural outsiders prompted one gentile, mild
rebuke in his voice, to comment that 'Yiddish was the second
language of the record business." [COHODAS, N., p. 3-4, 2000]
"To the general
public," notes Steve Chapple and Reebee Garofalo, "the music
business seems to have a tremendous amount of corruption."
[CHAPPLE, p. 226] "I think in Hollywood," media psychologist
Stuart Fischel of California State University at Los Angeles
told the Los Angeles Times in 1993, "people get into a
kind of mind meld. You can come in as a relatively moral and
ethical person, but eventually [Hollywood] produces a
re-socializing of a subculture with different norms and ethics
based on hedonism and materialism. It's hard to know what's
going to breach the bounds of acceptable criminality in
Hollywood." [ELLER, p. B8, B11] Aside from drugs, prostitution,
and all the other extracurricular norms of the interrelated
music, film, and television worlds of Hollywood, just at the
most basic business level, "payola [bribery] has been a key
factor in the establishment of major artists," says Roger
Karshner, "the evolution of publishing dynasties and the
creation of recording empires. Payola, layola, and taking care
of business are the ABC's of the music industry past and
present. It has taken many forms, and many publishers, artists,
managers, and record people at all levels have participated in
payola practices." [KARSHNER, p. 39]
Probably the
most important early rhythm and blues recording company was
Chess Records, founded by Leonard and Phillip Chess,
Jewish immigrants from Poland. They started out with a scrap
metal business in the ghetto, then moved into the liquor
business, eventually owning several bars in the Black
neighborhoods of South Chicago, including the large Macamba
Club, which was "reputedly a prime center for prostitution and
heavy drug dealing." [DIXON, p. 78] The Chess brothers soon
recognized a profitable opportunity open to them with the many
Black musical acts that played at their nightclubs; the
entrepreneurs soon embarked upon a recording business,
eventually producing blues, gospel, and rock and rock music.
Seminal Black artists who signed on to the Chess label included
Bo Diddley, Howlin' Wolf, Muddy Waters, John Lee Hooker, Etta
James, Chuck Berry, and many others. Berry's songs were among
the most influential in rock and roll history. "Some people have
called Leonard and Phillip Chess visionaries who recognized the
potential in the visceral blues of post-World War II Chicago,
"says Don Snowden, who co-wrote the auto-biography of bluesman
Willie Dixon, "A far greater number have branded the Chess
brothers as exploiters who systematically took advantage of the
artists who created that music." [DIXON, p. 78]
The Rolling Stones even found seminal bluesman Muddy
Waters still painting the Chess's home when they came to record
in Chicago. [WADE, p. 71]
Frank
Schiffman, owner of a number of musical venues in New York's
Harlem area, "was a ruthless competitor who would do anything,
including take advantage of his black employees and exploit the
great black artists who worked for him, in order to increase his
profits and beat down the opposition." [COOPER, p. 44]
"Remember [Black singer] Little Eva Boyd?" asks Ralph
Cooper, "She worked as a babysitter for two Tin Pan Alley
[Jewish] rock and roll writers, Carole King and Gerry Goffen.
They wrote a song called 'Loco-Motion' and they asked her to
sing it ... Now [1990] she lives in North Carolina, where her
people are from. She's a working mother on welfare. She works in
a barbeque kitchen as a cook." [COOPER, p. 196]
In 1997, Black
singer Darlene Love won a lawsuit for back royalties against
famous Jewish musical producer Phil Spector. (Originally awarded
$263,000, it was later dropped down to $130,000.) Love was the
anonymous lead singer on a number of 1960s-era Spector
productions, including He's a Rebel, Da Do Ron Ron,
He's Sure the Boy I Love, and other hits. In the early
1980s Ms. Love found herself cleaning toilets for a living, but
her singing career later flourished anew. [WILLMAN, C.,
10-15-88, CALENDAR, p. 10; WARRICK, P., 11-2-98]
"I didn't know
anything about the record business," said early rock and roll
sensation Little Richard (of "Tutti Frutti" fame) about his rock
and roll career. " I was very dumb ... I was just like a sheep
among a bunch of wolves that would devour me at any moment. I
think I was taken advantage of because I was uneducated. I think
I was treated inhumane ... I think I was treated wrong and many
people got rich out of the style of music I created. They are
all millionaires, writ many times, and nobody offered me
nothing." [WADE, p. 74] Dorothy Wade and
Justine Picardie note Little Richard's lamentation, then add:
"To which many, if not most, of his black musical contemporaries
would add: Amen." [WADE, p. 74] Among
others, Richard had in mind the Jewish owner of Specialty
Records, Art Rupe, who many years ago bought the rights to
his songs for a paltry $10,000.
Chuck Berry remembers being cheated by
the Chess brothers:
"[Phil Chess finally acknowledged] in
writing that no songwriter
royalties had
been paid for three years on my Chess Records
product ...
[And in a review of Chess documents] I was
surprised to learn that I had been
paid the same songwriter
royalties for an LP as I was
receiving for a single record.
Chess claimed to be unaware of
this 'mistake,' as if they had
never noticed that LPs had between
eight and ten songs on
them." [BERRY,
C., p. 246-247]
"In 1974 Howlin' Wolf filed a lawsuit against Arc Music
[the publishing wing of Chess Records, it was co-owned by
the Chess brothers and two brothers of Jewish band leader Benny
Goodman] [COHODAS, N., 2000, p. 37] asking for $2.5 million for
unpaid royalties from his songs ... In 1976 Muddy Waters and
Willie Dixon filed identical lawsuits against the publishing
company, alleging fraud and conspiracy and asking to paid money
damages and to have their publishing contracts voided."
[COHODAS, N., 2000, p. 308]
In 1972,
Martin Otelsberg became the manager of African-American musician
Bo Diddley. Suspecting in later years that he had been swindled,
Diddley filed suit against Otelsberg's estate in 1994 and
recovered $400,000. As Diddley's lawyer (also Jewish) John
Rosenberg noted, "This is a typical story that's happened time
and again to musicians like Bo." [MORSE, S., 6-18-94, p. 28]
Diddley complained of being cheated by the Chess brothers as
well. "To me every nationality has a reason for bein' here,"
said Diddley, "an' mostly all the Jewish people own everything.
They got all the money. Give him a thousand dollars, he'll turn
it into ten million. How the heck they do it, I don't know."
[COHODAS, N., 2000, p. 110]
The Jewish community, of course, isn't comfortable with this history.
As Jewish author Neal Karlen describes one African-American
depiction of the Jewish music hustler: "In the 1990 film Mo'
Better Blues, Spike Lee crafted an artful if blazingly
anti-Semitic portrait of the fictional Moe Flatbush, an
avaricious Jewish club owner intent on swindling black jazzmen.
The ferretlike, Yiddish-spouting Moe, played by John Turturro,
was seemingly lifted straight from the pages of the anti-Semitic
screed The Protocols of Zions." [KARLEN, N., 1994, p. 145]
The Jewish
agent-producer exploitation of Black recording artists in the
early rhythm and blues era of the 1940s and 1950s (and later)
was predominant and widespread, entrenching a Black hostility
among many to their Jewish financial controllers to the present
day. The following Jewish entrepreneurs were among those who
founded record labels featuring mainly Black talent: Herman
Lubinsky (Savoy Records); the Braun family (DeLuxe
Records); Hy Siegal, Sam Schneider and Ike Berman (Apollo
Records); Saul, Joe, and Jules Bihari (Modern Records);
Art Rupe (Specialty Records-- its biggest hits were those
of Little Richard); Lev, Edward, and Ida Messner (Philo/Aladdin
Records); Al Silver and Fred Mendelsohn (Herald/Ember
Records); Paul and Lilian Rainer (Black and White Records);
Sam and Hy Weiss (Old Towne Records; Sol Rabinowitz (Baton
Records -- Rabinowitz eventually became vice president of
CBS International); and Danny Kessler (head of OKeh
Records, a "cheap" branch of Columbia Records).
Sydney Nathan controlled both the King and Federal
record labels and Florence Greenberg owned the Mafia-influenced
Scepter Records (featuring the Shirelles and Dionne
Warwick. "During the 1960s, Warwick gained fame singing
[Jewish] Burt Bacharach-Hal David compositions such as 'Walk on
By' and 'I Say A Little Prayer.' In 1985, she had a brief
comeback with another Bacharach song, 'That's What Friends Are
For,' sung with Elton John, Stevie Wonder and Gladys Knight.")
[CNN, 5-13-02]
"Those illiterates," Hy Weiss of Olde
Towne once said about his recording artists, "they would
have ended up eating from pails in Delancey Street if it weren't
for us." [WADE, p. 70] "Artists are pains in the asses,' [music
mogul Morris] Levy said. 'A lot of them are just imbeciles.
They're ignorant." [KARLEN, N., 1994, p. 146] "The record
producers were white," says Nadine Cohodas in her book about the
Chess brothers, "their talent for the most part black, many from
impoverished backgrounds and few with much formal education,
living in a society that regarded them as second-class citizens.
The deals between the two parties were not the negotiations of
peers. The relationship coluld be paternalistic, even
condescending. At Chess it sometimes looked as though
Leonard and Phil gave their musicians an allowance rather than a
salary." [COHODAS, N., 2000, p. 4] The history of rock and roll
is, of course," notes Rich Cohen, "riddled with pioneering white
record men who built careers recording, and sometimes,
exploiting black artists: Morris Levy, that burly, cigar-smoking
product of the Brill Building, allegedly stealing writing
credits from Frankie Lyman; Herman Lubinsky, the founder of
Savoy Records in Newark, New Jersey, throwing around nickels as
if they were manhole covers." [COHEN, R., 6-21-01]
In
Philadelphia, in 1984 lawsuits were swirling around WMOT,
a company that "developed a reputation as an aggressive
independent record producer specializing in the 'Philly sound.'"
Formerly owned by Steve Bernstein, Alan Rubens, and David
Chacker, it was acquired by Michael Goldberg, Allen Cohen, and
Jeff and Mark Salvarian. Lawsuits even named Israel's Bank
Leumi among defendants in a scheme to use the record company
to launder drug money. The central player in this accusation was
Larry Lavin, who was indicted as the "kingpin of a 13-member
[drug] ring that allegedly sold $5 million of cocaine a month."
[DAUGHEN, 1984]
By 1978
president Oscar Cohen of the Associate Booking Corporation
presided over "the country's biggest black talent booking
agency." [SHAW, A, p. 419, p. 133]
Recurrent, "mobbed-up" Morris Levy even eventually owned
Birdland in its heyday, the famous jazz club. [WEXLER, p.
130] Levy also controlled the Roulette
Record label. Nat "the Rat" Tarnopol headed the Brunswick
label (Jackie Wilson was one of its most prominent
African-American stars). Tarnopol was indicted twice in the
1970s "for using payola, drugola, and strong-arm goons to get
radio airplay for Brunswick recording artists."
[MCDOUGAL, p. 366]
An early and important supporter of disc
jockey Alan Freed and his own empire was Leo Mintz, who owned a
large record store near Cleveland's Black ghetto. Even earlier,
Eli Oberstein founded Varsity
records in the 1930s, Joe Davis launched Beach records in
1942, and "Jake Friedman had Southland, one of the
biggest distributing outfits in the South." [SHAW, A.,
Honkers, p. 236]
"The whole history of rock 'n' roll,"
noted the London Guardian in a
review of Jewish author Michael Billig's book about the subject,
"has been portrayed as white artists 'ripping off' black music.
Only now [with Billig's volume] has the major Jewish
contribution been acknowledged." [ARNOT, C., 10-4-2000, p. 6]
Atlanta-based Mark Shimmel, for instance, is the CEO of
LaFace Records, which headlines TLC, Usher, Tonik Braxton,
GoodiMob, "and a raft of hot hip-hop artists ... He built
his own company, managing talents as varied as John Denver and
Broadway composer Frank Wildhorn ... He doesn't worry much about
what he calls 'the white guy in the black music business.'"
He has also worked with Huey Lewis, Harry Belafonte, Ray
Charles, and former Eagle Don Henley. [POLLAK, S., 1-7-00]
Looking to the
Hispanic record market, George Goldner founded the Tico,
Rama, and Vee record companies; he also owned a
number of Latino-oriented dance halls. Goldner later founded the
Mafia-influenced Red Bird label. (Goldner once hired a
team of whores to service a deejay convention. He "had the girls
arrive a day early, to sit down and go over his new releases
with them. The idea was for the girls to whisper the names of
those records in the jock's ear while they were making love."
[ELIOT, M., p. 49] By the 1970s, Joseph,
Stanley, and Kenneth Cayre (of New York's Jewish Sephardic
community) owned the Salsoul record label. It was worth
$49 million in sales and held a 70% share of the Latino record
market. [UPBIN, 11-10-99]
In the folk music genre, Albert Grossman
managed the career of Peter Paul and Mary ("known affectionately
in the trade as 'two rabbis and a hooker.'" [PHILLIPS, M., 1986,
p. 16] "This established his reputation as a star maker," notes
Anthony Scaduto, "as some kind of genius manager, even as he was
being criticized for commercializing folk and for being an
excessively sharp operator." [SCADUTO, p. 106] Israel Young ran
the Folklore Center in New York's Greenwich Village in
the 1960s. Fred Weintraub owned the well-known Bitter End
nightclub. Manny Roth ran Cafe Wha? Among the prominent
Jewish folksingers of the era were Bob Dylan, Phil Ochs, Jack
Elliott, Peter Yarrow (of Peter, Paul, and Mary), David Blue
(Cohen), and two (Fred Hellerman and Ronnie Gilbert) of the four
Weavers. Ballad singer Leonard Cohen had
a grandfather who was the first president of the Canadian Jewish
Congress.
Moe Asch (whose father, Sholem, was "the
most widely read Yiddish writer of the twentieth century")
[GOLDSMITH, P., p. 1] headed Folkway Records, the label
that released recordings by Woody Guthrie, Pete Seeger (manager:
Harold Levanthal), Doc Watson, Black blues artist Leadbelly,
Josh White, Black poet Langston Hughes, and ethnic performers
from around the world. (Woody Guthrie's wife, Marjorie
Gleenblatt Mazia, was Jewish, and their child, Cathy Ann, was
"raised as a Jew." [POLLAK, O, p. 12]) Guthrie even lived with
Marjorie in a Jewish neighborhood in Coney Island.
Asch got into the recording business with
a connection to David Sarnoff, the eventual head of NBC-RCA.
[GOLDSMITH, P., p. 60] A later version of
Folkways was Verve/Folkways, which featured Tim
Hardin, Richard Havens, and Jewish artists Laura Nyro and Janis
Ian. (Nyro's original name was Nigro, and her name was changed
for fear that people might call her "Negro.") [KING, T., 2000,
p. 73] Another Jewish entrepreneur, Maynard Solomon, headed
another prominent folk-oriented record label, Vanguard,
which featured Joan Baez, Buffy St. Marie, Eric Anderson, among
others. Another folk label in Chicago, Flying Fish, was
founded by Bruce Kaplan.
Jewish popular
musical performers are many and varied, including the Beastie
Boys ("widely castigated for glorifying sex and violence")
[ANDERSON, 1991, p. 173], Bette Midler, Billy Joel, Barry
Manilow, Randy Newman, Carly Simon (one of the heirs to the
Simon-Schuster publishing house fortune), Helen Reddy, Lesley
Gore, David Lee Roth of Van Halen, Lou ("Take a Walk on the Wild
Side") Reed, [BELL, I., 6-1-93, p. 12] and Mountain's Leslie
[Weinstein] West. Donald Fagen co-founded Steely Dan. Marty
Friedman of Megadeth is Jewish, as is Peter Green of Fleetwood
Mac, Marty Balin of Jefferson Airplane, Marc Knopfler of Dire
Straits, Paul Stanley (Stanley Eisen) and Gene Simmons (born
Chaim Whitz in Haifa, Israel) of Kiss, Perry Farrell (Perry
Bernstein; son of a diamond dealer) of Jane's Addiction, Kevin
Dubrow (lead singer of Quiet Riot), Slash of Guns 'n Roses,
Geddy Lee (of Rush -- born Gar Lee Weinrib), Eric Bloom (lead
singer of Blue Oyster Cult), Robbie Robertson, Warren Zevon,
Jeff Beck, Mick Jones (of the Clash), Gavin Rossdale (head of
Bush), Jay (Blatt) and the Americans, Marc Bolan of T-Rex,
Manfred Mann (Lubowitz), Norman Greenbaum, Phranc (a Jewish
lesbian folksinger), and Howard Kaylan and Mark Volman of the
Turtles. And on and on. Jewish interest in the subject notes
that ukelele-rooted Tiny Tim's mother was Jewish, Donovan's
mother was Jewish, Cyndi Lauper's father is Jewish, Country Joe
MacDonald's mother is Jewish, Twisted Sister's Dee Snider's
father was Jewish and on and on. [JEWHOO, 2000; BOUCHER, G.,
4-17-01, p. 62; TAYLOR, L., 12-27-00, p. F5]] Even the 1998
"Eurovision Song Contest winner" -- featuring an event watched
by 100 million people in 33 countries -- was Israeli transsexual
Dana International, born Yaran Cohen).
Not Jewish? Want to make it in the music business? Enhance
your chances by learning Yiddish:
"Even gentiles learned to salt their language with
pinches of Yiddish, the industry's vernacular. Courtney
Love, not long before her own major label debut at Geffen
Records, began boning up with the help of Leo Rosten's The
Joys of Yiddish. 'I'm going to blow the minds of all those
shemedricks at the record company,' Courtney said.
She would even sometimes refer to her dispute with Kat [of the
all-female band Babes in Toyland] over who was the first
to wear a baby-doll dress onstage as 'that shmatte'
controversy.'" [KARLEN, N., 1994, p. 146]
From France, singer Sergio Gainsbourg [born Lucien
Ginzburg]
"is still most famous in Britain for his number one 'Je
t'aime moi non plus': the
scandalous anthem which was in the British charts 30 years
ago. He and
[actress Jane] Birkin simulated their lovemaking so
effectively that the
single was banned by the BBC and formally condemned by the
Vatican
...Yet Gainsbourg is the greatest popular musician France
has ever produced ...
Echoes of his favourite technique, of murmuring profanities
against
a delicate and beautiful harmony, can be heard in many
contemporary
records, not least the later work of Leonard Cohen ...
Towards the end of his
life, the singer's media apparances beame ritual
provocations: in one
television broadcast, he subjected a veteran paratrooper --
horrified
by Gainsbourg's dub version of the Marseillaise -- to a
torrent of
obscenities, pausing only occasionally, to inflate condoms.
On another notorious
live show, sharing a platform with a young Whitney Houston,
Gainsbourg,
then 58, turned to the presenter Michel Drucker and
declared, in English,
'I want to fuck her.'" [CHALMERS, R., 1-4-00]
The magazine
"Bible" of rock and roll music, Rolling Stone, was also
founded by Jewish entrepreneur Jann Wenner [see elsewhere, Mass
Media chapters]. Wenner also is "the single most important
person behind" Cleveland's Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and
Museum. [HINCKLEY, D., p. 9] Joel Siegel, later prominent as a
film critic, was also "TV's first rock and roll reporter."
[SLEWINSKI, C., 3-23-99, p. 102]
Jerry Wexler,
the Jewish co-director of Atlantic Records -- remembers
with fondness the early rhythm and blues and rock and roll
industry years with a curious perspective:
"How well I remember those labels and
the grizzled infighters who owned
them.
Exclusive (Leon and Otis Rene), Modern (the Biharis),
Imperial
(Lew Chudd),
Specialty (Are Rupe), Old Towne (Hymie Weiss),
Herald/Ember (Al Silver),
Chess (the brothers Chess), and on and on
into the night -- memorable logos,
all. I am reminded of the tribes of the
Sinai desert -- the Hittites, the
Moabites, the Midianites, the Amorites.
Gone, perished, vanished from the
face of the earth. Only one survived --
the Hebrews." [WEXLER, p. 183]
Wexler's
written memories also include stories about other fellow Jews in
the later music world, including the music editor of
Billboard, Paul Ackerman; his early Jewish bosses at MGM
Records -- Abe Olman and Mitch Miller, and A&R men Harry
Myerson at RCA and Morty Palitz at Decca; and Nat
Shapiro, the promotion man at Atlantic.
"What [Wexler] achieved at Atlantic makes him a
key figure in the history of post-war black masterworks."
[HOSKYNS, p. 10] Among Wexler's most famous Black talents was
Aretha Franklin. Also, "throughout the 1950s and 1960s, Jerry
Wexler worked with several of the most influential R&B singers
ever to hit the charts: Wilson Pickett, Otis Redding, Clyde
McPhatter, the Drifters, Joe Tex, Ray Charles, Ruth Brown, the
Clovers, Joe Turner, and La Vern Baker, to name a few.
Rolling Stone has gone so far as to christen him 'the
Godfather of Rhythm and Blues.'" [BEGO, M., 1989, p. 90] In the
building of Atlantic Records to power, non-Jewish
co-founder Ahmet Ertegun feared collusion between Wexler and two
Jewish songwriters, Jerry Lieber and Mike Stoller, to oust him.
[HOSYKYNS, p. 10] (Jerry Greenberg was also "one of
Ertegun's top lieutenants at Atlantic." [KING, T., p. 166]
Jewish mogul David Geffen once tried to create a rumor that
Ertegun was anti-Semitic which "could hurt Ertegun's business."
[KING, T., 2000, p. 292]
In 1992, Bill McKibben noted an
interesting piece of music trivia that he had heard about on
television:
"Neil Sedaka went to the same high
school as Neil Diamond and Barbara
Streisand, and while he was there he
wrote a song about a girl called
Carole Klein who went on to become
Carole King and of course had
several number one records."
[MCKIBBEN, p. 20]
The author
doesn't mention it, but, rather curiously, aside from the fact
that they all became famous pop singers, they were also all
Jewish. In fact, in the early 1960s, Don Kirschner and partner
Al Nevins had a company called Aldon Music as a kind of
last outpost of the seminal Tin Pan Alley complex at the
so-called "Brill Building" in New York City. Their hirees
(mainly song writers at that time) were virtually all Jewish,
including Carole King, Gerry Goffin, Barry Mann, Cynthia Weill,
Neil Diamond, Neil Sedaka, and Howard Greenflens. Later came
Phil Spector, Jeff Barry, Ellie Greenwich, Doc Pomus, Mort
Shuman, Burt Bacharach, Hal David, Jerry Leiber, and Mike
Stoller. [SCHEURER, T., p. 90] Ellie
Greenwich and Jeff Barry, notes Rich Wiseman, were "one of the
hottest songwriter teams in pop." [WISEMAN, p. 31]
"To my surprise," writes Jewish
author Michael Billig,
"song after well-known pop song,
revealed itself to 'Jewish music,' from
[Elvis] Presley to the soft sounds
of the drifters to [producer] Phil
Spector. So much of the
rebellion-music which I had loved in my
youth and which seemed to be a
window to a foreign, dangerous
world, turned out to be a product
of familiar surroundings. Surprise
was mixed with delight." [ARNOT,
C., 10-4-2000, p. 6]
In the 1960s
era, the Beatles' agent/manager, Brian Epstein, was Jewish, as
was the promoter, Sid Bernstein ("New York's leading promoter in
the mid-sixties," [GLATT, p. 87] of their
early Carnegie Hall and Shea Stadium concerts. The head of
Bernstein's employer -- the General Artist Corporation --
was Norman Weiss, also Jewish. A Jewish
entrepreneur in America, Irwin Pincus, "secured foreign rights
on six original Beatles recordings." [ELIOT, M, p. 127] These
seminal tunes appeared on the Vee Jay label (which also
recorded the popular Four Seasons) in the early months of
"Beatlemania' in America. (Meanwhile, the state of Israel banned
the Beatles from performing there in 1965 "for fear of the
decadent affect it would have on Israel's youth)." [FRANKEL, G.,
p. 273] Sandy Gallin (also Jewish and, like Epstein, gay) "shot
to stardom after booking the Beatles for their legendary 1964
American debut on The Ed Sullivan Show." [KING, T., 2000, p. 93]
"The daughter of prosperous furniture manufacturers in
Sheffield," says Albert Goldman, "[Brian Epstein's mother] had
been educated in a school dominated by Roman Catholics, an
experience that led to her to attribute all her subsequent
misfortunes in life to anti-Semitism, another trait Brian
adopted." [GOLDMAN] "At age ten," adds
Chet Flippo, "[Brian] was expelled from Liverpool College for
scrawling dirty pictures. He and his mother attributed the
expulsion to anti-Semitism." [FLIPPO, C., 1988, p. 143] Both
Epstein's parents "were from prominent Jewish families in
Liverpool" and he was an heir to his family's NEMS
company: the North End Music Store chain, which was
purchased in the 1930s. [FLIPPO, C., 1988, p. 143] "Brian
didn't care that much about the Beatles' music," writes Flippo,
"They knew that early on and he always acknowledged it. He had
absolutely no experience in managing a group and the Beatles
knew that. His contacts, such as they were, were with the
business side of record companies." [FLI_PPO, C., 1988, p. 142]
Epstein, notes the Jewish Forward, was a
"gay, Jewish record-department manager -- of the Liverpool
store owned by his
parents -- who met the Beatles and in little more than a
year turned them into the
most successful musical act in the world. The life of the
Beatles' first manager
has been familiar to Beatles fans for decades, though
always as one of the sideshows
to the record-shattering main attraction. With the focus
reversed, some arresting
tidbits emerge, such as when Paul McCartney explains his
father's immediate
approval of Epstein. 'He thought Jewish people were very
good with money,'
Mr. McCartney says. 'That was the common wisdom. He
thought Brian would
be very good for us ... And he was right ... If anyone was
the fifth Beatle, it was
Brian.' MANDELL, B., 2001]
A biography of
Epstein is entitled "The Man Who Made the Beatles."
"While none of his performing artists were Jews," notes
author Roy Coleman, "Brian veered towards the company of Jews in
the music business, and some of his senior colleagues were Jews:
Nat Weiss, Dick James [originally Richard Leon Vapnick], Dan
Black, Vic Lewis, Bernard Lee." [COLEMAN, p. 345]
Weiss became partners with Epstein in a company called
Nemperor Artists. Another Beatle-based company (called
Stramsact in London and Seltaeb in America) was
formed, in conjunction with Epstein's lawyer, David Jacobs, to
merchandize everything from Beatles chewing gum to wallpaper.
Jacobs funneled considerable Beatles business in America to
famous Los Angeles Jewish lawyer Marvin Mitchelson. [JENKINS, p.
85]
David Jacobs, note Peter Brown and
Steven Gaines,
"adored the young Brian Epstein and
took him under his wing. The
two men were similar in many
coincidental ways. Their families were
both in the furniture business, both
were born and bred of money,
and both had doting Jewish mothers.
Both were homosexual. David
Jacobs became Brian's chief
solicitor. From then on, all legal decisions
and contracts would be made with
David Jacobs' advice."
[BROWN/GAINES, 1983, p. 122]
Victor Lewis,
also Jewish, was the Managing Director of yet another Epstein
company, NEMS Enterprises. The Beatles had a 10% interest
in this company that was based on their profitability; Epstein
and his brother held the other 90%. [COLEMAN, p. 305] As
Decca writer Tony Barrow once noted, "As for hiring of staff,
what John Lennon said to me upon our introduction -- 'if you're
not queer and you're not Jewish, why are you joining NEMS?'
-- proved to be pretty accurate. They weren't all Jewish, but
that was the ideal combination of the two things that were most
close to [Epstein] or his family's heart." [COLEMAN, p. 178]
Nemperor Holdings (formerly NEMS) was eventually sold to
Jewish businessman Leonard Richenberg of Triumph Trust. "Trust
became a 90 percent holder of Nemperor ... The Beatles were
stunned that they had lost Nemperor." After various legal
threats, they managed to reacquire it). [BROWN/GAINES, 1983, p.
322]
The
aforementioned Jewish businessman, Dick James, controlled the
Beatles' publishing licenses and was their publisher at
Northern Songs. James, note Peter Brown and Steven Gaines,
"became the for the Beatles a symbol
of the music business. He was
a balding Jewish 'uncle' to the boys,
a man with a big cigar and a sly
smile, who taught John and Paul one
of the biggest lessons of their
lives ... John and Paul would form a
songwriting partnership called
Northern Songs ... Dick James,
in return for his responsibilities as
a music publisher, would get 50
percent of the earnings. In literal
terms Brian [Epstein] signed over to
Dick James 50 percent of
Lennon and
McCartney's publishing fees for nothing. It made him
wealthy beyond imagination in
eighteen months." [BROWN/GAINES,
1983, p. 186]
Chet Flippo notes the context of Epstein's death (an
overdose of sleeping pills):
"There were immediate rumors then, just as there are rumors
now, that
Brian Epstein was murdered as the end result of one or
another of the
many business deals that he had cut regarding the Beatles.
There were so
many murky deals, involving so many people and so much
money, that
it could even have been a deal that he failed to do that
might have resulted
in such rumors of vendetta and revenge. Subsequent court
hearings
over the years have showed that the Beatles were probably
-- there is no
information for this kind of data -- the most underpaid
superstar
performers ever. Given thier worldwide acclaim and the
milions of records
they sold, one would have imagined that they were
millionaires many times
over. That was hardly the case ... As Paul [McCartney]
especially had started to
try to dig into the Beatle business books, which they had
never even thought
to do during the Fab Beatlemania years, suspicions of Brian
had started
bubbling to the surface." [FLIPPO, C., 1988, pl. 244]
Also after
Epstein's death, in 1969 James sold the rights to the Beatles
songs from under them. "It was the single most contentious deal
arising from the Epstein-James era," says Coleman. "The Beatles
were angry at what they regarded as betrayal." [COLEMAN, p. 306]
Marc Elliot notes that James sold "his interest in
Northern Songs to the notorious [British Jewish media mogul]
Lew Grade, known in the film industry as Low Grade." [ELLIOT, p.
158] Epstein also had "good
communication" with Grade's brother, Bernard Delfont, "one of
the czars of London show business." [COLEMAN, p. 245-246]
Epstein also managed the career of
singer Cilia Black. "After Cilia's performance [in New York
City]," notes Brown and Gaines,
"Brian threw a party for her in a
hotel suite upstairs. The party was
crowded with press and New York show
business personalities when
some woman within Brian's earshot
remarked that the lobby of the
Plaza Hotel looked 'Jewish.' Brian
flew into a wild rage. The party
came to a halt around him as he
screamed, 'Madame, I happen to
be Jewish!’.... It was a small
miracle the incident didn't find its
way into the press." [BROWN/GAINES,
1983, p. 183]
Moving in the
circles of rich and powerful, notes Coleman, "Brian had struck
up a particularly warm rapport in London with Bernice Kinn, wife
of the owner of the New Musical Express. An ebullient,
intuitive Jew, she and her husband Maurice formed part of the
core of London's 1960s show business hosts and party goers."
[COLEMAN, p. 245-246] Another of Epstein's "close friends" was
Lionel Bart (Beglieter), the Jewish song writer for many of pop
star Cliff Richard's songs, and originator of the musical score
for the musical play, Oliver! [PRESS ASSOCIATION
NEWSFILE, 4-3-99]
The Beatles'
"official photographer" during their peak years (1962-67) was
Jewish -- Dezo Hoffman. Paul McCartney's wife Linda (Eastman --
originally Epstein) was also Jewish. [GILBERT, G., 1996, p. 77,
172] Eastman's father also became active in legal squabbles
between the Beatles, especially between McCartney and Lennon.
McCartney's lawyer in this contentious era, Charles Corman, was
an Orthodox Jew. [BROWN/GAINES, 1983, p. 333] The producers of
the Beatles first movie, A Hard Day's Night, were Walter
Shenson and Bud Orenstein. Richard Lester directed the movie,
and is also Jewish. [JEWHOO; online] Famous Jewish singer Bob
Dylan (Robert Zimmerman) introduced the Beatles to marijuana the
first time he met them, a gathering arranged by music writer Al
Aronowitz. [BROWN/GAINES, 1983, p. 150]
After John
Lennon's death, another Jewish agent, Elliot Mintz, has been for
years Yoko Ono's publicist (he has also worked as a public
relations man for Bob Dylan, and other capacities with pop
singers throughout the years).
Immediately after Lennon's assassination, an employee, Fred
Seaman, and his "old college roommate," "psychiatrist and New
York diamond dealer" Bob Rosen, set up a network (termed
"Project Walrus") to market Lennon's stolen journals and other
memorabilia. [MINTZ, 1991]
One of the most
famous popular music producers of the 1960s -- Phil Spector --
was also Jewish. Specter was renowned for his strange
temperament and a music style described as a "wall of sound."
"Philip was a very strange person," remarked pop singer Sonny
Bono, "He always had a tough time staying rational, a real tough
time." [WADE, p. 100] Specter also
founded Phillips Records with partner Lester Sil. "The
most famous pop producer [Spector] of them all," noted the
Los Angeles Times in 1988,
"was a bigger superstar than any
singers among his bullpen he kept on
hand to belt out wonderfully
disposable ditty after ditty -- and he kept
it that way by issuing most of the
singles under the name of some generic
group, not the actual lead singer."
[WILLMAN, C., 10-11-88,
CALENDAR, p. 10]
Another top
Jewish manager, Allen Klein -- starting out with clients like
Steve Lawrence and Eydie Gorme (both Jewish), Bobby Darin, and
Sam Cooke -- eventually owned the Cameo Parkway company,
managing many of the biggest British musical acts of the 1960s,
including the Rolling Stones (whose early agent was Sandy
Lieberson), the Yardbirds, the Kinks, the Animals, and Donovan.
Eventually, upon Brian Epstein's death, Klein even managed the
Beatles' Apple company. "Klein was a New York
accountant," notes Mark Hertsgaard, "whose foulmouthed
personality and street-fighter instincts masked a razor-sharp
financial mind but helped explain his propensity for attracting
lawsuits and tax fraud accusations." [HERTSGAARD, p. 287] "At
the peak of his career," says Phillip Norman, "his company was
involved in fifty lawsuits," [NORMAN, p. 184] including one with
the Beatles. The Rolling Stones once sued Klein for $29 million.
[SANDFORD, p. 164]
Christopher Sandford notes that
"By midsummer [Rolling Stones singer
Mick] Jagger was unable to
mention his manager's name [Klein]
calmly. Later he gave an
interview in which he stated, 'Half
the money I've made has been
stolen. Most artists in show business
suffer the same kind of thing...
It's all the hangers-on and
parasites. There are very few honest
people in the profession." [SANDFORD,
p. 139]
Klein had this
interchange with a Playboy interviewer in 1971:
"Q: Would you lie?
A: Oh, sure.
Q: Would you steal?
A: Probably. Look. You have to
survive. Whatever it takes ... It's a
game for
Chrissakes and winning is everything."
[GARFIELD, p.
257]
Another legendary Jewish manager,
Albert Grossman, was "probably the best-known, most successful,
and aggressive artist's manager in the music business."
[SCADUTO, p. 105] He ran the careers of Bob Dylan, Janis Joplin,
Jimi Hendrix, and many other top musical artists. (When
Grossman's business manager, Dick Asher, signed Joplin to a
contract, he never forgot what she said to him: "I hope you
didn't fuck us too much." [DANNEN, p. 76] The early booking
agent for Joplin's Big Brother and the Holding Company band was
Todd Schiffman; its manager was Julius Karpen.
Bob Dylan was
also signed to a song-licensing deal by Lou Levy, and later by
Artie Mogull ("a hustler") [KING, T., 2000, p. 72] at M. Witmark
and Sons. Early in songwriter's career, "when a girlfriend's
mother challenged his lies and said she thought Zimmerman was
his real name, he called her an anti-Semite, as if a mere
description of the truth was bigotry." [RUBIN, p. 94] Dylan, who
early in his career hid his Jewish past and made up various lies
(he was from Oklahoma, etc.) about his background, nonetheless
joined the Jewish fraternity house at the University of
Minnesota in 1959, Sigma Alpha Mu. [SCADUTO, p. 26] After
becoming rich and famous singing about social justice, in the
1980s, "Dylantologist" A. J. Weberman declared that the famous
singer "is an ultra-Zionist. He is doing the tour to raise money
for Israel. He has given large sums of money to Israel in the
name of Abraham Zimmerman." [SPITZ, p. 430]
Newsweek and Time each reported that Dylan
had indeed donated sums to the Jewish state, and even the far
right-wing Jewish Defense League. [SPITZ, p. 407] A biographer,
Anthony Scaduto, noted earlier, in 1971,
"At this writing, Dylan's search for
personal salvation seems to be
coming around full circle, back to
the religion of his fathers. Bob
has started to study Judaism, and
Hebrew. Dylan, who gets so
Gemini-enthused about everything, has
made several trips to
Israel in the last year to 'sniff the
breeze' as his friends put it. He
has reportedly donated some of his
funds to help support at least
one kibbutz there. Folksinger Theo
Bikel [also Jewish, and a
Zionist activist] adds: 'Dylan has
told me that Israel appears to be
one of the few places left in the
world where life has any meaning.'
He has even attended several meetings
of the militant Jewish
Defense League. The JDL's head, Meir
Kahane, [charged by many,
including Jews, as a racist and
fascist] will say only that Dylan has
'come around a couple times to see
what we're all about' and has
promised to donate money to the
organization. Dylan refuses to discuss
it." [SCADTO, p. 274]
By 1977, the
biggest rock concert promoters were San Francisco-based Bill
Graham (a Jewish Holocaust survivor originally named Wolfgang
Wolodia Granjanka, the owner of the famous hippie Filmore
Ballroom who had named his own northern California estate after
the mythic Israelite fortress, Masada), Concerts West, Concert
Associates, Chicago's Frank Fried, and in New York, Ron Delsener
and Howard Stein. [CHAPPLE, p. 152] In
1976, Howard Stein (whose "father, Jack 'Ruby' Stein, had been a
loan shark, ... ended up floating down the Hudson, sans head")
[HADEN-GUEST, ., 1997, p. 66] noted that the field of his
endeavors in musical concert production had a "territorial
overtone":
"It's hard for a major concert
producer to get started in New York City
and do battle with Delsener and
myself. It's equally difficult for a major
concert producer to establish
himself against Frank Fried and myself in
Chicago. In Miami, I virtually
don't consider myself as having any real
competition. In Atlanta, minor
competition. In Texas, some competition.
In New York there are three:
Delsener, myself, and Jerry Weintraub. Bill
Graham on the West coast ... The
power of an impresario or a concert
producer is through associations.
It's very political. It's very personal.
It's building
reciprocal relationships." [LEVINE, F. p. 262]
Jon Fischel at
Billboard magazine named Jerry Weintraub and Bill Graham
(sometimes described as the "Godfather of Rock and Roll") as the
"most powerful men in the [rock concert] business" in their era.
[LEVINE, p. 275] "As Bill Graham became increasingly successful
and achieved celebrity status in San Francisco," says John
Glatt, "he faced a growing hostility from many people who saw
him as a capitalist pig growing rich on the backs of the Love
Generation." [GLATT, p. 61]
By the 1970s,
lawyer Allan Grubman (whose partner was Arthur Indursky) became
"the biggest music attorney in the history of rock and roll."
[DANNEN, p. 144] Grubman, Indursky, Schindler, & Goldstein have
been "the country's leading rock-and-roll law firm." [Karlen,
N.,, 1994, p. 59] Irving Azoff, "one of the most loathed men in
the movie business," eventually headed the Front Line
management firm, "the top management firm in rock and roll."
[DANNEN, p. 134] Top man at Front Line
after Azoff? Howard Kaufman. [KING, T., 2000, p. 436] Azoff,
short in stature, is known by enemies in the Hollywood world as
the "Poison Dwarf." Azoff's acts included the Eagles, Boz
Scaggs, Dan Fogelberg, Steely Dan, REO Speedwagon, Joe Walsh,
and many others. Azoff eventually headed MCA, and later
Giant Records. When he was president of MCA, three
of four vice-presidents were also Jewish: Myron Roth, Zach
Horowitz, and Larry Solters. [KNOEDELSEDER, p. 26]
The Leber-Krebs agency became "one of the biggest
management companies in rock"; their acts included Aerosmith and
Ted Nugent. Dan Weiner founded the rock
talent agency, Monterey Peninsula Associates. John and
David Handleman (the Handleman Company) eventually became
the largest rock and roll "jobbers" (distributors) in the United
States; in 1991 they bought out their largest rival, also
Jewish-founded -- Lieberman
Enterprises. [HULL, p. 181] "Almost every time you buy an
LP, cassette, compact disc or book at K mart," says Tim Kiska,
"you're putting a few dimes in the Handleman family fortune."
[KISKA, p. 91]
Lou Adler
(formerly teamed with fellow-Jewish mogul Herb Alpert) was the
backbone producer of the influential Monterey Pop Festival and
head of the Ode record label. (Alpert and another Jewish
partner, Jerry Moss, also founded A&M Records. Adler, Jay
Lasker, and Bobby Roberts also headed Dunhill Records --
which highlighted the Mamas and Papas, etc.) [PHILLIPS, M.,
1986, p. 72] The Monterey festival was originally conceived by
Benny Shapiro and Alan Pariser who sold the project to Adler and
Michelle Phillips. [HOSKYNS, 1996, p. 142] Ray
Manarek remembers when he and the rest of the Doors rock group
went (before they became famous) to Adler's office, hoping he
would sign them to a recording contract:
"He rejected the whole demo. Ten seconds on each song ...
and we were dismissed
out of hand. Just like that. He took the demo off the
turntable and handed it back
to me with an obsequious smile and said, 'Nothing here I
can use.' We were shocked.
We stood up, the three of us, and [lead singer] Jim
[Morrison], with a wry and
knowing smile on his lips, cuttingly and cooly shot
back at him, 'That's okay, man.
We don't want to be used, anyway.'" [MANZAREK, R.,
1998, p. 153]
The landmark
1969 Woodstock Musical Festival was the entrepreneurial
investment of four young Jews: Joel Rosenman, John Roberts (heir
to a pharmaceutical fortune), Artie Kornfeld, and Michael Lang.
The person hired to pull the whole project together was
Stanley Goldstein. Mel Laurence (born Melvin Bernard Lachs) was
also the Director of Operations for the festival creators,
Woodstock Ventures. Bert Cohen, of Concert Hall
Publications, soon joined the production team for various
tasks. [SPITZ, 1979] The first employee of Woodstock ventures
was Rene Levine, a bookkeeper and another Jew, Alex Jaffee, was
the company's accountant. In a book chapter called "Buying Off
the Underground," Joel Rosenman recalls when he and others of
the Woodstock Ventures investment team went to Greenwich
Village's East Village Other "counterculture" newspaper
to buy them off, guaranteeing that prominent members of that
anti-capitalist community wouldn't cause problems with the
economic exploitation of the supposedly anti-materialist Love
Generation. Famed radical (and Jewish) agitator Abbie Hoffman
demanded $10,000 from Woodstock Ventures, "or else that
fucking festival you guys are planning is gonna end up around
your ass." [ROSENMAN/ROBERTS/PILPEL, p. 102]
Others involved
in the Woodstock project included Judi Bernstein (business
manager for the sound company that handled the festival; she
later became executive director of Boston's Zionist Hadassah
Organization) and her husband Harold Cohen; Lee Blumer
(Assistant to the Director of Security); Steve Cohen (who was
"largely responsible for designing and building the Woodstock
stage"); Len Kaufman (who "headed the 'elite black shirt'
security force"); and Rona Elliot (who worked in Woodstock
Ventures public relations and later became the music
correspondent for NBC's Today show). Many of the
Woodstock musical artists were even boarded at the famous Jewish
resort hotel in the Catskill Mountains, Grossinger's.
Even Max Yasgur, the dairy farmer whose land was used for the
festival, was Jewish. [JEWHOO]
One of the four
Woodstock festival entrepreneurs, Artie Kornfeld, was vice
president of Capitol Records (1967-68). He "wrote and
produced all the Cowsills' stuff." In later Kornfeld recalled
how Woodstock was started:
"My secretary said, 'There's a
Michael Lang here to see you.' And I said,
'Who's Michael Lang?' And she said,
'He says he's from your old
neighborhood.' And I said, 'Well, if
he's from the neighborhood, tell him
to come in.' Bensonhurst. It's a
section of Brooklyn that's all Jewish and
Italian. That's how he got to see
me; by saying he was from the
neighborhood.'" [MAKOWER, p. 25]
The two men
shared some marijuana in Kornfeld's office. Later, discussing
the grand idea of a gigantic music festival, Kornfeld notes that
much "was basically talked out that night, that first night,
probably behind some Colombian blond, which had something to do
with it. Overachieving, pseudo-intellectual Jewish kids with an
idea that came from outside of us, I believe. It was the
culture." [MAKOWER, p. 27] The two men later paid a visit to
join forces with Rosenman and Roberts (later partners in a
venture capitalist firm called J.R. Capital) and
Woodstock was born.
The disastrous
1999 Woodstock Festival was also headed by Michael Lang, and
John Scher. It ended in rioting, vandalism, injuries, arrests,
and sexual crimes. [MORSE, S., 7-27-99] Also in the
rock-and-roll entrepreneurial world, "the first Lollapalooza,"
notes Neal Karlen, "was held in 1991 as the brainchild of Perry
Farrell [born Perry Bernstein], former leader of the defunct
Jane's Addiction. That summer's eight band line-up drew 430,000
fans, grossed $10 million, and was the surprise smash of the
entire [music] industry."
[KARLEN, N., 1994, p. 160]
Another Jewish
entrepreneur, Harold Leventhal, promoted folk acts like the
Weavers and Woody Guthrie. "Jefferson Airplane was the creation
of [their manager] Matthew Katz." [GLATT, p. 57] Danny Rifkind
managed the Grateful Dead. Paul Rothchild produced the Doors
(and many other groups); Jac Holzman, head of Elektra, signed
them to his record label. [DENSMORE, J., 1990, p. 79] (Todd
Schiffman signed them to a talent agency). [KING, T., 2000, pl.
97] Rothchild was so integral to the Doors that band member Ray
Manzarek calls him "the fifth Door." [Manzarek, R., 1998, p.
203] Manzarek recalls Elektra owner Jac Holzman's attitude
towards his best-selling group:
"We were all excited at the prospects of breaking the
cherry of a brand-new, state-
of-the-art [Elektra] recording studio. And we thought it was
going to be for free.
Hell, Jac Holzman built the damned place with profits from
the Doors' record
sales. Everybody called the new Elektra facility on La
Cienga 'the house the
Doors built,' so why shouldn't we record for free? Besides,
it was an in-house
studio. It would be for all Elektra artists. Outsiders
could hire the studio at the
going rates, but Elketra's own people could record there
anytime they wanted
and for free. Right? We were excited. Wouldn't you be?
Bullshit! No free
time. No freebee recording sessions. Everybody paid.
Strangers or family ...
everybody paid. However, Jac did say ... 'Boys, I'll tell
you what I'm going
to do. For you ...' And you could see the calculator in his
head whirling.
You could see that he wanted to be generous to us, he was
on the West
Coast now, he wore love beads, he had grown his hair long,
he was not a
crass materialist, he was new man who believed in peace and
love for all
races, religions, creeds, nationalities. But he was also
from New York.
'For you ... a ten percent discount!'
I almost snorted in his face. [Lead
singer] Jim [Morrison] just spun
around on his heels, unable to face Jac." [MANZAREK, R.,
1998, p. 302]
Early in their career the Doors practiced at home
of Stu and Marilyn Kreiger in wealthy Pacific Palisades.
[MANZAREK, R., 1998, p. 149] This was the home of the parents of
Doors guitarist Robby Kreiger, also Jewish. Heiress Naomi
Hirschorn literally bought the Byrds their first musical
instruments. [CROSBY/GOTTLEIB, p. 86]
Terry Melcher (whose father was Jewish) managed both the
Byrds and Paul Revere and the Raiders. [WYNN, N., 1990, p. 197]
Herb Gart "handled" the Youngbloods. [KING, T., 2000, p. 66]
David Kapralik managed Sly and the Family Stone and Barbara
Streisand. [SCADUTO, p. 105] Nik Cohn, a music critic for the
Manchester Guardian, and later the New York Times,
provided Peter Townsend of The Who important criticism in the
development of his rock opera "Tommy." Townsend, notes Larry
Smith, had a "willingness to compromise his work for a favorable
review from [this] respected journalist/friend." [SMITH, L.,
1999, p. 3] In 2002, just before a
new Who tour, bassist John Entwistel died. And this is who
announced the bad news:
"John Entwistle, the bassist for the innovative 1960s rock band
The Who, was found dead Thursday in his hotel room of an
apparent heart attack ... The Vegas show was canceled but the
rest of the tour was undecided, said Beckye Levin of
promoter Clear Channel Entertainment. 'I was told he passed away
in his sleep last night,' Levin said, breaking into sobs
during a telephone interview. Who manager Robert Rosenberg
said he was 'saddened and shocked.'"
The Beach Boys story eventually centered around
key member Brian Wilson's destructive drug habit and his
controlling psychotherapist, Eugene Landy [see elsewhere for the
story of Landy's exploitation of his famous patient]. The band's
road manager was also Jewish, Arnie Geller. At the peak of his
success, Wilson also married a 16-year old Jewish girl, Marilyn
Rovell. His autobiography was also written by Todd Gold, who was
hired by Wilson and his psychotherapist Landy, to create the
book (portraying the controversial Landy in an extremely
favorable light) from tape-recorded interviews.
Top rock act
Creedance Clearwater Revival was effectively destroyed largely
by its Jewish overseers. The group signed with Fantasy
Records in 1964. In 1967 the company was bought by Jewish
entrepreneur Saul Zaentz (he also produced the films One Flew
Over the Cuckoo's Nest and Amadeus). When CCR soon
began a string of hit records, the group demanded a royalty
increase, per a clause in their contract. Zaentz refused, but
led the group to an acquaintance, an unscrupulous (and
mob-linked) Jewish lawyer named Bruce Kanter, who developed a
complicated scheme to secure the rock group's earnings in a much
lower tax bracket. Kanter shifted much of Creedance's money into
tax dodge companies created in the Bahamas; one such Kanter
company was called King David Distributors, and later
Sholom (Hebrew for peace) LTD. [BLOCK, A., p.
268-269]
As Alan Block notes:
"Over the years the Creedance
Clearwater Revival repatriated much
of their
Castle [another Kanter-related firm] money by borrowing
it from companies they actually
owned, or thought they controlled,
under Kanter's
plan. Nevertheless, when Castle went bust it took
$4 million of the group's and [leader
singer/writer] John Fogerty's
money. Before that happened John
Fogerty desperately tried to
extricate
himself from Castle and the Kanter grasp ... Fogerty was
particularly angry with Saul Zaentz
because he held him responsible
for bringing the group into the
Kanter scheme." [BLOCK, p. 271]
In the mess,
Fogerty also lost the rights to every song he wrote with the
band. [BLOCK, A., p. 271] In 1983, the
group won a lawsuit of $1.5 million against Kanter for his part
in the Creedance problems. The next year, recording again,
Fogerty lyrics in his Centerfield album included obvious
references to Zaentz that could certainly infer anti-Semitic
overtones. He was described as a "little pig" who is "silent and
quick / just like Oliver Twist." [BLOCK, A., p. 272-273]
African-American singing superstar
Diana Ross, originally of the Supremes, married a Jewish
Hollywood public relations agent, Robert Silberstein, in 1971.
J. Randy Taraborrelli, in his biography of Ross, suggests
careerist dimensions to the marriage:
"Why Diana Ross decided to marry Bob
Silberstein remains a mystery
today. If the two of them were in
love, it was the best kept secret
in Hollywood ... Bob Silberstein was
both white and Jewish. Diana's
appearance and singing style were
meant to appeal to Caucasians, so
a white husband would certainly not
hurt her image -- in fact, it would
enhance it -- and Jewish men were
perceived to be shrewd and
intelligent." [TARABORRELLI, p. 249]
(African-American singer-actress star
Diahann Carroll's first two husbands were also Jewish: Monte Kay
(owner of the Birdland jazz nightclub), and Freddie Glusman,
head of a Las Vegas dress shop. The second marriage collapsed
after Glusman beat her).
Harvey Goldsmith is the manager of
rock star Elton John, among others. He is recognized as "the
best known rock promoter in England." [GRAHAM/GREENFIELD, p.
551] Doug Goldstein manages Guns 'n Roses. (Jerry Heller and
Samuel Frankel manage Guns 'n Roses guitarist Slash. [SNYDER,
N., 2-19-01] Steven Levine produced Culture Club. Jerry Meyer
"became one of the top independent record promoters in the
country. He was part of an informal group of about 10 promoters
known at the Network, which dominated airplay on Top 40 radio
during the '70s and '80s. The Network had the power to make or
break records ... [Meyer] loves music, which next to his Jewish
faith, has been the constant of his life." [VIOLANTI, p. 8M]
Rock superstar Bruce Springsteen
fell under the control of two agents of Jewish heritage, first
"the tutelage of sharpie Mark
Appel, who simultaneously managed
him, ran the production company
through which his contracts were
signed, and owned his
publishing.... [Springsteen] managed to escape
... Appel through a series of
lawsuits prompted by rock critic/social
climber Jon
Landau. Landau ran Rolling Stone's record review section
even as he worked as a producer
for major record labels ... Landau
came out the other end
Springsteen's manager, producer, and best
friend and confidant." [DOHERTY,
p. 54]
Reviewer Brian Doherty noted Landau's
portrayal in a rock and roll history book as "an unethical,
anti-art, money-grubbing climber." [DOHERTY, p. 54]
Elsewhere,
Dick Friedberg was a partner at the Premier rock and roll
management service. Gil Freisen became the president of A&M
Records (Janet Jackson, Sting, et al). Herb Abrahamson was a
cofounder of Atlantic Records. Norman Granz owned
Verve. Jac Holzman founded Elektra Records with "$600
of bar mitzvah money." (President of Elektra? Mel Posner. [KING,
T., 2000, p. 245] Simon Waronker and cousin Herb Newman founded
Liberty Records in 1955 (Ricky Nelson, Jan and Dean,
Bobby Vee, Fats Domino, Johnny Rivers, the Ventures, etc.).
Newman also founded another label, Era. Ted Wallerstein
headed RCA records in its formative years. Art Kass, Phil
Steinberg, Hy Mizrahi, and Artie Ripp founded the Kama Sutra
recording label (financed in part by a known mobster, [WADE, p.
118] and later Buddah. Buddah producers Jerry
Kasentz and Jeff Katz helped develop the trivial genre of
"bubblegum music," including the 1910 Fruitgum Company and Ohio
Express. Both groups had the same lead singer, Joey Levine.
[DANNEN, p. 164] Don Kirshner is credited with the supervision
of the quintessential media-illusory artificial band, the
Monkees; three of the four band members didn't even know how to
play an instrument. Jewish film moguls Burt Schneider and Bob
Rafelson were their creators. Bob Ezrin's Migration Records
features acts like Peter Gabriel, Aerosmith, Lou Reed, Robert
Flack, Kiss, et al. Trauma Records (owned by Rob Kahane
and Paul Palmer) has featured acts like No Doubt, Bush, and
basketball star Shaquille O'Neal. Israeli arms dealer and
Hollywood mogul Arnon Milchan sought to purchase Trauma
in the late 1990s and merge it into his own Restless Records
company.
Eventually most
of the small record labels were bought out or rendered extinct
by large mega-media corporations. "The term 'oligopoly' is an
apt one to describe today's record business," wrote Frederic
Dannen in 1990, "Most Americans get nearly all their wares from
six suppliers -- CBS, Warners
[including the labels: Warners, Atlantic, Atco,
Elektra, Asylum, Reprise], BMG
[the initials of the Bertelsmann Music Group, which
includes RCA], Capitol-EMI, Poly-Gram
[including Mercury, Polydor, London,
Vertigo, Verve, Wing, A&M, Island,
Motown], and MCA [including
Decca, ABC-Dunhill, MCA, Geffen,
DGC, GRP] ... Far out in front there are the big two
... A whopping one-third [of the record business] belongs to
CBS and Warners ... Today CBS and Warners
can be viewed as the record industry's equivalent of the
world's two superpowers." [DANNEN, p. 112]
For years CBS Records was headed by
Walter Yetnikoff. "The heart of Yetnikoff's persona," notes
Dannen, "was his Brooklyn Jewishness ... An outsized number of
[record] label bosses were Jews from Brooklyn, but Walter wore
his ethnicity like a gabardine ... [He] fit well with the record
business which was culturally Jewish ...
The goyim. With Walter it was always Us versus Them. When
CBS Records had its annual convention in London, Walter
forbade his people to stay at the Dorchester Hotel because it
was Arab-owned ... One of Walter's inconsistencies was that he
dated only gentile women, preferring well-endowed blondes.
Before his twenty-five marriage broke up in the early eighties,
he had already begun to amass a stable of such girlfriends --
his 'shiksa farm.'" [DANNEN, p. 23]
Yentnikoff was a "close friend" of record industry mobster
Morris Levy, as was Sheldon Levy, another president of CBS
Records. "Walter grew fond of Morris," says Frederic Dannen,
"and spent time at [Morris] Levy's farm." [DANNEN, p. 34]
(To
rock star Sting's credit, in 2001 he resisted unspecified
"media" pressures to censor an Arab out of one of his songs. As
the Associated Press noted, "Sting told the [Arab
American Institute Foundation] that some people in the media had
advised him not to put out his duet with Algerian vocalist Cheb
Mami as a singer, 'because of the Arab guy singing at the front.
'They said, 'If you take him out, we'll play it on the radio.' I
said, 'No can do. It's an integral part of the song.' His
remarks drew cheers from Arab Americans across the
ballroom.") [ASSOCIATED PRESS, 5-2-01]
Bertelsmann Music Group (BMG)
is a giant German-based entertainment conglomerate. The
president and CEO of BMG Entertainment North America,
since 1994, has been the Jewish executive Strauss Zelnick,
formerly the president of Twentieth Century Fox. From
this position he oversees "the operations of all North American
divisions of Bertelsmann Music Group as well as Music
Publishing and Interactive Entertainment
operations worldwide." [BUSINESS WIRE, 9-13-94]
The division Zelnick heads accounts for over $4 billion
in yearly sales. In 2001 another Jewish executive, Joel Klein,
was named chairman and CEO of the U.S. operations of
Bertelsmann AG. For years, another Jewish head, Clive Davis,
has overseen the important Arista record division in
BMG's stable. In 1998, another executive at BMG (both
a German convert to Judaism, and a rabbi) quit to become the
director of Germany's chapter of the environmental Greenpeace
organization.
In 1997, Frank
Woessner, the non-Jewish CEO of Bertelsmann's giant book
division, was awarded the (Jewish fraternal organization) B'nai
B'rith of Continental Europe's "Gold Medal for Humanitarian
Work." "Woessner," noted the Jewish
Week, "was lauded for supporting liberal Jewish causes in
speeches by prominent members of the local Jewish community."
[AXELROD, p. 41] Among the most important of his "humanitarian
work" was the publication of Jewish American author Daniel
Goldhagen's controversial work that affixed blame upon all
Germans for the Holocaust (not just Nazis).
In 1998, the
Jewish Bronfman family's Seagrams firm (which already owned
MCA) bought PolyGram NV -- "the world's largest music
company" -- for $10.5 billion. The International Herald
Tribune noted that:
"The transaction would be the
biggest in the history of the entertainment
industry, eclipsed only by Walt
Disney's $18.9 billion purchase of
Capital
Cities/ABC Inc. and the $11
billion merger of Time and
Warner Communications
that created Time Warner Inc."
[INTERNATIONAL HERALD, p. 15]
The
Polygram-MCA amalgamation now under the combined rule of
Edgar Bronfman made him, at age 43, "the most powerful mogul in
music land," with a quarter of all world record sales on earth,"
including the largest output of classics and jazz. [LEBRECHT, p.
25] Polygram alone, in the Bronfman empire, also owns
over 320,000 song copyrights. Among its labels are A&M,
Mercury, Decca/London, Phillips Classics,
and Island. [HOOVER, p. 138] Worldwide, Polygram-MCA
holdings include the Finnish Sonet Media AB company,
Japan's Nippon Phonogram, Polydor KK, and
Rodven Records, "the leading independent record company in
Latin America." [HOOVER, p. 138] Prominent musical acts in the
Polygram stable have included U2, Sting, Lionel Richie,
Soundgarden, Kiss, the Village People, Janet Jackson and
numerous others. MTV-like TV station projects include
Atomic TV in Warsaw, Poland and (in association with MTV)
2 MTV in Asia.
Charles
Koppelman was founder of the SBK record label, which
recorded "white rapper" Vanilla Ice, and Wilson Phillips among
others. Through the mid-1990s he was chairman of EMI Group
North America, later founding a company called CAK
Univeral Credits, geared to music stars looking for loans.
In 2000, Monte Lipman, co-founder of Republic Records,
was named president of Universal Records (part of the
Bronfman empire), which had bought out the former company. And,
in the same year, as the Cleveland Jewish News noted,
"Instead of forming on their own,
megapop bands like Backstreet Boys
and 'N Sync are
the manufactured creations of Transcontinental
Records mogul Lou Pearlman,
where inspired grooming and marketing
has shepherded a number of record
boy-groups to stardom."
[HOROWITZ, G., 3-24-2000, p. 37]
(In 2000, 'N Sync played at young
Rachel Colburn's private Bat Mitzvah party. She is the daughter
of American Online's President of Business Affairs, David
Colburn. "AOL spokeswoman Wendy Goldberg said the band has a
relationship with Colburn, and they did the gig as a favor."
Such a performance by the singing group normally costs between
$250,000 and a million dollars.) [DESERET NEWS, 6-8-2000, p. A2]
In the music
executive scene, at Warners, for example, for years Mo
Ostin headed the music company. "Warners," notes Neal
Karlen, in his book about the all-female band Babes in Toyland,
"was run by Mo Ostin and Lenny Waronker; the company's entire
A&R department was headed by Mo's son Michael. If [A&R man Tim]
Carr could get his way, the Babes' campaign would be largely
orchestrated from Warner Records' Burbank headquarters by a
half-dozen Jewish music men ... Traveling the spectrum of
popular music, one could still occasionally hear the word Jew
used as an epithet. If one listened, one could catch bands
talking of being 'Jewed down' by a record company executive or
having to hire a 'Jew lawyer' to fix a thorny legal hassle. The
attitude was no different in the shrunken universe of
alternative music. True, three of punk rock's spiritual
godfathers were Jewish: Bob Dylan, ne Robert Zimmerman, Lou
Reed, ne Louis Firbank; and Joey Ramone, ne Jeffrey Hyman. Yet
signing with a major label, one drunk English guitarist could be
heard saying late one night in 1992 at the historic New York
punk club CBGB, meant turning oneself into 'Jew-bait.'" [KARLEN,
N., 1994, p. 145]
At Sire Records, an affiliate of Warners,
Seymour Stein's artist stable has included Madonna, Talking
Heads, the Ramones, and many other premiere talents. "Before
long," says Christopher Anderson, "[producer Mark] Kamins and
Madonna became lovers ... After a few days together, Madonna
felt comfortable enough to spring her tape on Kamins ... He had
become friendly with an up-and-coming artist and repertorie man
at Warner's Sire label named Michael Rosenblatt
... Rosenblatt took the tape to the mercurial [Seymour] Stein."
Madonna also got her start in movies in Susan Seidelman's
Desperately Seeking Susan. [ANDERSON, 1991, p. 96-98, 121]
Guy Oseary, born in Jerusalem, is "a partner in Madonna's
Maverick Records" and he wrote a book called Jews Who
Rock, about Jewish performers in the rock and roll world. "I
keep getting calls," he says, "And they say, 'Why wasn't I in
your book? I rock. And I'm Jewish.'" [BOUCHER, G., 4-17-01, p.
62; TAYLOR, L., 12-27-00, p. F5] Oseary "as Maverick's chief
talent finder has become one of Madonna's most trusted
confidants." [FURMAN, P., 6-17-98, p. 12]
When Bob
Krasnow became the head of Elektra, "it was, he says, his
ethnic credentials more than anything else, that got him the
job." [WADE, p. 58] "I could work for a
big company like Warner Brothers [which swallowed
Elektra]," said Krasnow, "because I had all the ethnic
qualities -- I was white, I was Jewish, they could invite me
over to their home for dinner, and I could talk to Black
people." [WADE, p. 58]
Jerry Wexler
was the co-founder of Atlantic.
When the head of CBS Records, Clive Davis, was fired for
embezzling $94,000 (including $18,000 for his son's bar mitzvah
[DANNEN, p. 86], he was replaced by Irwin Segelstein. Dick
Asher, also Jewish "was the number two man at Columbia Records
under Clive Davis." [KING, T., 2000, p. 143] ("Since the days of
Abraham," notes the Jewish Forward, "machers in the
entertainment business have used their sons' and daughters'
special day to power-schmooze fellow moguls. In 1973, Clive
Davis, then president of CBS Records, threw one of the most
famous bar mitzvahs in show business history (that he was fired
for it only adds to its mystique.") [DORFMAN, J., 6-16-2000, p.
2] Davis later ended up as the head of Bell Records under
Columbia Pictures president Alan Hirschfield. (Davis
later had a successful career heading Arista Records,
whose artists included Whitney Houston and the Grateful Dead.
Davis' business manager at CBS was Michael Levy; Goddard
Lieberman was CBS Records' second in command; Lieberman's
assistant was Norman Adler. Al Shulman was head of the CBS
Special Products Division and Dick Asher was CBS Records'
Executive Vice President. Ron Alexenburg was a vice president
for promotion at Columbia. Elliott Goldman was the number
two man at Arista Records; Mitch Miller was a prominent
producer and musical celebrity at CBS.
By 1998 Jay
Boborg -- co-founder of IRS Records in 1979 which began
the careers of the Go-Gos, R.E.M., and others -- was the
president of MCA Records. Jerry
Greenberg, former head of Atlantic Records, "is now [in
1998, superstar] Michael Jackson's right hand man and president
of MJJ Records." [VIOLANTI, p. 8M]
(Jackson was the best man for Israeli psychic Uri Geller's
wedding. Geller's drawing -- minus a Star of David -- graces a
recent Jackson album). [REUTERS, 11-1-01] Alain Levy is chairman
(1998) of PolyGram. In 1997 Danny Goldberg, chairman of
Mercury Records, was described by the Jewish Week
as being "among the most powerful executives in the
entertainment industry." [GREENBERG, E., MUST, p. 49]
Among the divisions he directs is Motown Records
and PolyGram Classics and Jazz in the United States.
Goldberg was also formerly the president of Atlantic Records
where he controlled, among other groups, Nirvana. By 1995 he was
the chairman and CEO of Warner Records, but lost the
position during the controversy over Warners' support of
particularly abrasive "gangsta rap" recordings.
Goldberg is also a former chairman of the executive
committee of the American Jewish Congres
In 1987 Goldberg (then manager of Bonnie Raitt, Belinda
Carlyle of the Go-Gos, Don Johnson, and others) organized a
record industry-wide propaganda effort for the state of Israel.
As the Los Angeles Times described it:
"Israel's Foreign Minister Shimon Peres, in an
unprecedented appearance before
a group of recording industry executives, personal
managers, agents and lawyers,
told them that rock music was 'like praying' to some
Israeli youth and exhorted
them to 'come "pray" with our young people so they will
celebrate our [Israeli]
40th anniversary' in 1988. The reception/brunch at the
Beverly Hills Hotel
on Sunday was organized by rock entrepreneur Danny
Goldberg, the president
[then] of Gold Mountain Records ... The 100-plus guests
represented a
cross-section of the music industry, with strong ties to
musical talents. Among
them: Irving Azoff, president of MCA's Entertainment Group;
A&M Records
vice-president Jeff Gold; and personal managers Fred DeMann
(Madonna,
Lionel Richie), Mike Gormley (The Bangles, Oingo Boingo),
and Michael
Lippman (George Michael)." [CAULFIELD, D., 9-29-87, p. 6]
Goldberg told the Times that
"We talked about the fact that Israel needs to establish an
identity with
younger people. They're currently only aware of the country
as an item on
the nightly news. In the 1950s, an alliance was formed
between Israel
and what used to be the heart of show business. I mean,
Frank Sinatra
and Elizabeth Taylor were associated with Israel, but that
leaves out
the people who grew up after them." [CAULFIELD, D.,
9-29-87, p. 6]
The brunch was sponsored by the CRB Foundation, founded by
Jewish mogul Charles Bronfman "to create a mutual exchange
between Israel and the rest of the world." The Israeli Foreign
Minister, Peres, noted the Times, received "a standing ovation
when he arrived." [CAULFIELD, D., 9-29-87, p. 6]
In England,
Michael Levy headed Magnet Records, built to power with
help in 1972 from the then head of (British) Columbia Records,
Maurice Oberstein. Levy, known for "chasing people around the
office and throwing ashtrays," is also chairman of Britain's
Jewish Care organization. [BRIGHT, p. T2]
Levy "made his personal fortune propelling pop acts -- Alvin
Stardust, Chris Rea, Darts and Bad Manners -- to stardom."
[DAVIS, D., 2-10-2000, p. 5] "At one point [he]
was selling 8% of all records in the UK." [RED STAR RESEARCH]
In 1991 British producer Ian Levine began recording old
Black Motown record label acts for his new Motorcity
label. Levine gathered over 100 former stars to Detroit. "I was
in control of the entire Motown family," he chortled, "[I
brought] it back together again, and the press and the fans were
standing there in awe." [BULL, p. 14]
Perhaps the
most famous agent/manager/record executive is David Geffen (also
Jewish), former manager of Crosby Stills Nash and Young, and
many others, who founded Asylum, and later, Geffen
Records (the artist stable included Jackson Browne, the
Eagles, Joni Mitchell, Linda Ronstadt, and many others). (Alan
Cohen "structured the Asylum Records joint venture buyout
[with Warner and] left Warner to become head of
Madison Square Garden"). [KING, T., 2000, p. 287] Dennis
McDougal notes that Geffen "spotted Aerosmith, XTC, Nirvana, and
dozens of other pop acts in their infancy and nurtured them to
monied maturity and more than fifty gold record albums ... In
1989 alone, Geffen worldwide record sales came to over
$225 million." [MCDOUGAL, p. 474] A key
Geffen partner was Elliot Roberts (Rabinowitz) -- he was the
"pre-eminent manager of L.A.-based folk rock in the seventies,"
including, even later, Neil Young and Tracy Chapman.
[GRAHAM/GREENFIELD, p. 553] The president of Geffen Records
was Eddie Rosenblatt. Geffen's business manager was Jerry
Rubenstein. Gil Segel helped to get him into real estate. [KING,
T., 2000, p. 160, 184] "The funny thing," says Geffen, " is that
I had to forge a letter that I graduated from UCLA [to get an
early job], and today I'm on the Board of Regents of UCLA."
[SMITH, p. 303] ("He used his friendship with [his client]
Linda Ronstadt, who was then dating California governor Jerry
Brown, to obtain a seat on the University board of regents.")
[KING, T., 2000, p. 316]
Non-Jewish musical stars, caught in the Judeocentric web
of the musical world, often support Jewish/Israeli ethnocentric
interests on behalf of their Jewish friends and managers. Among
the old Geffen stable, for example, in 2002 a news item noted
that Don Henley of the Eagles was "donating the $7,900 from the
sale [of his guitar at auction] to the Jewish Federation of
Greater Dallas for use in supporting Israel and Jewish
organizations."[TOP FORTY CHARTS, 6-12-02] That same
year, the Jewish Week wondered: "What’s one
of the world’s greatest rock stars doing at a Jewish benefit
dinner? The answer came Monday night when Bono, the voice and
wordsmith driving the fabulously popular band U2, became the
first rock and roll personality to receive the Humanitarian
Laureate Award from the Simon Wiesenthal Center." [Jewish
Week, 11-22-02] (That same year, the Israeli newspaper
Ha'aretz noted that the new Wisenthal "tolerance" Center in
Jerusalem was built on a Muslim cemetery).
In the rock and roll world which is so heavily Jewish,
there are apparently different levels of what is considered to
be morally offensive, including the usual admonition: Thou Shalt
Not Offend Jews (Others, especially Christianity? -- No
problem). As Leah Garchik wrote in 2002, "Marilyn Manson reveals
in Rolling Stone's new book 'Tattoo Nation: Portraits of
Celebrity Body Art" that Madonna's manager, who was thinking of
signing Manson, called Manson's manager to inquire about whether
the rocker had a swastika among his many tattoos. 'Of course
not,' said Manson's manager. 'One of the guys in the band is
Jewish.' 'Oh, OK,' said Madonna's manager. 'We don't have a
problem with the Satanism, but we can't deal with any kind of
Nazism.'" [GARCHIK, L., 11-7-02, p. D14]
Jews even came
to prominence behind the scenes in the world of country music.
The first important Jewish figure in Nashville was Paul Cohen,
the A&R man for Decca in 1945-58 (the Decca
company in the United States was founded in Chicago by Jack Kapp
in 1934). Cohen, who lived in New York and visited Nashville for
a few weeks at a time, was "called by some 'the King of
Nashville.'" [JONES, M., p. 73] Margaret
Jones notes that
"As head of A&R
for Decca's country division, Cohen was responsible
for a blue chip roster of talent that
included the top acts of the time:
Ernest Tubb, Red Foley and Webb
Pierce ... In 1952, Cohen signed
the one and
only female star of country to Decca, Kitty Wells, and by
1954 he had two other solo girl
performers under contract: Goldie Hill
and Wanda Jackson ... After Cohen
signed Webb Pierce, Pierce
became the hottest artist in country
... [JONES, M., p. 74] ... Nashville
was Cohen's 'fishing hole,' and he
galvanized the town, convincing
Ernest Tubb to record there; soon all
the other acts fell into line."
[JONES, M., p. 73]
"Paul was one of the first Jewish
guys who actually came in to Nashville, once they saw country
music was getting to doing something," recalled singer Faron
Young. "Before that, most of the country people wouldn't accept
Jewish people. They were too clannish about that. He more or
less broke the ice, then the rest of them came in and more or
less took over this business. Hell, they own all the labels and
everything else now. Them and the Japs." [JONES, M. p. 73]
Cohen also
signed Brenda Lee and eventual country superstar Patsy Cline,
among others, to his stable. Earlier though, "Patsy got to
know and work with Ben Adelman, another fixture on the
[Washington] DC music scene. Adelman, and not Bill Peer, as one
story goes, appears to have been the direct link to Patsy' first
recording contract. The gregarious, redheaded Adelman was a
'Jewish feller' who hailed from upstate New York and had fallen
in love with country music in the late forties. He was willing
to spend a lot of his wife's money just for the fun of being in
the ball game. Fortunately his wife, Kate Adelman, as an heiress
and supported his efforts ... Adelman's real talent and the
focus of his energies was songwriting. His early compositions
were in the Tin Pan Alley mold, but when his interests shifted
to the booming country and western field, he started writing
hillbilly music. His wife claimed he wrote or co-wrote literally
thousands of tunes that are registered in the Library of
Congress." [JONES, M., 1994, p. 50]
"Cohen was a wheeler-dealer in many respects," notes
Margaret Jones, "He started a dozen or more publishing companies
of his own -- all named after brands of whisky. Then he had the
chutzpah to open his office two blocks away from Decca,
so he would be operating right under their noses." [JONES, M.,
p. 71] When Cohen's career was finished
in Nashville, another Jewish Decca agent, Milton Gabler,
"took over for him." [JONES, M., p. 73]
Among his finds, Gabler signed Bill Haley and His Comets in
1954. (Irvin Feld is also credited with "discovering" Bill
Haley, as well as Paul Anka, the Everly Brothers, and Fats
Domino, among others). [BLACKWELL, E., 1973, p. 164] In this
same genre, years later, country star Waylon Jennings recalled
that his big break in Hollywood came through Jewish producer and
musician Herb Alpert.
The Atlanta Jewish Times notes the story of the
birth of another country star, Willie Nelson:
"[Jewish agent Joel Katz] received a phone call from a man
with a distinct Texas
drawl. The man said he had read about the contract Katz had
negotiated for
[Black pop star] James Brown. He didn't have money, but he
wanted Katz
to make him a star. Katz hopped on a plane for Austin,
Texas, walked into
a room at the Ramada Inn, and stared into the eyes of
Willie Nelson."
[POLLAK, S., 1-7-00]
Katz has represented a wide range of singers: from country
stars Tammy Wynette, Waylon Jennings, and George Straight to
African-American artists The Temptations, B. B. King, Stevie Ray
Vaughn, Jimmy Buffet, and the rappers Rone Thugs and Harmony.
Finding a niche
wherever it is available, by the late 1990s Madeline Stone was
even a "leading writer of Christian music," working with top
Christian acts CeCe Wilnan, and the group Anointed. "I see
myself," she explained, "as being a Jewish girl who writes
inspirational songs, not a Christian writer." [DREYFUSS, I., p.
Y4] A Reform Jew, Steve Kaufman, is also "the only three-time
winner of the National Flatpicking Championship held in
Winfield, Kansas." As the Jerusalem Post notes,
"His 50 books and videos include A
Smokey Mountain Christmas for
Guitar and Flatpickin' the Gospels.
'My mother said 'Oy,'' he recounted.
'I said, "mom, it's going to sell."
In this business you fill the void. There
weren't many bluegrass gospel
videos.'" [ROBINSON, R., 7-24, 2000]
In the "heavy
metal" musical world, Jewish entrepreneur Jon Zazula of
Crazed Management-Megaforce Records has a stable of acts
that includes Method of Destruction (M.O.D.), Anthrax, Ministry,
Metallica, and others. Cliff Burstein and Peter Mensch have
managed AC/DC, Metallica, Def Leppard, Bruce Hornsby,
Queensryche, Tesla, and others. Their Q Prime company
also owns three radio stations in California.
The "godfather of punk," manager and
"mastermind" of the seminal "punk" band -- the Sex Pistols, was
Great Britain's Malcolm McLaren. He was also the manager of the
New York Dolls, Adam Ant, and Boy George. According to Sex
Pistol lead singer Johnny Rotten, his manager was "the most evil
man alive." [HARRIS, M., 8-19-94, p. 11; SHAW, D., 12-16-99, p.
5] McLaren "was brought up by his maternal grandmother, Mrs.
Corre, a formidable woman from a very rich Sephardic Jewish
family." [BARBER, L., 12-22-91, p. 8] The anarchistic Sex
Pistols, notes the London Independent, were "brought into
being quite cynically by Malcolm McLaren as an advertising
gimmick to promote sales of the fetishistic clothes and other
devices designed and sold by himself and Vivienne Westwood."
[GRAHAM-DIXON, 8-19-95, p. 2] (The Ramones are also a
candidate for the most influential punk band. The head of the
Ramones, Joey Ramone -- born Jeffrey Hyman -- is also Jewish. )
[TAYLOR, L., 12-27-00, p. F5] Elsewhere, Geoffrey Weiss
"first made a name for himself as a Harvard undergraduate when
he and some friends took over WHRB, the college's 50,000-watt
radio station, and turned it into an oasis of punk rock known
across the country for its idiosyncratic programming. After
graduation, Weiss had gone to work for A&M records, where he'd
helped to launch Soundgarden." [KARLEN, N., 1994, p. 160] Howie
Klein founded the "punk" rock label 415.
Joseph Heller,
formerly of Heller-Fischel, booked acts like Styx, the
Electric Light Orchestra, Boz Scaggs, and a variety of others.
"He represented top-drawer rock talent like Van Morrison, the
Guess Who, Marvin Gaye, War, Elton John and Pink Floyd."
[SNYDER, N., 2-19-01] Stretching out as dangerously as possible
to make a buck, Heller eventually gravitated towards a relative
goldmine in the Black ghetto-based "gangsta rap." He cofounded
Ruthless Records and managed the pioneer rap group NWA
(Niggaz With Attitude) from early in their careers. The musical
genre of gangsta rap, notes Jory Farr, "thrives on misogyny, as
well as homophobic and race-baiting rage ... [It] was the
perfect music for [a] lifestyle loaded down ... with warnings of
betrayal, murder, revenge, and a short life." [FARR, p. 70] "I
believed that rap would become the most important music of the
nineties," said Heller, "... [But] you can't sell two million
rap records to kids in the inner city. That's a way to sell
200,000. You have to market it to the white kids." [FARR, p. 68,
71]
Heller hired
Ira Selsky as his corporate attorney and an Israeli-born
security chief named Michael Klein to ward off angry, exploited
Blacks who quite literally walked into his office threatening to
kill him. Rap star Ice Cube even threatened Heller in one of his
recorded songs, prompting the Anti-Defamation League to flag it
as anti-Semitic. Ruthless Records released a Jewish rap
duo called Blood of Abraham. As Chuck D,
the lead vocalist for the Black rap group Public Enemy, noted,
"There's no way to get trained on the seamier elements of the
music business being on the street -- that element is reserved
for boardrooms." [D, CHUCK, p. 85] Those
in Chuck D's reminiscences about "boardroom" behavior include
Lyor Cohen (manager of Rush Productions, and an Israeli);
Al Teller, an executive at MCA whose parents died in the
Holocaust; Steve Ralbovsky of CBS; Bill Adler (a
publicist); and Rick Rubin of Def Jam Records. (Jewish
diamond dealer Jacob Arabo has made the news as a favored
jewelry merchant to the Black rap crowd that seeks to symbolize
wealth and power, or, as the New York Times put it, "the
jeweler who gives most of today's leading rappers their shine."
[CENTURY, p. 1]
In 2001, Heller was named the "Godfather of Latin Rap" by
the Los Angeles Business Journal; he was joining in
attempting to build a rap movement in the Latino market via
Hit a Lick records. As the Journal noted:
"If Heller is convinced that Latin rap will emerge as the
next big thing, it
probably will be, said other music industry veterans ...
Indeed, Heller is
widely acknowledged as one of the key forces behind gangsta
rap's
crossover into the music mainstream ... While Heller has
the second-tier
title of chief operating officer, he acknowledges that the
other partners
'generally run everything by me because of my experience
and expertise.'"
[SNYDER, N., 2-19-01]
By 2001 too, the aforementioned Lyor Cohen had catapulted
to power in the Rap world. Rolling Stone even magazine
featured an article about him, sub-titled How Lyor Cohen --
the White, Jewish Israeli-Raised President of Island Def Jam
Records -- Became One of the Most Important Men in Hip-Hop, and
Why He May Now Become One of the Most Important Men in Rock &
Roll." Cohen started out promoting punk rock acts like the
Circle Jerks, Social Distortion, and the Red Hot Chili Peppers.
He then became president of the rap music label Def Jam in 1988
and soon had become "perhaps the most powerful white executive
in an African-American business." (Def Jam was bought out by the
Jewish-owned Polygram company in 1999). Irv Gott, a Black
record producer, notes that Cohen is "a white Jewish guy, but I
think everybody respects him like he's black. He knows how to
carry it too. He knows how to get gangster, how to fall back,
when to shut the fuck up, whento say something. That's why other
white executives are scared of him. He knows how to deal with
the hoods, the criminal element." Cohen, continued Rolling
Stone, has broadened his musical base and "oversees an
empire that includes hundreds of artists performing in dozens of
genres, a roster that features PJ Harvey, American Hi-Fi, Shelby
Lynne, Lionel Richie, Bon Jovi, Melissa Etheridge, Saliva,
Ludacris, Kelly Price and Sisquo." Cohen's nickname is "Little
Lansky" (after famed Jewish mobster Meyer Lansky). He was born
in New York City "where his father, an Israeli, worked in the
consulate." He was later raised on an avocado farm near Tel
Aviv. [COHEN, R., 6-21-01]
Cohen has also been active in trying to readjust Black
consciousness of Jewish exploitation of the African-American
community. "In the late Eighties," notes reporter Rich Cohen,
when [Public Enemy's] album It Takes a Nation of Milions
to Hold Us Back was
topping the charts, the group's minister of information,
Professor Griff, made
several anti-Semitic statements. As a Jewish exec working
with the band, Cohen
found himself in the middle of a rough, formative
experience. 'When Professor Griff
from Public Enemy said what he said, and it caused this
whirlwind, the whole
industry asked me, 'What the fuck are you doing?' says
Cohen. 'Every president
of every record company called and said, 'Drop them: But I
believe part of
being Jewish is education. And I believe I was instrumental
in changing Public
Enemy's views. I said, "Your voice is being muted because
you say Jews are
this or that. You can't make blanket statements. If you
want your message
out there" -- and it was profound, I think -- "stop
generalizing." And I was
the only Jew in their lives. What if I resigned? They would
only be more
alienated. I hadn't quite being a Jew. I can't quit being a
Jew. Instead, I
tried to have an impact. I felt like I was doing the right
thing. Not just
as a Jew, as a person. They had a big voice da nation of
millions, to
quote their album. I had the Holocaust Museum [the Simon
Wiesenthal
Cednter] shut down, and we had a private tour. The first
thing you see
is a Jewish skull plus a black person's skull equals a
baboon. The last
thing is a monkey with enormous lips dressed with a Star of
Daivd holding
a trumpet and a sign saying, 'It'sthese Jews that are
bringing in this music call
jazz.'" [COHEN, R., 6-21-01]
Then there is
former tax attorney Joe Weinberger who drives a Jaguar S-200,
wears a diamond-studded Rolex watch and "fat gold rings," and
carries a "9mm automatic pistol tucked in his pocket." As the
Miami New Times notes about his rise to power in the
African-American rap music world,
"In the early Nineties, Miami's
reigning booty-rapper, Luther Campbell,
hired Weinberger away from the
carpeted hallways of a swash Brickell
Key law firm to help manage a growing
musical empire and its attendant
lawsuits. Within five years Campbell
was bankrupt and Weinberger
had purchased the rights to his
music. Rather than return to the
comfortable confines of his former
life, the 42-year old lawyer, who
is single and
childless, opted to launch his own label, Lil' Joe ... In
a
post bankruptcy fire sale overseen by
Richard Wolfe [Weinberger's
lawyer/partner, also Jewish],
Weinberger bought the rights to 2
Live Crew music for about $800,000,
plus the outstanding money he
claims Campbell owed him." [KORTEN,
T., 8-10-2000]
Weinberger has even been accused of
ordering a car bombing and directing death threats against an
employee.
Then there is
Canada-born Bryan Turner, who founded Priority Records in
1985; he is also Jewish. [JEWHOO, 2000] By 1998,
Priority had yearly sales of $250 million. As the Los
Angeles Times notes:
"When the pioneering gangster rap
group N.W.A. was looking for its
first record
deal, it found a distributor in Priority Records, which
released an album so obscene it
prompted a letter of complaint from
the F.B.I. When Ice-T left Warner
Brothers Records after police groups
and the company's shareholders
objected to his song 'Cop Killer,' he
found a new
home at Priority. When Suge Knight, the imprisoned head
of Death Row Records, who is known
for his pugnacious business
tactics, was
looking for his first deal, Priority gave it to him.
Through
all the violence and controversy of
hardcore rap music -- from its roots
in N.W.A to its current resurrection
with Master P -- the Los Angeles
label
Priority Records has been a major player." [STRAUSS, N.,
9-3-
98, sec. E, p. 1]
And as the
Times noted on another occasion:
"When Time
Warner first parted ways with rapper Ice-T after the 'Cop
Killer' flap and then with rapper
Paris over a song that portrayed an
assassination fantasy of President
Bush, Turner wasted little time
signing deals with both artists."
[HOCHMAN, S., 7-30-95, CALENDAR,
p. 82]
Jewish entrepreneur Steve Rifkind has also become very
successful in the rap music field. In 1993, Rifkind founded and
still heads Loud Records (its president is Rich
Isaacson). Earlier, Rifkind began the Steven Rifkind Company,
"a consulting firm specializing in Rap and R&B." Loud
acts include Wu-Tang Clan, Mobb Deep, Yvette Michelle,
Funkmaster Flex, Alkaholics, Raekwon, and Xzibit. The company's
value is estimated at about $100 million.
[collegemusic.com/1-11-00] "Rifkind," notes the online magazine
Entrepreneur,
"who trademarked the term 'Street Teams,' takes marketing to
the street --
literally -- by hiring youths to tell their communities
about his artists'
music. 'My philosophy has always been 'You can't stop
word-of-mouth,
explains Rifkind, who has street teams across cities,
distributing free singles
to teenagers at housing projects and schools, and scrawling
the names of
his albums in the dust on parked trucks, which then serve
as mobile billboards."
[entrepreneur.com]
Yet another major Jewish rap
entrepreneur is the aforementioned Rick Rubin, who, says Jory
Farr, found his "biggest stars were former gangsters who used
beats and rhymes to glamorize wealth, dope, and violence.
Deciding who to sign could be a moral quagmire ... but Rubin
wasn't one to be bothered by the trivia of social
responsibility." [FARR, p. 126] "I could do anything I wanted,"
Rubin once said about his own family life in New York, "We were
always upper middle class. We were wealthy for the community we
lived in. In a sense I was spoiled." [FARR, p. 119]
Rubin's record
company Def American is now called American Recording;
at one time Geffen Records distributed Rubin's material.
Earlier in his career he had signed bands like Slayer (whose
lyrics exhorted "everything from virgin sacrifice and satanism
to sadistic mutilations and the atrocities of Auschwitz" [FARR,
p. 109]) and the Geto Boys, who "pushed misogyny and sadism to
new depths." [FARR, p. 108]
Rubin's own star rose so high that
he eventually produced albums for Mick Jagger and the Red Hot
Chili Peppers. Troubles, however, came from a lawsuit against
him by Adam Horowitz of the Beastie Boys and threats from the
Meir Kahane-founded Jewish Defense League. Outraged by Rubin's
promotion of violently anti-Jewish lyrics by Black ghetto
groups, the Jewish group reportedly came looking to beat him up.
Rubin couldn't understand their anger. He told an interviewer
that
"They should've talked to me and
found out what I felt before coming to
attack me, because I was a JDO
[Jewish Defense Organization]
supporter.
When I was at NYU I saw [right wing rabbi] Meir Kahane
speak and he
blew me away -- he was amazing ... After hearing
him
speak, I wanted to pack my bags and
go to Israel ... I called the JDO
several times, wanted to join, but
they never returned my calls." [FARR,
p. 123]
Among the most
controversial "gangsta rap" labels was Death Row Records
(including Tupac Shakur, Dr. Dre, and Snoopy Doggy Dog). A noted
earlier, Death Row products were distributed by the
Jewish-dominated Time-Warner company until "pressure from
stockholders after an outcry over the flagrantly violent and
misogynist lyrics" of its stars. Time-Warner dropped the
label, but eighteen months later it was picked up (for $200
million) by the Universal Music Group, a subsidiary of
the Jewish Bronfman family's Seagram company.
Universal too eventually abandoned the controversial label,
only after "pressure from stockholders and regulators."
[HELMORE, E., 8-29-97, p. 10]
Still another Jewish push -- more recently -- into the rap world is
Koch Entertainment's In The Paint record label.
Koch, one of the largest "independent music distribution
companies," is headed by founder and CEO Michael Koch and
President Bob Frank. [kochentertainment.com]
Jewish author Nearl Karlen doesn't like latent Black perceptions of
Jewish exploitation surfacing in the rap world, writing: "'I
want everybody to try and find this book!' rapper Ice Cube said
at a 1991 press conference where he held up a copy of The Secret
Relationship Between Blacks and Jews, a bogus piece of Nation of
Islam scholarship." [KARLEN, N., 1994, p. 146] Karlen later
applauds one rappers stand against "antisemitism, " saying:
"Easy-E, former leader of the gangsta rap group N.W.A., made a
courageous stand, going so far as to appear on a Jewish rap
group's single entitled 'Niggaz and Jews (Some Say Kikes).'
Easy-E was not long after lectured by Omar Bradley, the mayor of
his hometown of Compton, California, with 'I won't name the
specific racial group that's using you, brother, but they are
destroying us and having lunch and a bar mitzvah at the same
time." [KARLEN, N., 1994, p. 146]
And lastly for
the music scene, the president and CEO of the Recording
Industry Association of America --- a lobbying group (with a
staff of 72) for the big record companies -- is also Jewish,
Hilary Rosen, who was described in 1997 by the Washington
Post as "a powerful woman in an industry dominated by men.
One of the most influential yet least known players in the U.S.
entertainment behemoth." [WEEKS, p. C1]
Rosen became the CEO when another Jewish executive, Jason
Berman, stepped down from the position.
C. Delores Tucker, the founder of the
National Political Congress of Black Women, has singled out
Rosen's organization for special condemnation:
"In terms of children, the RIAA is
the most destructive lobbying force in
America. It is incomprehensible that
anyone with an ounce of concern
for children would be demanding the
promotion, distribution, and sale of
gangsta/porno rap to children."
[WEEKS, p. C1]
Another
organization often under public fire for negatively influencing
children and adolescents is the Interactive Digital Software
Association, which represents nearly fifty video game
companies. Doug Lowenstein, also Jewish,
[who was once the Legislative Director for Ohio Senator Howard
Metzenbaum], became the first president of the organization in
1994, and he remains in power. Lowenstein is often called upon
to defend the excessive violence and decadence found in many of
the games. "Video games," he insisted in 1998, "are not the
source of violence in society." "The producer of Flesh Feast,
Eric Wahlberg," noted one media report, "agreed." [MEDIA
AWARENESS NETWORK, 5-29-98; BLOOM, D., 9-23-99, p. L8]
The most
controversial video game for the early 1990s was Mortal
Kombat, produced by Acclaim Entertainment.
In an appeal to video firms, asking for restraint from
excessive violence, California Attorney General Dan Lundgren
noted that "Mortal Kombat depicts bloody decapitations as
well as scenes where a still-beating heart is pulled from a
body." [SAN FRANCISCO CHRONICLE, 9-9-94, p. C7] Acclaim
Entertainment is headed by Gregory Fischbach, once hired by
Elliot Goldman (the president and CEO of RCA/ARIOLA) to
head RCA/ARIOLA Record International. (Fischbach
represented musical acts Crosby Stills and Nash, Emmylou Harris,
Boz Scaggs, among others.) In 1998,
Lawrence Kassanoff, CEO of Threshold Entertainment, was
making a weekly TV series based on Mortal Kombat.)
[KNOEDELSEDER, W., 6-18-86, pt. 4, p. 3; O'HARE, K., 12-27-98,
p. 45]
For all the Jewish complaints that
they are "marginalized" in American society and subject to
Gentile-inspired self-hate, Jews have for decades been afforded
mass media dominance in literally telling everyone else how to
run their lives. "Dear Abby" (Pauline Esther Friedman Philips)
and "Ann Landers" (Esther Pauline Friedman Lederer) -- the twin
Friedman sisters from Sioux City, Iowa -- have been mentioned
before. One or both of them have been listed in polls as among
"the most admired women in the United States," "the most
important women," and "the most influential women in America."
By the late 1980s both women were in demand in the national
lecture circuit, commanding $10,000 for a half hour talk.
[POTTKER/SPEZIALE, p. viii, 4]
The sisters'
father, Abraham, began a successful theatre business as co-owner
of a burlesque house in a seedy part of Sioux City.
[POTTKER/SPEZIALE, p. 15, 312] Ann (Esther) once admitted that
she "learned the facts of life from the girls in the chorus
line." [P/S, p. 16] Both women are remembered by locals in Eau
Claire, Wisconsin, where they later lived, for their
ostentation: "their flare for making an entrance." [P/S, p. 65]
Both women took separate routes to advice column stardom,
although "neither twin has had formal training in social service
work or journalism." [P/S, p. 4-5] A
non-speaking, competitive feud between them lasted eight years.
Sister "Abigail
Von Buren" eventually married Morton Phillips, Jewish heir to a
Midwestern liquor fortune. In Eau Claire, the Phillips family
also owned a factory, Presto Industry, (which gained
national fame as a maker of pressure cookers) which alienated
some in the town. "Many of the town's blue-collar workers,
resentful of their dependence on the Jewish-owned Presto
Industry, openly made anti-Semitic remarks ... [P/S, p. 65]
... Despite the profits Presto reported in 1953,
including an astounding 48 percent return on net worth the year
before, Presto managers shocked union employees with a
proposal for wage cuts." [P/S, p.89]
"Dear Abby" sits on her husband's $70
million philanthropic foundation. A millionaire many, many times
over, she has also done advertising commercials for English
muffins and a milk lobbying organization. Telling the world with
assurance how to solve its problems, her own daughter spent five
years in therapy with (the aforementioned) Judd Marmor. [P/S, p.
178-179]
Sister "Ann
Landers" was married to Jules Lederer, founder of the
Budget-Rent-a-Car company. In her columns she was "ever
mindful of maintaining the facade of a happy marriage, ...
presenting her readers with the image of a devoted wife and
loving husband." [P/S, p. 216] In 1975, her husband of 36 years
dumped her for a younger woman. "Gossip about the affair," note
her biographers, "had an extra zing to it. Jules was cheating on
the woman who had set herself up as America's moral conscience
... [P/S, p. 222] ... Perhaps her public statements, years
before her divorce, reflected her fears and insecurities over an
empty marriage." [P/S, p. 216] A friend
of the Lederer family, therapist Abe Franzblau, who knew Ann
Landers well, noted that "All it took was a short time in the
Lederer company to realize that [Ann] exhibited the classic,
textbook traits of a cold, rejecting woman." [P/S, p. 217]
Landers also lives a life of extreme
ostentation:
"The ornate showplace at 209 East
Lake Shore Drive is still [Ann's]
home. Wall panels and sconces
imported from a British castle
complemented the mullioned windows
and intricately sculpted ceilings.
Recasts of fifteenth-century statuary
in the living room, including
a covey of kneeling angels...,
provide a stunning counterpoint
to Louis XV sofas and mother-of-pearl
inlaid chairs. Works by
Picasso, Renoir, and Dali cover the
walls ... [Her husband] was
offended by the extraordinary amount
of money [she] was lavishing
on their apartment." [P/S, p. 219]
In 1995,
Landers got into hot water with some comments she made in New
Yorker magazine about the Pope and the Polish people. "He
has a sweet sense of humor," she said, "Of course, he's a
Polack. They're very anti-women." Polish-Americans responded
with outrage to the slur, wondering how and why she had singled
them out as being "anti-women." Landers issued a formal apology
but refused to comment further. [O'CROWLEY, P., 12-1-95, p. A1]
The woman who
tells the little people of the world how to handle their lives,
also had a chauffeur and housekeeper. [P/S, p. 229] The values
she champions also reflect her behind-the-scenes "facelift" and
"extensive body surgery." Her sister, Abby, has also had
cosmetic surgery. [P/S, p. 255] Both
women, but especially Ann Landers, survived scandal in the 1980s
when it was discovered that the two millionaires were sometimes
doing nothing for their pay -- merely recycling advice columns
(not identified as reprints) from two decades earlier. [P/S, p.
277-283]
Concerning Jewish identity, notes
Landers' daughter Margo, "[My mother] made the rule when I went
to college that I could only date Jewish boys ... Mother was
simply ethnocentric. She made it a point to tell everyone she
was Jewish and often mentioned it in her column." [HOWARD, p.
142-143]
(In 1987 there
was a much publicized search to create a new "Ann Landers" when
Esther Lederer left the Chicago Sun-Times to work at the
Chicago Tribune. 12,000 people applied to become the new
syndicated advice columnist. Jeffrey Zaslow, male, and also
Jewish, was selected as one of two people to replace Landers.
Zaslow's column was called "All That Zazz"; his wife is also in
the media business, a "TV news anchor.")
[ZASLOW, J., 1990; MOMENT, 12-31-96]
Another
syndicated troubles columnist, Judith Miller ("Miss Manners") is
Jewish as is the popular media sex therapist "Dr. Ruth"
(Westheimer) whose shows include her "Sexually Speaking" radio
show, "Good Sex!" cable TV program, and "Ask Dr. Ruth" TV
program. She has also lent her name to a "Good Sex" board game,
a "Terrific Sex" videotape, and ads for condoms, bras, and
typewriters. She has been afforded acting spots in movies and
was a panelist on the TV game show "Hollywood Squares."
"I raised my children with an emphasis on Zionism and
idealism," writes Westheimer, "... They both went to Zionist
summer camps ... [When my daughter graduated from college] she
announced that she was going to Israel to live. I knew it was
coming -- I had encouraged it." [italics in original:
WESTHEIMER, p. 180-181] (In 1996, the
Cleveland Plain Dealer noted another Jewish sex therapist,
Sherry Levine, who was making appearances throughout the
national media. Levine, headlined the paper, "is the Dr. Ruth of
Northwest Ohio.") [YERAK, p. 8] Dr. Joy Kuriansky is another
prominent Jewish media sex-therapist.
Elsewhere, the
second-most listened-to radio talk show host in America is "Dr.
Laura" (Schlessinger), who has been known to have her rabbi as a
guest in her studio during her show. (Schlessinger's favorite
therapist? Rhoda Markovich "is the best therapist I know of.")
[SCHLESSINGER, L., 9-1-2000] "Geoff Rich [the president of Radio
Today, was] one of the key people in marketing Laura." [BANE,
V., 1999, p. 165] Schlessinger, whose father was Jewish and who
asserts an activist Jewish identity, has even incorporated
herself as Dr. Laura Inc. She also has a syndicated
newspaper column and two books that have together sold over two
million copies -- How Could You Say That? and Ten
Stupid Things Women Do to Mess Up Their Lives. By 1997,
60,000 people were calling her program per day, seeking her
advice on how to solve their problems; that same year she sold
the rights to her radio show for $71.5 million. [MYERS, p. B6]
In 1999, an unauthorized expose of
Schlessinger's life was published by Vickie Bane, which
portrayed the talk show host as an extremely unpleasant
personality behind the scenes and a steady hypocrite in both her
past and present, rarely following in her personal life the
moral dictates she demanded for others on her talk radio show.
In 1998, the news world also noted that "her conservative
message had been sullied by the publication of 12 color
photographs of her, either topless or nude, on the Club Love web
site." [BONES, p. A21] The photos were taken over 20 years
earlier by her former boss, Bill Ballance, who gave Schlessinger
her start in radio; the photos were taken when she was separated
from her first husband. Schlessinger unsuccessfully sued both
her former lover and an Internet company.
"Schlessinger,"
notes Yvonne Crittenden, "hasn't spoken to her mother for
fourteen years, and is equally estranged from her younger sister
and family -- more fodder for critics who claim she's a
hypocrite for espousing strong family values ... She fell in
love with a married Zoology professor -- Lew Bishop (who was
married with children at the time they met) ... Schlessinger
converted to Judaism after watching a show on the Holocaust with
her son ... [An article written by Leslie Bennetts of] Vanity
Fair found her to be "cold and condescending, defensive,
evasive and spiteful about those she'd worked with and hated by
many formers friends and colleagues, all long before she became
successful.'" [CRITTENDEN, 10-10-99]
Schlessinger,
notes Evelyn Theiss, is "particularly tough on callers who have
been divorced, but she herself is a divorcee ... By the sheer
numbers of documented episodes of such outrageous behaviors,
[author Vickie] Bane persuades us that this is a woman with some
serious problems ... There is plenty more of such behavior -- an
almost stultifying amount." In 1998,
"Schlessinger received Israel's 50th Anniversary Tribute Award
for her contributions to humanity." [THEISS, 10-10-99] The
Jewish Forward notes the brand of Judaism she practices:
"Ms. Schelssinger was born to a Jewish father and an
Italian Catholic mother, but
was raised without religion, she has said in interviews.
Prompted by questions
from her son, Derek, while they watched a Holocaust
documentary, Ms.
Schlessinger began to research her Jewish roots and ended
up converting
under the auspices of Conservative Judaism. She later
joined Chabad-Lubavitch
of Conejo in the Los Angeles area and underwent an Orthodox
conversion
two years ago. The Chabad congregation's rabbi, Moshe
Bryski, said Ms.
Schlessinger regularly attends." [EDEN, A., 2001]
The author,
David Reuben, of the popular volume, Everything You Wanted to
Know About Sex But Were Afraid to Ask, was also Jewish. And
for decades, the prim know-it-all Jewish psychologist, Dr. Joyce
Brothers, (real surname: Bauer) was omnipresent in the mass
media (her ride to fame began on a TV game show when she won
"top prize on the first leg of the $64,000 Question, telling
twenty million TV viewers that 'cestus' was the name of the
leather glove worn by ancient Roman boxers.")
Brothers was "the only member of the American Psychology
Association who was 'repped' by General Artists Corporation,
which said [in its handout to journalists] for background: she
looks like Loretta Lynn, walks like Marilyn Monroe, and talks
like Dr. Freud.") [KRIM, p. 139-140] "She's obviously a fraud,"
wrote journalist Seymour Krim, "but I can't undress her in
public. It's too goddamn cruel." [KRIM, p. 140]
Brothers has a syndicated column in 350 newspapers, a
daily program on NBC Radio/Westwood One and "is a long-standing
member of the Federation of Jewish Philanthropies." [HYMAN, p.
191]
Another Jewish
psychiatrist in the talk show business was David Viscott. "At
his peak in the early '90s," noted the Los Angeles Times,
"he advised millions on both radio and television programs."
[ZAMICHOW, p. 10] Viscott had his own
greeting card line, therapy audio tapes, and he had written
two autobiographies. His personal therapy sessions
cost $1,500 for two hours, which helped finance his ostentatious
lifestyle including a Jaguar automobile and a Hancock Park
mansion. Consummate hypocrite, police were often called to his
home to break up family fights. "Abrasively confident on the
air," says the Times, "megalomaniacal off it, Viscott was
never in doubt about what other people should do with their
lives. But when his own life began to crumble, he turned out to
be clueless." [ZAMICHOW, p. 10]
Other prominent
Jewish American radio "shrink" talk-show hosts in the last
decade have included Elyse Goldstein, Harvey Ruben, Harry Sobel,
and Sonya Friedman (her show was entitled, "Telling Secrets with
Sonya Friedman"). The pioneer (in the early 1980s) of this radio
genre, however, was Toni Grant, "the first in the growing ranks
of 'media therapists' who give free advice on the airwaves."
[BOSWORTH, p. 112] "While Grant is a nationally recognized
advisor on love," noted the Los Angeles Times, "she
almost gave up finding it for herself."
"I've been single eight years," she admitted. "And I confess
openly that I was starting to wonder if all I knew how to do was
talk about it." [FINKE, p. VIEW, 5] It is
difficult to locate any ethnic information about Grant, born and
raised on Long Island. She may or may not be Jewish, but,
judging by Al Goldstein, publisher of the free love, semi-porno
magazine, Screw, she has travelled in some intimate
Jewish circles. Goldstein told People magazine that, "she
was the hottest sexual partner I ever had. But basically it was
a dishonest relationship. I loved her fame. She loved my
excitement." [CHAMBERS, p. 70]
In 1987, Los
Angeles Times journalist Al Martinez -- intrigued by the
avalanche of local telephone call-in therapy programs -- decided
to randomly select one of the therapists advertising in the
Hollywood Reporter. The psychologist-entrepreneur turned out
to be a Jewish woman named Audrey Levy. Her ad was for call-in
psychological help, offering "telephone counseling out of
Beverly Hills by calling 2-RELATE, credit cards accepted."
[MARTINEZ, pt. 9, p. 2]
In 1991, Larry King introduced his
(Jewish) guest and "inspirational speaker" Marianne Williamson,
like this:
"Who is that petit brunette standing
behind the pulpit and why are some
of Hollywood's hottest stars
listening? ... Her detractors say she is a New
Age guru more interested in
self-promotion than teaching others about
self help." [KING, L., 9-26-91[
Jewish mass
media psychology profiteers also dominate the scene in England.
"Few people," noted the London Sunday Telegraph in 1997,
"have been so influential in British life in recent years as the
four famous agony aunts [i.e., mass media personal problem
advisers] -- Marjorie Proops, Irma Kurtz, Anna Raeburn, and
Claire Rayner. They have been empresses of pelvic epics and
laureates of female personal pleasure." They are also all
Jewish. [MYERS, p. 26] "The role of the
agony aunt is up for examination," noted the Telegraph in
another piece, "What makes a good one? There is a joke among top
practitioners that the key qualification is to be a Jewish
mamma." "Maybe Jews have been so good at it because we have such
an intense curiosity," suggested Claire Rayner. [GRICE, p. 17]
"Have you noticed," Irma Kurtz once asked an interviewer, "that
three-quarters of the agony aunts in the world are Jewish? We
have carried common sense with us. Why are Jews violinists? You
can pick it up and run." [SCOTLAND ON SUNDAY, 2-13-94]
And what of the personal background
of such people who have given advice to the emotionally needy
for decades? What are their qualifications -- other than mass
media connections and great drive -- towards counseling millions
about etiquette, ethics, and healthy emotional lives? Late in
their careers, there were startling revelations about each of
the famous four in Great Britain, underscoring a profound
audacity and hypocrisy at base in their professional careers.
In 1995 Claire
Rayner, agony aunt for the London Sun, publicly confessed
that "I've been a depressive all my life ... I'm ashamed to
admit that I'm still ashamed ... In America you show off if you
need psychiatric help, and in this country you'd rather die than
get it." [(SCOTTISH) DAILY RECORD & SUNDAY MAIL, 8-14-95, p.16]
In turn, her husband "has been suffering from severe depression
for ten years which at time have left him feeling suicidal.
Despite his wife's career as an agony aunt, he says she hasn't
been able to help." [MIDDLEHOUSE, 7-26-99, p. 41] "I was beaten
to hell and back as a child," she says, "... I hardly knew my
mother so I couldn't love or respect her. I did not have any
self-esteem to speak of..." At the age of 15, she spent 14
months in a psychiatric hospital because of a "misdiagnosed
thyroid problem." The kind of woman qualified to give advice to
the psychologically and ethically troubled?
Irma Kurtz? In
1999 the London Daily Mail noted that Kurtz, for over 20
years Cosmopolitan's
"personal problem solver ... has
given advice on everything from
promiscuity and its consequences to
abortion and the advisability
of getting married too young. There
would be those who argue that
her own flawed emotional life is
hardly conducive to dispensing
considered, unbiased advice to women
... Irma admits she was a
recklessly promiscuous young woman
who stopped counting the
number of her lovers when they
exceeded 38. At the age of 30, she
had an abortion when her married
lover got her pregnant. And she
chose a man to father her child, with
no intention of ever marrying
him." Kurtz notes that "when [my son]
was eight or nine, I can
remember getting very low and
sometimes I would drink too much.
There were a lot of nights in a row
when I didn't go to bed sober."
[MIDDLEHOUSE, 2-27-97, p. 46-47]
Marjorie
Proops? In 1992 the London Daily Mirror noted that "In
her Mirror column ... she has often referred lovingly to
her husband, giving the impression that she was writing from the
experience and security of a happy marriage." [BROOKE, 12-24-92,
p. 2-3] In her biography of that same year, however, she
admitted that it was a disastrous marriage. "Britain's best
known agony aunt had a largely sexless marriage accompanied by a
secret 30-year affair" with the Daily Mirror's chief
lawyer, Philip Levy. (For his part, it was later revealed that
he always met Proops at a hotel and never told her that he lived
with another woman, Meli Meitner). Proops also had three
abortions, a divorce, an alcoholic mother, and "chronic
depression." "Every agony aunt has a murky past," she once said.
"Most use the problems that they've had in the past to share
with their readers." [GRANT, p.23]
Anna Raeburn?
She built her reputation on Capital Radio with a call-in advice
show, the first of its kind in England. In 1998 the London
Evening Standard noted that "she's the agony aunt who has
suffered more than her fair share of anguish: rape, two
abortions, three suicide attempts, four periods of therapy. What
next?" She once told an interviewer: "I'm not a nice woman. I
have never been a nice woman. I did try it once and it didn't
suit awfully well." Pregnant by her husband, she told him that
he couldn't "cope" with a child and secured an abortion.
[BILLEN, 7-22-98, p. 23]
In 1994, Ann De
Courcy, a critic in the London Daily Mail, lambasted the
profound hypocrisy of this genre of "agony aunt":
"What makes these women believe that
they are specially gifted to
offer moral guidance? ... They have
no hesitation in telling their
readers how to be happy, nor in
laying down moral guidelines
that often smack of pure hypocrisy
... Most people seeking
made a success of their emotional
life, rather than one traumatized
by it." [De Courcy, 2-1-94]
Other prominent Jewish agony aunts in
Great Britain include:
*Vanessa
Feltz.
In 1999, she signed a $4 million deal with the BBC.
Her qualifications for this career
included the fact that "she was
known as 'Vanessa the Undresser'
and her interest in sex was
such that her mother would ring up
hostesses at teenage parties
and tell them: 'Don't let her go
upstairs [with any boys].'" Feltz
wrote a book
called What Are These Strawberries Doing on My
Nipples? I Need Them for Fruit
Salad and was a columnist
for the
Jewish Chronicle; she also presented "Jewish London"
on Greater London Radio. Her comedy
routines she described
as "nice smut ... [like] 'Is sperm
kosher?" Her TV program's
formula, noted one critic, "is not
only moronic, but can be
deeply wounding [to those
participants on the program]." The
London
Sunday Times also noted that "Vanessa lives in some
grandeur with her husband and two
daughters in a Hampstead
mansion with a marble hall, a
ballroom, and a swimming pool.
She plays the much-loved part of
the Jewish princess to
perfection, clothes with jewelry
like a medieval knight togged
out for a tournament ... She says
she cannot understand the
'non-Jewish way of dressing.'"
[SUNDAY TIMES, 8-23-98]
* Miriam
Stoppard. Her 25th book was The Magic of Sex and
she was by 1991 an anchor woman at
BBC's morning program
People Today. "Hailed ... as the
vixen of permissive parenting,"
one critic said that "some are born
to controversy, some achieve
it, and some have controversy
thrust upon them. She luxuriates
in all three,
and her latest book, Sex-Ed -- Growing Up, Relationships
and Sex, has nothing to
diminish that status." [GLOVER, 9-219-97,
p. 7] Stoppard, noted another
media observer, "married playwright
Tom Stoppard when he divorced his
first wife because Miriam was
expecting his child." [DE COURCY,
2-1-94]
* Suzie
Hayman, mass media "sex counselor" and author of The
Good Sex Guide. "The only
thing my mother ever said about my
father was that he was not Jewish,"
she says. "And yet when Dad was
with my mother, he threw himself
into the Israeli War of Independence
... Why had he been prepared to put
himself at such risks, if he
wasn't Jewish?" Hayman's husband's
father was "violently anti-
Semitic"; later she discovered that
he was Jewish too. "And so,"
she resolved, "as I have found time
and time again with counseling
others, the subconscious drives
towards 'martial fit,' keys to common
ground that we are not even told is
there." [HAYMAN, 12-24-97, p. 11]
In America,
decadent radio commentator Howard Stern (with the third-ranked
talk show radio in America), sensationally obnoxious "shock"
radio agitator Michael Savage (Weiner), sports commentator
Howard Cosell (William Howard Cohen), talk show host Larry King,
radio personality Dennis Prager, popular Los Angeles talk show
host Michael Jackson (from South Africa), talk-show physician
Dean Edell, woman-beating sportscaster Merv Albert, Jerry
Seinfeld, Ed Asner, and Roseanne Barr were/are Jewish. ("I
remember [my mother] taking us down to
the basement [at their home in Salt Lake City] if someone just
came and knocked on the door," says Barr, "I really truly
believed that if anyone found out we were Jewish they would kill
us." [LAHR, p. 126]
Gossip queen Rona Barrett (Burstein)
was Jewish, as was/is gossip columnist Sheila Graham (Lily
Shiel), gossip columnist Louella Parsons (whose father was
Jewish), "Let's Make a Deal" game show host Monty Hall, 50s-era
television puppeteer Shari Lewis, popular media astronomer Carl
Sagan, Henry Winkler (the Fonz), Gilda Radner, Goldie Hawn, and
Israeli psychic Uri Geller. Prominent Jewish film critics
include Pauline Kael, John Simon, Stanley Kaufmann, Judith Crist
(born Klein), Gene Shalit, Leonard Maltin, Gene Siskel (of
Siskel and Ebert), and Joel Siegel of "Good Morning America"
(among numerous other Jewish movie commentators). Assassinated
Denver talk show host Allen Berg was Jewish, as is financial
columnist Sylvia Porter, and many, many others are familiar
Jewish mass media "personalities" to the public. Mel Blanc was
even the voice for Bugs Bunny, Porky Pig, Daffy Duck, and other
cartoon characters.
In earlier
years, prominent Jewish sports voice personalities included
Marty Glickman, Bill Stern (Sterngold) -- "one of the best known
voices on the airwaves," [LEVINE, P., p. 232] and Mel Allen
(formerly Mel Israel). Even the ex-wife, Claudia Cohen, of
billionaire financier and corporate raider, Ronald Perelman, was
a gossip columnist for the New York Post and later a TV
reporter. [BRUCK, p. 218] Not surprisingly, her father is Robert
Cohen, "the wealthy book and magazine distributor." [SPORKIN, p.
150]
Profoundly
influential in shaping American popular culture, it is estimated
that seminal gossip columnist Walter Winchell (original family
name: Weinschel) had an audience (for his weekly radio program
or his daily newspaper column) of two-thirds of all American
adults. [GABLER, Winchell, p. xi] His
focus was brash and sleazy. Like most who are driven towards
power, he was, notes Neal Gabler, "vindictive, cruel,
egocentric, paranoid, selfish, cheap and thoroughly
reprehensible [GABLER, p. p. xiv] ...
What made him a national phenomenon was gossip ... Winchell
introduced a revolutionary column that reported who was
romancing whom, who was cavorting with gangsters, who was ill or
dying, who was suffering financial difficulties, which spouses
were having affairs, which couples were about to divorce, and
dozens of other secrets, peccadilloes and imbroglios that had
previously been concealed from public view ... He suddenly and
single-handedly expanded the purview of American journalism
[GABLER, p. xii] ... Few lives are more instructive of the
forces that shaped mass culture in America than Walter
Winchell's." [GABLER, p. xv]
In 2001, Jews gathered for a
"special program for student journalists sponsored by the Jewish
Agency for Israel and the World Zionist Organization at the
General Assembly of the United Jewish Communities." "Do Jewish
journalists have more obligations than others?" asked the
Jewish Bulletin of Northern California, "Are they
responsible first to their communities, and do they need to
represent Israel in their newspapers?" [RAGOLSKY, H., 11-23-01]
"On campus there is already so much anti-Israel sentiment that
we have to be careful about any additional criticism against
Israel," Marita Gringaus told a reporter,
"This is our responsibility as Jews, which obviously
contradicts our responsibilities
as journalists." [RAGOLSKY, H., 11-23-01]
"I'm a Jew before I'm a journalist," added Uzi Safanov, a
reporter for Long Island University's school newspaper,
"before someone pays me to write. If I find a negative
thing about Israel, I
will not print it and I will sink into why did it happen
and what can I do to
change it." ("If he eventually wrote about negative
incidents that happen to
Israel," added the Jewish Bulletin, "he would try to find
the way 'to shift the
blame.'" [RAGOLSKY, H., 11-23-01]
What of the case of the New York Times' Tom Friedman, "a
Jew who was raised on all the stories, all the folk songs, and
all the myths of Israel." [DIAMOND, E., 1993, p. 44] Edwin
Diamond notes the personal "crisis" Friedman faced when he was
confronted with reporting honestly (which he eventually did)
about Israel's involvement in the notorious Shatila-Sabra
massacre of civilian Palestinians in Lebanon:
"Shatila-Sabra became a 'personal crisis' for Friedman,
convinced as he was
of Israeli knowledge -- and probably, approval -- of what
happened inside the
camp. Sitting at his typewriter, trying to reconstruct the
massacre, he felt
driven by 'two conflicting impulses,' the truth-telling
role of a Times journalist
and his private Jewish sympathies. 'One part of me wanted
to nail [Israeli
Prime Minister Menachem] Begin and [Defense Minister Ariel]
Sharon ... Yet
another part of me was looking for alibis -- something that
would prove Begin
and Sharon innocent, something that would prove that the
Israelis couldn't
have known what was happening." [DIAMOND, E., 1993, p. 45]
In a much more practical expression of this censorial world
view, in 2001, the Canadian CanWest media conglomerate
(headed by ardent Zionist Israel Asper) announced that "We do
not run in our newspaper Op Ed pieces that express criticism of
Israel." CanWorld, with media holdings in Ireland, New
Zealand, and other countries, had earlier announced that it had
acquired "all of the major Canadian newspaper and Internet
assets of Hollinger Inc., including the metropolitan
daily newspapers in nearly every large city across Canada and a
50% partnership interest in the National Post."
[ELECTRONIC INTIFADA, DECEMBER 11, 2001] CanWest also has major
television interests in Canada and other countries.
In 1993, a former reporter for the Washington
Post, Jeffrey Goldberg, addressed the issue of the
"disproportionate" Jewish presence in the mass media and its
implications:
"[There is a] particular perception
about the Jews and the press,
namely, that Jews own the presses,
and not only the ones off
Times Square ... There certainly is a
disproportionate Jewish
presence in the newsrooms of major
media organizations; anyone
who knows what the suffixes 'berg'
and 'stein' generally indicate
would agree. But there is, of course,
no Jewish conspiracy to control
the press, and when I am asked how I
know there isn't (as I was long
ago by an official of the [Lyndon] La
Rouche organization), I offered
two forms of proof: 1) No one has
ever asked me to join such a
conspiracy, even though my
credentials for membership are impeccable;
2) If 'the Jews' really did control
the media, coverage of the Jewish
community and the issues that
interest it would be far superior to what
we see today." [GOLDBERG, JEFFREY,
1993]
Are Goldberg's
"proofs" convincing? Are there any legitimate signs of a
"conspiracy" (whatever the semantic nuances of that word) in the
American mass media about expressly Jewish and Israeli
themes? By what reasoning should we ignore, in the mass media
context, incessant in-house ethnocentric Jewish discourse about
their collective superiority, international solidarity with
other Jews, the sacredness of the Holocaust, and special
attention to Jewish welfare? Need pan-Jewish activism express
itself today in "conspiratorial" form, in the sense of a secret
spy ring? How can the everywhere celebrated and
distinct Jewish world view -- religious or secular -- be
completely discarded in any reasoned analysis of Jewish
dominance in the mass media? (Many Jews
declare this in their in-house writings. As Eric Kahler
observes, for example, about highly assimilated Jews of Europe,
"Such distinguished personalities as [Heinrich] Heine, who was a
skeptic, an intellectual adventurer, as [Baruch] Spinoza, as
[Franz] Kafka, whose devotion was entirely unorthodox, unfixed,
exploratory, a Bernard-Lazare who was a freethinker, and as
Werfel, who was almost a Catholic -- all of them show attitudes
and proclivities, clearly deriving from the Jewish religion.")
[KAHLER, E., 1967, p. 7] And is not transnational Jewish
solidarity (so much highlighted and heralded by modern Jewish
observers) manifest in a purely "naturalized" manner the virtual
norm in today's media workplace?
And what of
Goldberg's own case? Here's an American-born reporter who, as we
learn in his own writings about the lack of a "conspiracy" among
Jews in the media, volunteered for service in the Israeli army.
Is this of no consequence in speculating upon this man's
objective journalism as a former Washington Post
reporter? Perhaps Goldberg will run
across fellow journalist Bruno Schlumberger in Israel.
Schlumberger is a staff photographer for the Ottawa Citizen
who was sent on assignment to the Jewish state in 1998 to cover
its fiftieth anniversary celebration. "I couldn't sleep, so
thrilled was I to be in Israel," wrote Schlumberger in the
paper, "... When I was in high school I joined Habonim, the
Labour-Zionist youth movement." [SCHLUMBERGER] (Although
soured on religous Orthodoxy in Israel, former Cleveland
Plain Dealer editor Stephen Esrati was once even a member of
the Zionist terrorist Irgun Zvai Leumi organization.
[GUTH, D., 12-8-00] Hank Greenspun, publisher of the Las
Vegas Sun, as noted earlier, even broke American laws in
delivering weapons to Israel.)
And what of
the following observations by Israeli Ze'ev Chafets?
"In a study undertaken in the winter
of 1979-80, Professor S. Robert
Lichter found that fully ninety-one
percent of the Jewish journalists
he surveyed agreed with the
statement "The United States has a moral
obligation to prevent the
destruction of Israel ... [CHAFETS, 1985,
p. 279]
Can we expect
that these Jewish journalists have the same noble "moral"
obligations about El Salvador, Argentina, Afghanistan, Poland,
Russia, Kenya, France, Iran, the Philippines, or anywhere else?
How about the "destruction" of the Palestinians by Israel?
Here's Max Frankel (for years the Executive Editor of the
New York Times) and his thoughts about Israel in his
work:
"I was much more deeply devoted to Israel than I dared to
assert. I had yearned
for a Jewish homeland ever since learning as child in
Germany that in Palestine
even the policemen were Jews! Like most American Jews,
however, I settled
on a remote brand of Zionism, which rejected all
importuning to move to Israel to
share its hardships and
dangers ... I did indeed have many close Israeli friends, not
only relatives and journalists but high officials, ranging
from Yitzhak Rabin to
Lova Eliav. That is why I well understood the full range
of Israeli opinion on all
of the country's vital security concerns ... Fortified by
my knowledge of Israel and
my friendships there, I myself wrote most of our Middle
East commentaries. As
more Arab than Jewish readers recognized, I wrote them
from a pro-Israel
perspective. And I wrote in confidence that The Times no longer
suffered from
any secret desire to deny or overcome its ethnic roots."
[FRANKEL, M., 1999, p.
401, 402, 403]
When push comes to shove in the world of patriotic
allegiance, or merely objective journalism, where do such men
(particularly a Jeffrey Goldberg or Bruno Schlumberger) stand?
And what about an American-born Israeli soldier who scoffs at
the "conspiratorial" view of Jewry, asserting that no fellow
Jews came around in the newsrooms of America, asking him to join
a special underground organization? As
Goldberg well knows, no one needs to ask him to join anything:
by religious or secular perspective, the "organization" is a
birthright. The modern state of Israel codifies this fact:
any Jew can emigrate to Israel by virtue of his genetic
identity. And pan-Jewish solidarity and its collectivist
perspective is so widely ensconced in the American mass media
(and American culture as a whole) that there is in fact nothing
at all "conspiratorial" about it whatsoever, since it is, after
all, the prevalent, naturalized norm of operation for all. And
yet few recognize -- and no one dares risk a challenge to -- it.
And the charge
of Jewish "conspiracy?" What does that mean? What are the word's
nuances? Do the "behind the scenes"
unified wheelings and dealings of hundreds of Jewish
organizations that seek to maintain the unpopular "separation of
Church and state" fit the bill? Is a lack
of public honesty and candor about Jewish belief, purpose, and
identity part of the same paradigm? As Jewish sociologist Arnold
Eisen notes about a veritable Jewish American cultural trait:
"Many [Jewish] informants [in one
academic study] demanded
assurance of the interviewer's
Jewish background before volunteering
certain responses (especially those
reflecting their less public attitudes
about dominant
[Gentile] groups) ... [EISEN, p. 144] ...
[The Jew in
public] represents his people before
another, and knows that if his
behavior is found wanting, his
people as a whole will suffer. He must
manipulate the opinion which others
have of him and, as the sociologists
observe, such manipulation is
acceptable in secondary relations but not
in friendships requiring candor and
trust." [EISEN, p. 144]
In this regard of Jewish protective
self-censorship, Lesley Hazeleton notes the case of an Israeli
journalist:
"One of Israel's top journalists had
been asked by an American
magazine to
write an article called 'Has Israel Lost Its Soul?' He
turned down the assignment. 'Why?'
someone asked. 'You've been
saying it often enough in the Hebrew
press.' He gave a despairing
shrug: 'I can't. It's read
differently in the States. Knowing that, I'd
only end up writing an apologia.'"
[HAZELETON, L., 1984, p. 26]
In other words,
the man felt that he couldn't write the truth about
Israel in English (perhaps in part because American Jews/media
powers were biased towards apologia), but, more importantly, his
critical thoughts would be revealed in a language that could
also be read by a non-Jewish audience. As Peter
Novick notes about journalists in the ethnic Jewish press: "They
are 'less Jewish' in that their public role, the fact that they
know what they say is being listened to by a gentile audience,
may make their utterances less frank, less expressive of
spontaneous feelings, more 'correct,' than conversation around
the kitchen table." [NOVICK, P., 1999, p. 38]
And the formal, institutionalized
Jewish apologia for the subject of Jewish dominance in the mass
media? After conceding the obvious in the year 2000 (that even a
Jewish scholar, Steven G. Kellman, noted that "most" of the "100
most powerful people" in Hollywood were Jewish, and that
"boosters and anti-Semites agree: Jews have been prominent and
predominant in all phases of the [motion picture] business:
production, distribution and exhibition"), the Anti-Defamation
League was still taking the only apologetic spin on these facts
available to it:
"Though individual Jews control
Hollywood, Jewishness does not ... The
ADL believes that the recitation of
numbers and percentages is not
the answer to the false charges of
Jewish 'control' of the motion
picture industry, or, indeed, of
similar accusations involving the
media, banking, finance and other
businesses. Reliance on statistics
alone plays into the hands of
anti-Semites." [ADL ONLINE, SEPT 1999]
Indeed it
does. This is a profound concession in formally admitting the
obvious. What else can the ADL say, lest it be caught as a
public liar in refuting the notion of Jewish "predominance" in
the mass media? Yet the key, however untenable, to the ADL's
Jews dominate the media, so what? argument, is that Jews
don't "in any field act in concert with other Jews similarly
situated simply because they happen to be Jewish." [ADL ONLINE,
SEPT 1999]
Maybe not in
whether they root for the Los Angeles Dodgers or New York
Yankees, but what reasoned analysis of Jewish identity and
politics can possibly assert that they have no collective
agenda in the mass media? [See also, for example, later
discussed Jewish collective efforts in American government
towards molding American foreign policy in support of Israel]. A
recurrent subject on entertainment television, for example, as
noted by Jewish researchers Jonathan and Judith Pearl, is
anti-Semitism, a subject that -- as we have earlier seen -- is
virtually non-existent in modern America. But it is a crucial
antithetical foundation (against non-Jews) of Jewish
identity and socio-economic advantage/advancement. As the Pearls
note about their fifteen years of television research:
"The various manifestations of
anti-Semitism that popular television
has portrayed have been almost
unlimited ... The continued existence
of modern anti-Semitism is reflected
in the numerous programs that
dramatize its many manifestations ...
[TV] invariably depicts anti-
Semitism as an ugly, abhorrent trait
that must be fought at every
turn ... Non-Jews often have a strong
and prominent role in the
battle against anti-Semitism ... For
the vast majority of Americans
who are not Jewish, watching their
favorite TV character do battle
with religious bigots can be an
important influence. And often, non-
Jewish characters can make inroads
against anti-Semitism on their
own turf in ways that Jews cannot ...
[PEARL/PEARL p. 103-104]
... Anti-Semitism is clearly
presented in the television dramatic
programs as an injustice that should
be constantly fought. In virtually
no program is the derogation of Jews
or Judaism left unchallenged
either by inference, word, or action
... This kind of portrayal projects
the important message that fighting
anti-Semitism is not solely a Jewish
concern but the responsibility of all
people." [PEARL/PEARL p. 130]
In 1980, Patricia Erens, noted Jewish
dominance throughout the mass media and its self-protection:
"Although anti-Semitic literature [in
America] has appeared in every
decade, anti-Semitism has not been a
dominant or even prevalent
aspect of the mass media (newspapers,
radio, film, television) or the
fine arts (painting, literature,
drama). Therefore, it is not surprising
to discover that although negative
portrayals of Jews exist in film,
little overt anti-Semitism occurs.
The large number of Jews who hold
the reins of Hollywood's power
prevented this." [ERENS, P., 1980,
p. 117]
And what about
the ceaseless avalanche of Holocaust-related material
throughout the mass media, (as noted in detail elsewhere)
including, for example, the front page 1999 article in a Los
Angeles Times by Jewish author Josh Geitlin? Again and
again, special sympathy is demanded by the public for
"Jewish survivors" (and Jews in general), now in their old age.
In this case, readers are informed that "as they get older, a
lot of these people feel like they're facing extinction for a
second time." [GEITLIN, p. 1] This "extinction," as the article
notes, is death itself, something -- apparently lost to the
author of the piece -- no Jewish suffering, of "survivor"
quality or not, has a corner on.
As Jewish scholar Peter Novick notes why Jewish victimology
themes -- especially the Holocaust -- of the Jewish power elite
is so omnipresent in popular culture:
"There are many reasons why concern with the Holocaust
among the 2 or 3
percent of the American population that is Jewish came to
pervade American
society. I will mention one important reason here, if only
because it is often
nervously avoided. We are not just 'the people of the
book,' but the people
of the Hollywood film and television mini-series, of the
magazine article and
the newspaper colun, of the comic book and academic
symposium. When a
a high level of concern with the Holocaust became
widespread in American
Jewry, it was, given the important role that Jews play in
American media and
opinion-making elites, not only natural, but virtually
inevitable tht it would
spread thorughout the culture at large." [NOVICK, P., 1999,
p. 12]
Let us also
turn to other specific Jewish/Israeli issues in the mass media
and widespread Jewish-enforced censorship against addressing,
let alone scrutinizing, the dominant Jewish presence at the
upper echelons of the mass media and its influence in shaping
American popular culture. The taboo against this subject is
itself institutionalized, usually by dismissing any queries
about the subject as both groundless and nakedly anti-Semitic.
At a New York Times-sponsored question-and-answer session
for the foreign press in 1987, for example, Mato Sato, a press
officer at the Japanese mission to the United Nations, made
waves for daring to ask Jewish New York Times Foreign
Editor (later Executive Editor) Joseph Lelyveld why the Times
covers "so many Jewish stories" and "how many Jewish editors are
employed at the New York Times?" Sato apparently did not
realize that asking such questions are forbidden and considered
"bizarre" (to use Lelyveld's description of them) in American
society. Lelyveld responded, said the Jewish Week, by
saying "that he was unaware of employees' religious
backgrounds." (This is a curious response for someone whose own
father is a rabbi). [ATLAS, J., 6-7-2000] (Lelyveld was
appointed to be Executive Editor by the Times 'Jewish
owner Arthur Ochs Sulzberger in 1994, following in that position
fellow Jews Max Frankel -- 1986-1994 -- and A. M. Rosenthal --
1970-1986). Mina Joffe, the wife of an Israeli press officer,
followed up Sato's query with her own sarcastic remark in an
attempt to trivialize Sato's question: "How many blue-eyed
people are employed at the New York Times?" The Jewish
Week reported that the New York Times had not yet
gotten "an apology" from the Japanese United Nations mission for
Sato's unseemly curiosity. [LIPMAN, S, 5-22-87]
Jewish scholar
David Grossman (who coauthored a book with a Japanese scholar
about Japanese "cultural stereotypes" about Jews) noted the Sato
incident, saying that the inquirer's "questions were tactless
and displayed astonishing naiveté, but they were probably not
malicious and the intense reaction he received bewildered
Japanese observers, who failed to understand what he had done
wrong." [GOODMAN, p. 10] (Meanwhile,
while Jews and Israel are institutionally protected from
examination of their collective power in the mass media,
economic, social, and political worlds, it is apparently no
problem for anyone that Marvin Wolf wrote a book in recent years
entitled The Japanese Conspiracy, that Daniel Burstein
wrote Yen! Japan's New Financial Empire and Its Threat to
America, or that Pat Choate called his own work Agents of
Influence: How Japan Manipulates the American Political and
Economic System. At least two of these three authors are
Jewish: all three surnames can be found in Jewish surname
databases. In Burstein's case, he links Japanese self-identity
to Hitler's Master Race concept and even mentions the Japanese
reporter's inquiry [about how many Jews work at the New York
Times and why there were so many articles about Jews] to be
an example of Japanese anti-Semitism). [BURSTEIN, D., 1988, p.
72-73]
Sato might
well have asked the same questions about the Jewish stories in
the Washington Post. A Jewish scholar, Barry Rubin, notes
that
"Three of four main articles in
the July 22, 1990 Washington Post
features section were about
assimilating Jews who had made widely
different choices -- Andrew Dice
Clay [Silverman], Sandra Bernhard,
and Allen Ginsberg. That
newspaper's October 18, 1992 reviews
section is full of books by or
about Jews: on sports and the American
Jewish
experience; a biography of Bill Graham, a Holocaust survivor
and leading rock and roll
impresario; the story of a upper-class New
York family infected by
anti-Semitism; a South African woman's group
portrait of her set of Jewish
friends; a Jewish couple's volume on
foreign investments in America,
analyzing problems of multiple
loyalties and foreign influence
paralleling issues in assimilation; and a
Jewish author's book on politics
in higher education, discussing
multiculturalism in terms drawn
from the integration of Jews into
American society." [RUBIN, p.
xiii]
Earlier, Rubin (whose specific
interest is declared to be Jewish assimilation into American
society), notes that
"An author knows a subject is
compelling when it seems omnipresent.
For
example, the April 1991 Vanity Fair contains four
relevant articles
concerning Alfred Stieglitz,
scion of a rich German Jewish family who
founded art photography in
America and wed Georgia O'Keeffe;
Lady Mary Fairfax, whose family
migrated from Poland in the 1920s
and who became a powerful press
lord and doyenne of Australian
society; Charles Feldman, head
of Famous Artists Agency and the
great love of Jean Harlow; and
the actress Ali McGraw, whose
Hungarian mother would never
admit to being Jewish." [RUBIN, p.
xii]
Of course the American mass media is
regularly flooded with stories about Israel. As Doug Bloomfield,
"former chief lobbyist for AIPAC, the pro-Israel lobby on
Capitol Hill", remarked:
"If E.T. had
stayed in the U.S. and read the New York Times, the
Washington Post, or the
Christian Science Monitor, or had watched
the network news instead of riding
around in bicycle baskets, when
he finally returned home and they
asked him, 'What is it like on
earth?' -- the first thing he would
have said is, "There are three
superpowers. There is Israel and two
others." [STARR, J., 1990, p. 33]
The Judeo-centric world view of film
director Mel Brooks suggests, increasingly, a useful paradigm in
analyzing the Jewish entertainment world. As Andrea Most
observes,
"The humor in Brooks' movies
originate in the idea that everything and
everyone is Jewish -- and it is his
job to reveal it as such. So the oldest
man in the
world is Jewish (The Two Thousand Year Old Man), the
Indians are
Jewish (Blazing Saddles), Sherwood Forest's Merry Band
is Jewish (Robin
Hood: Men in Tights), the past is Jewish (History of
the World),
and the future is Jewish (Spaceballs)." [MOST, A., 1999,
p. 337]
In the Arab-Jewish political field,
in 1985 American media reports were swamped with stories about
the horrible death of wheelchair-bound Leon Klinghoffer, an
American Jew murdered by Palestinian ship hijackers of the
Achillo Lauro. Yet, notes Israeli Amnon Rubenstein, "In the
aftermath of the hijacking, the United States media covered his
death in great detail ... The same week, Alex Odeh, a United
States citizen of Palestinian descent who was the West Coast
Director of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, was
murdered by a bomb explosion [later attributed by the FBI to an
act of terrorism by the Jewish Defense League]... Odeh's death
was virtually ignored by the national media." [RUBENSTEIN, A.,
p. 157]
"The truth
of the matter," said novelist Truman Capote on the Johnny Carson
Show in 1973, "... is the entire cultural press, publishing ...
television ... theatre ... film industry ... is almost 90%
Jewish-oriented. I mean, I can't even count on one hand five
people of any importance -- of real importance -- in the media
who aren't Jewish. Here's this God-damned Jewish mafia working
tooth and tong on the New York Review of Books, the
New York Times, whether they're doing it consciously or not.
And mostly they're doing it consciously." [FORSTER, p. 108-109]
Needless to say, Capote's public comments are mainstays
in Jewish-written books about Anti-Semitism.
In 1988 John Hohrn, a Black official
at the Mississippi film commission, was assailed by the
Anti-Defamation League and other Jewish groups for the following
comment:
"You hear people say, 'Well, that's
civil rights -- that story's been told
already.' But no one has questioned
the right of the Jewish community,
which controls the media, to retell
the story of the Holocaust." [JEWISH
WEEK, 1-15-88]
ADL attorney Betsy Ross denounced
Hohrn's clause about Jews to be "obnoxious ... This person needs
an education. His comments about Jews controlling the media is
completely inaccurate. It's an age-old anti-Semitic canard."
[JEWISH WEEK, 1-15-88, p. 33]
This
"anti-Semitic canard" of Jewish media dominance has held
credence, albeit discretely, in some pretty high places.
According to the memoirs of H. R. Haldeman, President Richard
Nixon's Chief of Staff, during one closed door session with his
boss, "there was a considerable discussion of the terrible
problem arising from the total Jewish domination of the media
and agreement that this is something that would have to be dealt
with." [NEW YORK TIMES, 5-18-94, p. A19]
Nixon's vice-president, Spiro Agnew, even spoke publicly about
Jews and the mass media, complaining that the American media
"was unduly influenced by Zionist opinion ... All you have to do
is look around and see who owns the networks, who owns the
Washington Post ... the New York Times ... As you
look around in ... the big news business you see a heavy
concentration of Jewish people." [VOLKMAN, p. 104]
Even when Richard Nixon signed with Warners to
write his memoirs, the people (including his press secretary)
who arranged the deal were almost all Jewish:
"The price, according to the agent,
Irving 'Swifty' Lazar, would be
$2 million. Lazar met with William
Sarnoff and Howard Kaminsky
of Warners
Communications and Nixon's former press secretary,
Ron Ziegler, and sealed the deal
with handshakes." [BAGDIKIAN, p. 34]
In the
entertainment world, country singer Dolly Parton was forced to
apologize to the Jewish community for telling Vogue
magazine that "everybody's afraid to touch anything that's
religious because most of the people out here [in Hollywood] are
Jewish and it's a frightening thing for them to promote
Christianity." TV personality Kathy Lee Gifford (whose own
father -- Epstein -- was Jewish) also publicly apologized for
complaining that "they're changing who crucified Jesus," during
a TV show that discussed recent New Testament changes.
[ROSENFELD, p. 61] "When the NRA
[National Rifle Association] exercises political power," noted
Jewish journalist Philip Weiss, "it's a hot-button issue. When
Jewish money plays a part [in politics], discussing it is
anti-Semitic. If you say anything about [Jewish power in]
Hollywood, you are shouted down." [WEISS, p. 32]
In 1990, Giancarlo Parretti, an
Italian financier (with alleged links to the criminal
underworld) complained to an Italian newspaper that "the Jews
have ganged up on me ... The fact is that the Jews don't like
the idea that I represent the first Catholic communications
network ... There isn't a single [media] holding company in the
world that isn't in the hands of the Jews." [TUGEND, T, p. 37]
Parretti was widely attacked for
anti-Semitism for this statement. The Los Angeles Times
quoted a "veteran Hollywood leader" as saying that "it's one
thing to note that many prominent figures in all aspects of
Hollywood are Jewish and always have been. It's quite another,
however, to make hostile statements on that fact." "As an
anti-Semite," said another movie executive, "I don't see how he
could ever function in this town." Rushing to Parretti's defense
was Yoram Globus, a Jewish co-President of Paretti's Pathe
Communications Corporation (which had earlier taken over the
Canon Group, owned by the Israeli-born Globus and his
cousin Menahem Golan). "There is not even an inch," proclaimed
Globus, "of anti-Semitism in him." [TUGEND, T, Hollywood,
p. 37]
In 1994,
William Cash's aforementioned comments in Great Britain's the
Spectator about Jews controlling Hollywood drew widespread
attack and publicity. Both the New York Times and
Chicago Tribune featured prominent articles about Cash's
speaking the unspeakable in a distant overseas publication. The
Toronto Star even joined in with a headline proclaiming,
"Anti-Semitic Article Shakes Hollywood."
[TORONTO, p. C4] A group of Hollywood actors wrote a letter to
the Spectator accusing Cash's piece of "racist cant" and
"anti-Semitic stereotypes." Jewish author Neal Gabler, in
condemning Cash's ideas of excessive Jewish power in Hollywood,
told a Jewish newspaper that Cash was "only contrite to the
extent that he feels he has damaged his career -- which of
course he has. [Cash was a Hollywood-based reporter for London's
Daily Telegraph.] I can't imagine anyone [in Hollywood]
wanting to meet with him after that article." [CENTURY, p. 1]
This danger of Cash losing his entire journalistic
career, of course, is the paradigm for the reason that those who
know well Jewish dominance in the mass media cannot give public
voice to the fact.
Among those
formally complaining directly to Cash's regular employer -- the
aforementioned Conrad Black, owner of the Daily Telegraph
-- was Britain's powerful Jewish Board of Deputies
lobbying body. Not only does Black own the Telegraph, he
also owns the Spectator, the journal in which Cash's
offending article appeared. Jewish omnipresence in the mass
media is so great that even the editor of the Spectator
itself, Dominic Lawson, was Jewish -- the son of former British
chancellor Nigel Lawson. [WOOLF, p. 1]
For Cash's simple telling of the truth, Rabbis Marvin Hier and
Abraham Cooper of the Los Angeles Simon Wiesenthal Center
charged the sensationally absurd libel that the British author
"has actually plagiarized a page from the playbook of [Nazi
theorists] Julius Streicher and Joseph Goebbels ... fanning the
flames of bigotry and genocide." [RICHLER, p. 32]
Referring to
the Vanity Fair article addressing 16 Hollywood media
moguls that Cash used as reference in his own piece, apologist
Gabler -- author of a book on (in his own words) the "Jewish
invention of Hollywood" -- complained that those 16 "are not
predominantly Jewish at all. Only nine of the 16 are Jewish."
When the (Jewish) Forward pointed out that Gabler's own
books focused predominantly on Jews, he responded, "What I'm
interested in are the figures who shaped popular culture in the
20th century, and because such a disproportionate number are
Jewish, the subject inevitably arises." [CENTURY, p. 1]
Richard Neuhaus
in the National Review pointed out the craziness, and
even sinister intent, of the Jewish Cash crucifixion:
"Some Jews have ratcheted up to an
almost painful degree their antennae
for the
detection of anti-Semitism. A few months ago, the New York
Times went ballistic when
the London Spectator ran a little article on the
self-described dominance of Jews
in Hollywood. The somewhat naive
Spectator author thought he
was doing nothing more than reporting
on interesting circumstances; as
it turned out, he was in large part
relying on what Jewish writers had
said about Jews in Hollywood. The
young man did not understand that
non-Jews are not supposed to
notice when Jews publicly
celebrate Jewish influence and success. As
anyone familiar with the large
role of Jews in American history knows,
the large role of Jews in American
popular entertainment goes back to
the nineteenth century and, far
from being a secret, has been frequently
extolled in film and song. With
weeks of letters and commentary in the
Spectator, our British
cousins had great fun with this little squall,
chalking it up as yet another
instance of American hypocrisy about our
professed devotion to free
speech." [NEUHAUS, p. 52]
British journalist Charles Cummings
noted that